5 ms·
While I understand and agree with the sentiment you express, I don't agree with using the word "magic" to refer to it. I believe that in the minds of most peop
by tsimionescu 4y ago
While I understand and agree with the sentiment you express, I don't agree with using the word "magic" to refer to it.
I believe that in the minds of most people, the notion of magic essentially means the ability to use willpower to modify physical laws, or at least that physical laws are ultimately a product of a conscious will (often the will of a God, not a Human - but still a will that can be pleaded or bargained with through prayer or ritual).
And in this sense of the word, science has utterly destroyed magic. Not only is it impossible to extend your will to the world, it turns out that it is in fact the conscious will itself that is subordinate to physical laws, not the other way around - or at least this is what science is currently strongly hinting towards (we would know for sure if we had a much deeper understanding of the workings of the brain, and how consciousness arises out of it).
It's important to realize that this is vastly different from what scientists/philosophers throughout history have generally believed - even upto fairly recently, some form of Descartes-like dualism, with a mechanistic physical universe and a non-mechanistic spiritual universe of the mind (and God) being the most common way of picturing the world among most scientists even in the 1800s or later.
- rileyphone 4y agoNow, once we get proper brain-computer interfaces, the real magic begins.
- ntr-- 4y ago> And in this sense of the word, science has utterly destroyed magic. ahh good, so which interpretation of quantum mechanics is correct?
- tsimionescu 4y agoHow is that relevant? All interpretations agree on the math, and the math leaves no room for consciousness in the equations of motion.
- eurasiantiger 4y agoSomehow we are still claiming that the system is fundamentally random when it is very obvious it is fundamentally deterministic (but not predetermined).
- dandelany 4y agoIt’s not obvious at all at the quantum scale. Nothing we’ve seen indicates that eg. the timing of the decay of a single particle, or the ability of a single electron to escape an energy well is deterministic, though they are easily predictable in aggregate. What does “deterministic but not predetermined” mean?
- eurasiantiger 4y agoIt means that like in Game of Life, the rules are set, but the outcome at any timestep is not determined until the simulation reaches that timestep.
- tsimionescu 4y agoI'm not sure what this has to do with consciousness. We can go into the details of what various interpretations of QM mean for determinism vs indeterminacy (e.g. MWI implies that there is fundamentally no randomness of any kind at the universal level, and everything is predetermined, but also every possible outcome will happen; Copenhagen implies a kind of epistemological randomness - the outcomes of measurements are random, and it's meaningless to talk about anything other than the outcomes of measurements; Pilot Wave theory implies that QM only has randomness in the sense that Newtonian mechanics already does - we can't measure the starting state well enough to say for sure what would happen, but the process is fundamentally deterministic and peredetermined). However, there are only two possibilities: completely random (nothing can predict or influence which value the wavefunction will take after collapse) or fully determined (what you're eating for lunch today could be predicted by studying the initial state of the universe at the time of the Big Bang). There is currently no room for any other possibility in physics.
- smegsicle 4y ago> the notion of magic essentially means the ability to use willpower to modify physical laws so the harnessing of nuclear power was not due to willpower..? and of course reality is dual- otherwise what is mathematics made of? or how is anything similar to or separate from anything else, without some out-of-band judgement?
- tsimionescu 4y ago> so the harnessing of nuclear power was not due to willpower..? Let me put it like this. We know that we can use water to grow vines, harvest and ferment grapes, and make wine. However, we still see Jesus/God turning water into wine as a magical event. Harnessing nuclear power is like turning water into wine by using it to grow grapes. We have discovered that certain materials have the property that they become very hot in certain conditions, and we can use our willpower to move our hands and feet to build machines that do this. But magic refers to us (or some other being) using its willpower to achieve such effects directly. Just like you or I can will our hands into moving, a wizard or god can will the seas into parting. > and of course reality is dual- otherwise what is mathematics made of? or how is anything similar to or separate from anything else, without some out-of-band judgement? What is a Linux made of? Ultimately, it is some configuration of fundamental fields that defines it, either in a computer or in our brains. Now, did Linux, or Pyhtagoras' theorem, exist immediately after the Big Bang? In some sense, you can say that they did, because a hypothetical sentient being would have been able to formulate them just as much as we can today. But then, in this sense, the Empire State building also existed at the time of Big Bang. In a much more concrete sense, no - these things only started existing when they were thought up or built by some human minds, and in this sense the copy of Pythagoras' Theorem in my mind is just as much a physical object as Linux is on my phone and as the Empire State building is in Manhattan.
- liber8 4y ago>>the notion of magic essentially means the ability to use willpower to modify physical laws<< It's interesting that this is how you defined magic, because in a very real sense the ultimate purpose of most science is precisely to use our willpower to modify (what we previously believed to) physical laws. Physical laws prevent human beings from flying, or breathing underwater, or viewing individual atoms. Until we literally used our willpower to design machines to overcome these "laws." I have no doubt that eventually our collective willpower will be used to modify other "laws" we believe today, like the law that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. Pretty magical if you ask me :)
- implements 4y agoThe “laws of nature” aren’t proscriptive (decrees on the order of nature as commanded by a divine superpower), they’re descriptive - observations about related phenomena that appear (or are theorised) as being universally true. When humans achieved “heavier than air flight” they didn’t do so by modifying (or subverting) any physical law - they applied imagination to state of the art knowledge of what the laws suggest about reality to create technology that overcomes gravity by harnessing natural phenomena (thrust + angle of attack + properties of air = lift).
- schoen 4y agoI'm going to be prescriptive and say that you meant "prescriptive" rather than "proscriptive". "Prescriptive" means "requiring" or "normative, specifying, prescribing", while "proscriptive" means (more specifically) "forbidding". It has only a negative sense of saying something is not allowed, while "prescriptive" includes a broader sense of specifying or ordaining something in any way.
- implements 4y agoI was going to argue, but, yeah - that makes sense.
- tsimionescu 4y ago> in a very real sense the ultimate purpose of most science is precisely to use our willpower to modify (what we previously believed to) physical laws. I don't agree at all. The purpose of science is to understand physical laws well enough that we may predict how various objects work. Sometimes this allows us to make things that we previously believed impossible possible. Sometimes physical laws and limits turn out to be different than we thought, other times we simply find a better way to work within the same laws we always knew. > Physical laws prevent human beings from flying, or breathing underwater, or viewing individual atoms. Until we literally used our willpower to design machines to overcome these "laws." I don't think anyone has ever believed that one of the physical laws of the universe is "human beings can't fly". We have always known that heavier than air flying was possible (since birds do it). The notion of humans flying (or breathing underwater, or seeing really small things) with some kind of assistance has existed probably since pre-history, but definitely since antiquity - have you ever heard of Pegasus, or Hermes' winged sandals, or flying chariots and such? Airplanes are just a scientific realization of those ideas. > I have no doubt that eventually our collective willpower will be used to modify other "laws" we believe today, like the law that nothing can travel faster than the speed of light. Pretty magical if you ask me :) This is also something you are wrong about. If you look at the progress of science, at least since the 1600s or so, we have almost universally discovered new fundamental limits, not the other way around. Given Newton's laws of motion, we thought that we could reach any speed we wanted to, if only we had the right technology. It was a new discovery that actually speed is limited. We also thought that an object can have any density, until GR showed that past some density, it ceases to be an object in the usual sense (it becomes a black hole). We used to think that energy can vary continuously between any two values, until we discovered that it can only vary by fixed quanta. We used to think that we can measure the position and velocity of an object to arbitrary accuracy, but then we discovered Heisenberg's uncertainty principle. So, as science advances, I'm looking forward to finding out what other thing we currently think is possible will turn out to be impossible.
- kawaiikouhai 4y ago>It's important to realize that this is vastly different from what scientists/philosophers throughout history have generally believed - even upto fairly recently, some form of Descartes-like dualism, This spirit-physical duality is mainstream in the West, however you are reaching when you say that every culture and their thinkers held the same beliefs.
- tsimionescu 4y agoYes, I should have limited that statement to Europe and its (former) colonies.
- zozbot234 4y ago> While I understand and agree with the sentiment you express, I don't agree with using the word "magic" to refer to it. The word is historically accurate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_magic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_magic Prior to the scientific revolution at least, this really is how "tech" was conceptually understood. (This becomes quite clear when considering how e.g. Newton was equally involved in highly "scientific" (by a modern standard) and highly "occult" pursuits. The two would've been essentially indistinguishable at the time.)
- tsimionescu 4y agoI don't claim to have very deep historical or anthropological knowledge, but I have to say I find it hard to believe that there wasn't a separation between "tech" and magic before the scientific revolution. For example, is it really true that people viewed the construction of chariots, windmills or watermills etc as a magical endeavor? I do know that for a long time smithing had a magical mistique around it, so yes, some things we view as technological today were viewed as magical in the past. But the distinction between magic and "tech" I think has always existed.
- pnf 4y ago"And the will therein lieth, which dieth not. Who knoweth the mysteries of the will, with its vigor? For God is but a great will pervading all things by nature of its intentness, Man doth not yield himself to the angels, nor unto death utterly, save only through the weakness of his feeble will."