3 ms·
Not exactly. If all the user wants is a editor. Which generally acts as a cache for temporary text a general user wants to use somewhere else. There is always
by kamaal 15y ago
Not exactly. If all the user wants is a editor. Which generally acts as a cache for temporary text a general user wants to use somewhere else. There is always notepad or wordpad. There is also a word processor called Microsoft Word. Which generally does more than sufficient job. There are sufficient enough alternatives. Emacs can't become notepad just to become usable to general users. Emacs's design case is for programmers who need to do a lot text lifting, execute repeated patterns of complex text editing.
Keeping all this in mind Emacs is designed, to facilitate use of macros and alikes. There are also key bindings to enable short cuts to do that sort of automation quickly. Also there is a huge repository of what the community considers 'common pattern of solutions' to most problems developers face while editing code. Emacs is mean't to provide large gains in productivity while coding for long hours. Notepad is designed for a few minutes of use by a user. Vim is optimized on similar line of Emacs, but in a different usability case, which is also awesome and serves some users pretty well.
Also we already have drag and drop programming to a very large extent these days. Most people working on SAP, and package based solution don't see code in years. But they actually do a lot of programming. In most mega corporations there are business units, where there are consultants, who do a lot of domain logic coding by mere button clicks on GUI. You will surprised how many large number of people are actually with that sort of a thing these days.
Not to mention armies of Java programmers. If auto complete weren't to be there how many Python and Java programmers and their supply in the industry will actually scale? Given the verbosity and configuration hell I doubt even half of that would be possible. Even the mere existence of those programmers is dependent on the existence of eclipse. Remove away eclipse today, and you will see the supply of Java programmers will fall by 90%. Even those 10% available programmers will suffer a massive decline in productivity.
We are already in the drag and drop era. We are just not realizing it. Since we are doing it in different ways.
- crucini 15y agoWould you really group Python in with Java? I find it reasonably compact. True, there is an unfortunate tendency to drag java-style thinking into Python. I write python with vim; so do most of my co-workers. (But then I also write Java with vim (when I have to write Java))
- kamaal 15y agoI wouldn't group Python with Java, But I would group a bunch of programmers common to Python and Java. Python attracts the same major group of programmers as Java because it has a very low barrier to entry. It has all the qualities that you would need build a army of programmers. But unfortunately that quality also has a downside, you tend to get a lot of people who need tools and stuff to help them overcome their personal shortcomings. If you make the tool very easy for novices sure you will get a lot of novices, but they won't really like to take the extra step beyond those initial steps. This is also the crowd that is in love with verbosity. Verbosity in every thing, code, configuration etc. Because it helps them to write more than they think. Whereas ideally you must be thinking more than your write. Unfortunately Python belongs to the former school of taught. Good to know you develop Java applications with vim. I don't see that as a very productive thing for the rest of the world. They are better off using eclipse.
- agentgt 15y agoThe whole Java configuration hell stereo-type is kind of getting old. Its really not true anymore (have a look at the play framework). Although I do agree Java is verbose and you defiantly need an IDE to edit it that doesn't mean other less verbose languages could not benefit from an IDE. If you really want to play the Ivory Tower of condescension you need to attack the army of PHP programmers and there love of string manipulation of SQL statements.
- dextorious 15y ago"""Not to mention armies of Java programmers. If auto complete weren't to be there how many Python and Java programmers and their supply in the industry will actually scale?""" I don't think I ever used autocomplete with Python. And I don't know many who do, either. You really believe many Python users use something like the Eclipse python mode? Except for the "tokens in the same file" autocomplete that Vim and such editors offer.
- Erwin 15y agoAfter 10 years in Emacs I've switched to PyCharm (for about 100 EUR). Its autocompletion feature are quite decent (aided by specifying types in docstrings but otherwise it does whole-project type deduction) and I use them frequently. It has many time saving features -- like real time "pyflakes" like warning, automatic import management (when I type time.strptime it warns me about time being undefined -- would I like to import the time module?). Only downside is that it can get sluggish in large file on this 5-year old processor.
- bfrs 15y agoauto-complete.el does a great job for Python in emacs. To install it check out: http://bfrsblog.blogspot.com/2011/10/making-emacs-first-class-python-ide.html http://bfrsblog.blogspot.com/2011/10/making-emacs-first-clas...