7 ms·
Why women receive less CPR from bystanders (2018)
- elil17 4y agoEasy solution: train more women in CPR. Also, many airports now have CPR training stations where you can practice on a dummy while you wait for your flight. Please try one, I found it very informative!
- petercooper 4y agoEarly days on this one: "researchers asked 54 people online to explain, with no word limit, why women might be less likely to get CPR when they collapse in public" .. though at least they did use VR to attempt to measure behavior, but concluded: "a study with more participants is needed to statistically identify any significant gender gaps" It doesn't seem surprising though. We've had stories in the UK where young children have wandered the streets for hours with no members of the public wanting to get involved because of the attitudes around stranger danger.
- 2000UltraDeluxe 4y agoUnfortunately, it's quite expected. I don't want to get into the debate about whether any of it is true or not, but I believe most agree that lot of the current online narrative either demonizes men or claims that fake sexual harrasment claims are commonplace. It's not hard to see why being bombarded with such messaging on social media would lead to some people responding to it.
- 42e6e8c8-f7b8-4 4y agoDo you disagree? There is no "innocent until proven guilty" with sexual harassment claims-- it's mostly "off with their head!" and no ability to defend oneself or present or argue evidence. You're tainted for life, regardless of the truth of some situation. Why shouldn't sexual harassment claims be feared?
- Balgair 4y agoNit: In the UK the burden of proof is on the defendant by default. Innocent until proven guilty is a US thing.
- petercooper 4y agoI don't think I'd even point the finger at online narratives. I think the behavior we see in day to day life has a bigger effect on how we also behave in public. But maybe I'm being optimistic!
- gsibble 4y agoAs I just said, I've been a party to and witnessed over a dozen entirely fake sexual harassment claims (those are just the ones where I was there when said harassment was said to have occurred when it didn't). I've actually seen more fake claims than real ones in my life (sorry). So I wouldn't point the finger at online narratives either.
- gsibble 4y agoI've been accused of fake sexual harassment. So have most of my friends. I actually think the internet underestimates how frequently it happens.
- claudiawerner 4y agoI'm interested in whether the available statistics from law enforcement underestimate how frequently it happens - and how one could possibly find out.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- panarky 4y agoI have never been accused of sexual harassment, and none of my friends or family have been either. It seems statistically unlikely that you and most of your friend group have all been accused of sexual harassment if your behavior was unimpeachable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hnfong 4y agoYou seem to be proving the GP's point.
- dtx1 4y ago> It doesn't seem surprising though. We've had stories in the UK where young children have wandered the streets for hours with no members of the public wanting to get involved because of the attitudes around stranger danger. Who would have thought that publicly considering every male to be a (potential) sexual predator would have negative consequences? In any case if you are male and ever in a situation where you consider helping someone but don't because you might be considered a perv or a creep, look for another, preferably female adult and involve them in the effort of helping.
- petercooper 4y agoIn any case if you are male and ever in a situation where you consider helping someone but don't because you might be considered a perv or a creep, look for another, preferably female adult and involve them in the effort of helping. I would hope if the situation were grave enough, the instinct to help would just kick in regardless. Like if a kid were hit by a car, most people will want to help if they can. It's the less grave 'grey area' situations where I think people hesitate (which could well include someone in cardiac arrest or maybe having a fit) and teaming up with other strangers seems like a reasonable compromise.
- dtx1 4y agoI was thinking about the little girl lost on the street crying. I've been screamed at for walking the same path as a woman and her child mostly because I was male. Always better to have a preferably female Witness with me.
- blitzar 4y agoWhat incentive is there to help at all given the univeral perception of society is that a male who renders assistance they must be, at best a pervert or more likely a 'pedo guy'. "Teach your child to go to a woman if they are lost. Why? First, if your child selects a woman, it's highly unlikely that the woman will be a sexual predator."
- 4y ago
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoAlso why men can't work at daycare centres. It is sad one pedo can spoil it for every male.
- petercooper 4y agoHere in the UK it's not unheard of, and especially in elementary education there has been a bit of a push to have more male teachers (all my kids have had at least one). The only flat-out ban I've personally experienced is all my kids are dancers and men are forbidden from being backstage chaperones at the shows. Luckily, I don't want to be one.. :-D
- panarky 4y agoMy kids' daycare lets moms and dads volunteer, but only moms help kids in the bathroom. Not because they think the dads are abusers, but because it's far less likely that the moms are abusers. Seems like a strong policy backed by evidence, and both moms and dads support it.
- petercooper 4y agoWhat I'd call an actuarial approach. It's tricky, though, because it can be interpreted as discrimination. For example, here in the UK young women used to get cheaper car insurance than young men, but this was outlawed – https://www.choose.co.uk/news/women-car-insurance-costs-to-soar.html https://www.choose.co.uk/news/women-car-insurance-costs-to-s... (and in an amazing display of transparency, the head of a major insurer said: "As an insurer, I'm pleased. We will raise rates for young women: we won't bring them down much for young men. That means more profit").
- nopehnnope 4y ago
- Overtonwindow 4y agoI can’t say for certain how I would act in such a situation, but I like to think I would provide CPR regardless of gender. However I can certainly see the point that a man would be very hesitant to provide aid to a woman in this…time of easy misunderstanding.
- Syzygies 4y agoOne never knows till one is in the moment. I watched a wave grab a child. As it happened we both came back out, but it was neither or both, that's how we're wired. As a professor one of my students had a seizure then stopped breathing, during one of my exams. There were fifty students closer to her than me, yet somehow I found myself giving aid, as everyone else either dialed 911 or swooned "there goes my professor!" There was that second where all these thoughts went through my mind, but then she started breathing. As for false accusations, there's a principle that accusers should understand but don't: NEVER assume you're the craziest person in the room.
- xeromal 4y agoYeah, that instant reaction is very primal(?) for everyone. Everyone has ideas but most of the time your higher level thoughts aren't even operating. It's just instinct. I was on a plane once where a man donned a helmet and knee pads and attempted to open the door to the outside. I'm know that is an impossibility in the air, but instinct says stop it. Several men charged the guy and held him down until the flight touched down but it was interesting to see the reactions from various people.
- psyc 4y agoAs a former outdoorsman I’ve been in situations where I had to rush to a potentially critically injured near-stranger, and other situations where I was startled by a large wild animal, and as far as I can tell it’s the same response. My rational mind simply disengaged like a clutch, and it was barely even informed of what I was doing until minutes later. My memory says my body was moving without my help. I’m usually the one who’s calm and troubleshooting like a robot while others are freaking out, but when the brain decides it’s time for an adrenaline flood I believe that trumps every other thing.
- hprotagonist 4y agoFor the obvious and purient reason. Semi-related reasons at least partially explain why the AHA moved away from rescue breaths as part of CPR: they found high rates of total noncompliance because people don’t want to do that. Compressions only turns out to both be fine from a perfusion perspective and also increases bystander participation. I think not taking any breaks for breaths during compressions also reduces clotting, but i’m not sure. The other reason to not bother with rescue breathing is that AEDs are everywhere now and you’re much more likely to get pads on someone promptly.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AnonC 4y ago> The other reason to not bother with rescue breathing is that AEDs are everywhere now This is a very bold claim that needs a citation with data covering different locations and the number of devices per unit population.
- hprotagonist 4y agoI'm speaking slightly casually. Access to AEDs has expanded in public areas of the region of the world where AHA guidelines for CPR pertain so much that it is reasonable to expect prompt availability to one in the case of sudden cardiac arrest in public, and this has driven updates to CPR guidelines. Better?
- pilom 4y agoCounterpoint, I'm a whitewater rescue instructor. My students and I are much more likely to see drowning victims than heart attack patients. Compression only CPR doesn't help drowning victims at all so we've had to add a "don't listen to your CPR instructor, do rescue breaths first" statement to our classes.
- hprotagonist 4y agoYep, drowning (and cold water drowning in particular) gets special rules. And a better save rate, iirc…
- closewith 4y agoEdit: Unwanted attention
- tokai 4y agoI really lack this angle from their studies. In their later study they conclude that: "Likewise, said Perman, people need to be assured it's OK to touch a woman you don't know if you are helping someone who might otherwise die" But that only holds if the risk of getting in trouble is not real. But they don't spend any energy figuring out if this barrier to CPR is imagined or real.
- dvfjsdhgfv 4y agoThese two angles are not mutually exclusive.
- tokai 4y agoYou'll have to explain yourself. What is not mutually exclusive?
- dvfjsdhgfv 4y agoThe fact that random bystanders and experienced staff in certain situations both have reservations about giving CPR to women.
- elil17 4y agoI would argue that, even if you will be falsely accused of a crime, you have a moral obligation to perform CPR because that accusation is so unlikely to go anywhere. I'm sure people make accusations, but from a Google search I can't find any cases where someone was actually arrested or charged for that. It's hard to imagine police or prosecutors not believing that defense, especially given that there would be medical evidence of cardiac arrest.
- michaelmcdonald 4y ago
- tokai 4y agoThis lacks a year in the title. They continued their research, with their next study having +500 participants. It's mechanical turk participants though. https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.142.suppl_4.139 https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/circ.142.suppl_4.139
- MichaelCollins 4y agoWhen people believe society doesn't trust them, they'll be less likely to stick their neck out for others. Even if the perception of mistrust is illusory and not backed up by any data, that perception of mistrust will still dissuade altruistic behavior.
- benj111 4y agoI wonder if CPR training dolls were to made female, whether that would improve matters? It would at least force you to deal with the question of breasts during training.
- incone123 4y agoAt least one major brand does exactly that. https://laerdal.com/gb/doc/2404/Resusci-Anne-QCPR https://laerdal.com/gb/doc/2404/Resusci-Anne-QCPR
- molotovh 4y agoResusciAnnie has been the gold standard CPR mannequin since at least the early 90s when I first learned CPR at my local fire station. In fact, I don't think I've ever seen a CPR mannequin that wasn't based on Annie.
- hackeraccount 4y agoI always thought it was resussannie ?
- throwawaysleep 4y agoThere is no emergency where I touch an unconscious woman or get involved with a child where I do not trust the parent. I don’t even think I would be willing to get involved unless I trusted the witnesses. I’m a socially awkward guy, so if there is a problem I lose by default. So unless it is friends and family, I don’t know anything medical.
- bayofpigs 4y ago
- hoseja 4y ago, now lie in it.
- bone_frequency 4y agoI specially agree with the two first reasons listed in the article. I do have certified first aid and CPR training but the wellbeing of my family comes first, I am not going to get charged with attempted rape and/or cancelled because I wanted to be a good samaritan.
- elil17 4y agoI've done a lot of searching after reading this article and I couldn't find a case where a man was charged with a crime or canceled for performing CPR or using an AED. The closest I could find was this case in Japan, where someone was let go by police the minute he told them he was using an AED (https://japantoday.com/category/national/man-revives-woman-with-aed-but-branded-pervert-for-removing-her-clothes-to-apply-electrode-pads https://japantoday.com/category/national/man-revives-woman-w...).
- xeromal 4y agoIt doesn't matter if there is evidence or not, if statistically, women are treated less the issue is real and there needs to be a social/public push to make it appropriate. There needs to be a law similar to good Samaritan that allows for men to touch women during CPR without fear of reprisal.
- elil17 4y agoThose laws exist in almost every state, where Good Samaritan laws specify that consent to CPR is implied if a victim is unresponsive. Consent is implied for children who are unresponsive if their parent is not present. https://americancpr.com/blog/tag/good-samaritan-act-good-samaritan-law/ https://americancpr.com/blog/tag/good-samaritan-act-good-sam... States should add those laws where they are absent and clarify them where they are vague.
- xeromal 4y agoThanks for this!
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoMy personal perspective is that if you are performing CPR on me and saving my life, you're forgiven if you want to touch my junk, steal my watch or accidentally break a rib.
- Markoff 4y agoSexual harassment accusation? Edit: So as I thought: "In the replies, the team identified four themes: Potentially inappropriate touching or exposure; Fear of being accused of sexual assault; Fear of causing physical injury; Poor recognition of women in cardiac arrest -- specifically a perception that women are less likely to have heart problems, or may be overdramatizing or "faking" an incident; or The misconception that breasts make CPR more challenging."