2 ms·
Imagine you had a drone that could dive to the ocean floor, pick up a chunk of rock, fly up one foot above the deck and drop the rock, then fly back down and re
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Imagine you had a drone that could dive to the ocean floor, pick up a chunk of rock, fly up one foot above the deck and drop the rock, then fly back down and repeat
That would take a ridiculous amount of energy.
- kragen 4y agoIf we suppose we have to stack 100'000 more tonnes of rock on top of a 100'000 tonne displacement aircraft carrier to sink it, and the ocean is 2 km deep at that point, it takes about 1.96 terajoules at 100% efficiency. At 46 MJ/kg that's 43 tonnes of gasoline. That is a ridiculously small amount of energy to sink a carrier; it's maybe a large gas station. Of course the question is open: how efficient would the rock-stacking drones be? If they're 50% efficient the scale of the operation is different than if they're 0.05% efficient.
- CamperBob2 4y agoSeems that energy will need to be expended in both directions, given that you're working in the opposite direction of the usual diving practice where a weighted diver sinks to the bottom and releases ballast to come back up. Is that being accounted for? Also, I imagine somebody will notice this rock-stacking activity at some point over the (days? weeks?) it will to swamp the aircraft carrier, and take care of the problem with plain old birdshot. Or just a bunch of sailors with brooms or fire hoses. Failing that, just cruise away from the drone swarm. They'll run out of gas long before the carrier runs out of U235.
- kragen 4y agoIt's easier to change your buoyancy by releasing ballast, but that's not the only option, or the best option in this context. You can instead adiabatically expand a vacuum space (for example, in a cylinder with a piston) against water pressure to go from negative to positive buoyancy. 100'000 tonnes is 100 million kg, so for a million drones it would be 100 dives. I agree that stacking rocks on the deck of a carrier, or even gluing or magnet-clamping them to its hull, is probably not the most effective way for drones to damage it. Firing birdshot at sailors, for example, would be more effective; blinding them with lasers more effective still. The point is that even ridiculously primitive attacks become effective when you multiply them by enough orders of magnitude.