3 ms·
The term "virtue signaling" has always confused me. Doing anything is better than doing nothing. I suppose you think California is doing nothing though. Regard
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
The term "virtue signaling" has always confused me. Doing anything is better than doing nothing. I suppose you think California is doing nothing though.
Regardless, I prefer seeing "virtue signaling" over "vice signaling" — for example: "Drill Baby Drill".
- paisawalla 4y ago> Doing anything is better than doing nothing. Reading the history of man shows that the opposite is many times true.
- crackercrews 4y ago> Doing anything is better than doing nothing Not if it distracts from accomplishing things that actually matter. Think about plastic straw madness. They take up very little room in landfills. By volume they make up very little of ocean waste. And if you get a plastic straw at a restaurant that isn't on the beach, it is hard to even imagine how it would get in the ocean. Yet society moved mountains to stop using plastic straws. What is the cost of creating these mostly-unnecessary alternatives? What could people have done with their time that would have been more productive? The costs of virtue signaling are real.
- JKCalhoun 4y ago> Yet society moved mountains to stop using plastic straws I have not seen that to be the case, but how would I know mountains were moved. Was this a fad on TikTok or something? Regardless, hard to see how that somehow distracted from doing something that really matters.
- theklr 4y agoThat was not a virtue signal nor demand. Media picked up cute kid asking to do good, companies found away to reduce costs for their profits. Most states and cities banned plastic bags, but the straw was corporate greenwashing
- freddybobs 4y agoRight. The claim of "virtue signalling" makes a pejorative from an activity that is virtuous of all things. If the point is to question the reasoning behind the act, the act is still virtuous regardless. If the problem is it won't work well or well enough, how strange that typically no plausible better path is never suggested. Well other the implied - do nothing.
- ralusek 4y agoVirtuous regardless? What does that even mean? To go with the quintessential virtue signaling example: If someone says "black lives matter," what are people meant to make of that? I know the snarky response is to say that it means that "black lives matter," but what does that really mean? Decoupled from any course of actions being prescribed, for the majority of people that statement is synonymous with saying "I'm a good person." This is why many people, irrespective of political affiliation, are somewhat disgusted by others publicly signalling their support for Latest Thing™. If the context in which you say something is virtually consequence-free, you're saying something so in line with the moral zeitgeist of the time, and virtually nothing will change as a consequence of you saying it, people will be often be disgusted. To get to the equally important part of what you said, though, is that > the act is still virtuous regardless. If the problem is it won't work well or well enough, how strange that typically no plausible better path is never suggested There are a few things wrong with this statement. If a guy goes to a "pussy hat" march with the intention of getting girls, are you confident in calling that "virtuous regardless?" The virtue of a thing is often inextricably linked to the motive, and you're dismissing motive out of hand. Secondly, you're saying that no better paths are suggested. Let's go back to BLM and try to map that onto a suggested course of action. When the subset of people who say those words mean something beyond "I'm a good person," they will often say them to mean "defund the police, adjust all systems so that they produce outcomes proportional to racial populations (irrespective of inputs), bring race to the forefront of all interactions and identities." You seem perfectly content to write that off as just a universally virtuous course of actions. You also seem perfectly content suggesting that no alternative has been suggested. Well here is my alternative: "Equip all police with mandatory use body cameras, remove loopholes through which they're not held accountable for breaking the law, remove race as a parameter for any decision making process, de-emphasize race as much as possible for all interactions and identities." It's the near polar opposite. TL;DR 1. Virtue is linked to motive in many (most) peoples' analyses. 2. Actions are rarely, if ever, universally regarded as virtuous, or the proper course of action
- ralusek 4y agoVirtue signaling is typically used to mean one of a few things. These are my own rough definitions: "Saying virtuous sounding things without any intention of acting in accordance with those virtues." (I don't think that's what's happening here) "Saying virtuous sounding things that are so in line with the virtues of the zeitgeist that they take no moral fortitude to say." I think that this is closer to what they meant. It's not necessarily a valid criticism in this case, but I hope you understand how people could find it off-putting when people signal their virtue in the couple of ways I mentioned.