8 ms·
Biden cancels $10k in student loan debts
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoBiden has successfully moved the 10k in student debt from the people who received an education and moved it to the general population at large. A review of this appears to state that it will by far benefit the mid-level income/high-income (up to 125k/250k) earners the most. This puts the burden of this on low income earners and introduces additional income during a time of historic price inflation. I have no idea what I can say.
- codefreeordie 4y agoConsider the party affiliation of the people who receive the money and the people who will be paying for it, and all will become clear.
- IceMetalPunk 4y ago> Biden has successfully moved the 10k in student debt from the people who received an education and moved it to the general population at large. $10,000 / 10,000 people is only $1 per person. That illustrates the benefits of shifting costs to "the population at large" from the "individual alone".
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sgerenser 4y agoIf everyone in the US gave me $1, I’d be a multimillionaire, while all you guys would only be out a dollar! Who wants to go first?
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoAre you spending that money on (a) food or medical treatments to survive, (b) mortgage/rent, or (c) an education to improve yourself and the society we share? If so, then sure, I'll go first, if you can prove that's what you're using it on. In fact, I spend far more than $1 a year doing exactly that. It's called donating to charity.
- mikece 4y agoHow is it fair that people who got degrees with borrowed money they cannot pay back are to have that burden moved to blue collar workers who went to trade schools or other forms of apprenticeship where they never incurred such debts? Yes, this burden will also fall in high-earners -- both those who did and didn't go to college -- but in proportion it will hit lower-earning tax payers the hardest.
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoIt's fair because the "burden" is much, much less when dividing across an entire population, and education shouldn't be made available only to people with stuffed bank accounts and rich parents. It's fallacious to think of this as the full impact being transferred to other people. The cost is being transferred, but it's being spread over many, many people, which lowers the impact on everyone.
- sul_tasto 4y agoIt’s not fair because it doesn’t solve the root college affordability problem. What about the students graduating a year from now and beyond?
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoNot solving the entire problem doesn't mean it's unfair, it just means it's a step in the right direction on a longer journey. Policies like this are a first step towards policies that apply to future generations. If this can show that forgiving loans retroactively -- all the student loans from decades past that are still being repaid -- is feasible, then forgiving loans proactively for future graduates, which is much less cost, is definitely feasible.
- brnaftr361 4y agoIt's definitely unfair. I'm currently in college as a non-traditional student who worked my ass off to avoid the debt trap and socially invalidated myself for a half-decade to do so - now not only is my savings dwindling because of price inflation but I'm also being excluded from this one-time forgiveness. I get no benefit from this, nada. I could've pulled loans and speculated on this - I did in fact expect this to happen - but I believe in personal accountability. Instead of entering the workforce ahead the way things are culminating it looks like I'm going to be entering into it indebted because of shit like this. The only fair move was to remediate the system, this is only going to exacerbate everything already in motion, worse for me, worse for my peers, worse for those forgiven. It does nothing to improve the outcomes of those in the future and everything to worsen them. It's a stupid move to buy votes.
- melling 4y agoThe taxpayer cost is around $300 billion dollars. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/student-loan-forgiveness-10000-cost/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/student-loan-forgiveness-10000-... The next time we question if the science projects are worth the cost… Webb Telescope cost: $10 billion CERN particle accelerator cost: $5 billion
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoremind me how much is american military budget?
- codefreeordie 4y agoOnly about double the cost of today's giveaway
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agothat is yearly, this one i assume is one time
- codefreeordie 4y agoWhy would you expect this to be only one time?
- melling 4y ago$800 billion. Sort of emphasizes the point that the science projects are cheap. Science pays future dividend.
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoScience definitely needs a bigger budget. There's some interesting math to do here: if the number $300 billion is an accurate estimate of taxpayer cost, and the quick Google I did on the number of taxpayers in the US is correct at 144.3 million, then that means the average cost to an individual taxpayer is about $2,080/year. Which is 1/7 the cost of my own university/student loan expenses, even after financial aid, grants, scholarships, etc. My local public college is $2,800/year. In other words, if these numbers are all correct, then the cost to each taxpayer is less than the cost of public college, and much less than the cost of private universities. And when you consider that students at more expensive universities are more likely to have larger student loans, it shifts the average costs being paid off higher, meaning taxpayers are paying much less than people going to college would need to pay. Obviously this is a simplification, and there are things to consider such as how this is covering everyone who's ever been to college in the US before and hasn't finished paying their loans (as opposed to just the people with new loans, which a policy like this would eventually settle into being).
- immigrantheart 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- krapp 4y agoIf only Americans could be radicalized against the systemic inequities in their society and the suffering it causes to their fellow citizens, rather than be radicalized against attempts to correct them, because doing so is unfair to the privileged. Ah well. Have fun becoming the Joker I guess.
- immigrantheart 4y agoI really can’t fathom your way of thinking. Evil, I don’t know what else to say other than this word. Evil.
- krapp 4y ago
- immigrantheart 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- the_only_law 4y ago
- immigrantheart 4y ago
- windows2020 4y agoSo, the government got involved in student loans, encouraged people who should have entered trades to get irrelevant degrees, significantly inflated the cost of tuition, and is now not only rewarding poor decisions and debt, but is making others pay for it? This is egregious vote buying during a period of high inflation! And who making $125K needs a $10K discount on their loans!? A friend intentionally stopped paying his a while back in anticipation. What a joke.
- IceMetalPunk 4y ago> So, the government got involved in student loans, encouraged people who should have entered trades to get irrelevant degrees, significantly inflated the cost of tuition, and is now not only rewarding poor decisions and debt, but is making others pay for it? If 10,000 people pay $1 each, none of them have any problems. If one person pays $10,000, it's a big problem, and possibly even life-ruining or inaccessible. "Making others pay for it" is a skewed perspective on what's really happening when taxes pay for public services, or services that should be public. Speaking of "should be public" -- who are you to decide whether other people "should have entered trades" instead of attending university? Many people don't attend higher education because they can't afford it, and you're basically saying that means they just should go straight to work and shouldn't even try to get an education? > And who making $125K needs a $10K discount on their loans!? A friend intentionally stopped paying his a while back in anticipation. What a joke. If your friend was affording his payments, then it sounds like your friend is a selfish dick. To answer your question: many people. I'm not at $125k, but I left college with $60k in debt, and I didn't even attend the top tier of costly schools, and I had grants to lower that amount. I'm making $80k now, and if you compare those numbers, it might seem like that's no big deal -- 80 > 60 after all, right? But then you subtract income taxes, and my disposable income is actually closer to $52k. Then you subtract my expenses which are more important than paying off student loan debt -- food, water, electricity, phone bill, mortgage, and internet (which I need for my job at least) -- and account for interest accrual... I'm 7 years out of college and I'll be paying those loans for at least another decade or two. So the answer is "probably quite a few people", especially when you consider the correlation between better university education (i.e. more expensive) and higher-paying jobs.
- legitster 4y agoInflation is already debt forgiveness. Since my subsidized loans had interest well below inflation, I decided to pay the absolute minimum possible payment on them for last 9 years. In that time, they have lost 37% of their real value just through inflation alone. I always felt bad for my friends who insisted on paying off their loans as soon as possible. And now, mine are about to disappear completely for free!
- codefreeordie 4y agoIn today's society, working hard is always a bad investment. The more you work, the more you create, the more punishment accrues to you. The way to a happy and successful life today is to make sure never to work hard at anything so that you qualify for all the goodies
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoAh, yes, the American Dream: success is all about hard work, therefore unsuccessful people just aren't working hard enough. So the only people who benefit from policies like these are irresponsible people who didn't work hard enough and now want "goodies".
- krapp 4y ago>Inflation is already debt forgiveness. No matter how many threads you say this in, it isn't going to be true.
- crhulls 4y agoIt is implicitly true. There used to be an informal social contract that the dollar had value, that the government would protect this value, and that there would be a free market that would provide a time value of money. Governments, businesses, individuals and reckless borrowers of all stripes - not just students - have been massively rewarded by our current policies from both the left and the right where there is no longer accountability. We make money free so the market doesn't crash. This is so sad and leads to the cynicism and distrust so many of us have towards our institutions today.
- tester756 4y agowhat the hell are the responses here? in my country edu is free unless you want to study on weekends (so you can work during the week) people shouldn't have to get into debt to get higher edu (and very often not even at top1 institutions)
- notch656a 4y agoThe debt didn't go away, your country just shifted the cost onto someone else other than the person currently studying.
- tester756 4y agoYet that small difference in direct vs indirect cost makes huge difference for the individual
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoNo, to be more accurate, it shifted the cost onto many other people. And that's an important distinction, because when you divide a large number by a large number, you get a small number. Think of it with this simplified example, using numbers that are easier to grok. Let's say I've got a school where tuition costs $1,000. Alice cannot afford that on her own. But there are 1,000 people in her country, so if taxes paid for that tuition, each person only needs to pay $1 extra in taxes for Alice to get a quality education. Of course, it's not just Alice going to college, but it's also not every person in the country. In fact, at any given time, most taxpaying people in a country are not attending university, since university is usually only 4-6 years and most people live to age 78 or higher. So to adjust the example to account for that, let's just assume every member of this society of 1,000 people attended or will attend university (an overestimate for sure). Using the ages as a guideline for proportions, if 60% are above age 18, and at most 8% are currently in college (6 years at college / 78 years of life), then we can easily see how much each taxpayer must pay for everyone to get an education: (80 people * $1,000) / 600 taxpayers = $133-ish. So you tell me which is a better society: one in which everyone gets a good education for about $130, or one in which some people can't afford a good education because it costs about 7.5x as much money?
- grapescheesee 4y agoI regret paying my loans off as quickly as I could. Should have just made the minimum payments and waited for my bailout. Where does personal responsibly even start anymore? I would like retroactive payment to the tune of $10,000. I delayed buying a house, or a new car, and several other indulge items; so I could be debt free. Nothing about this is for people. Its deeply political and fails to address any of the actual issues with higher education in the US. A while ago I worked in retail while going to school. One of my coworkers purposely stayed below the poverty level so she could receive free government support. She also only had another 8 years before her loans would be forgive at the 20 year mark by maintaining a lower income. During the part of the year she wasn't working she would backpack around India on money she saved.
- immigrantheart 4y ago
- SubaruIAUbuntu 4y agoIt’s incredible how negative these comments are. This is not a significant burden on taxpayers, this is a relief to those that need it. If you are seeing this news and reacting negatively, it’s time to step back and think about the bigger picture. The US wastes an incredible amount of money though corruption, inefficient budgets, programs, and poor taxing, all while frequently bending to corporate and wealthy individuals’ interests. This forgiveness program is far from perfect but it’s the best attempt in a while of large reaching positive impact for normal people. Nobody should be claiming this solves the underlying issue of the price of education, but it acts as a bandaid for people still suffering from their debt. It is a good first step and shows relatively good faith. The $10k-$20k is great for those that get it, but the big benefit is the limits placed on interest for loans that are otherwise crippling people. It is clear this is to buy peoples votes for midterms, but it’s also following through on promises made repeatedly to the public. Why would you not wait to make an action as impactful as possible? There are plenty of good faith arguments saying that this action is not enough or doesn’t solve the problem directly, but it’s ridiculous to oppose such an impactful plan that is genuinely giving relief to people that need it. If you’re stuck on how high the limit is (125k single / 250k married), it’s also important to remember that the cost of living varies wildly between different parts of the US. There are too many arguments in both good and bad faith to refute, but overall this is having a good impact on a lot of people. If this doesn’t affect you, or you just paid off your loans and feel bitter, it’s important to remember that you have overcome an obstacle that many people don’t have the same privilege of overcoming for whatever reason, and just be happy for them to have a win for once.