4 ms·
Source: https://itep.org/whopays/ https://itep.org/whopays/ Edit: The report does not include tolls, but I would incorporate tolls into taxes also, especiall
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
Source:
https://itep.org/whopays/ https://itep.org/whopays/
Edit: The report does not include tolls, but I would incorporate tolls into taxes also, especially for lower income groups. One can easily spend $1k to $2k per year in tolls in the Northeast, and I know Texas is quite heavily tolled in some areas as well.
Edit 2: The ITEP report also does not incorporate the effects of property tax laws in CA which give people who purchased land earlier and their descendants a much lower property tax liability (proportionally) than people who purchase land later.
- Apocryphon 4y agoI originally thought the cause of this would be a principle akin to how the U.S. spends more per capita on healthcare compared to countries with socialized systems, but looks like the study says the reason is regressive tax systems focused on consumption (sales and excise) taxes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rconti 4y agoSo does it just average property taxes? That would mean it underestimates the tax burden of a new homeowner in CA relative to TX, but after 8 or 10 or 15 years, overstates the property tax burden of a CA homeowner relative to TX.
- Apocryphon 4y agoProp 13 would probably keep the CA property tax burden understated.
- Aunche 4y ago>PROPERTY TAXES, INCLUDING BOTH TAXES ON INDIVIDUALS AND BUSINESS TAXES, ARE USUALLY SOMEWHAT REGRESSIVE. On average, poor homeowners and renters pay more of their incomes in property taxes than do any other income group They are very wrong about property taxes, which calls their entire analysis into question. Renters aren't the ones paying property tax, especially for expensive areas like SF. The savings property taxes from prop 13 absolutely does not get passed to the renters. If anything, it does the opposite because it disincentivises home sales.
- Apocryphon 4y agoAren't rental prices influenced in part by property taxes. Surely the owner would want rent to cover both their mortgage and their tax.
- caylus 4y agoIn general yes, but I think Prop 13 complicates matters, because it's not just a lower tax rate, but rather applies unequally to different properties based on their transaction history. (e.g. a property built or sold recently gets high taxes, while one that's been unchanged remains low) So we can divide the rental market into high-tax and low-tax properties. The landlords of high-tax properties must incorporate the tax into the rent. Meanwhile, the landlords of low-tax properties can set their rents just as high, since they compete in the same market, and pocket the tax difference. In contrast, a flat property tax reduction would increase the profit margins of all landlords equally, and any one of them could start undercutting the others and be undercut in return, which over time in an efficient market will tend to lower prices back to a similar margin before the tax reduction.
- jltsiren 4y agoIt's primarily an indirect effect. Landlords won't buy/build new houses if the expenses would be too high relative to the rent the market is willing to pay. That lowers the supply and raises the rents in the long term. However, if you have an existing property, there are no guarantees that you can find a tenant who is willing to pay enough to cover your interest, taxes, and other expenses.
- larsiusprime 4y agoThere's good empirical evidence that the portion of property taxes that falls on the unimproved value of the land (ie, the location's value minus the value of the building), is not passed on to the renter: http://gameofrent.com/content/can-lvt-be-passed-on-to-tenants http://gameofrent.com/content/can-lvt-be-passed-on-to-tenant...
- UncleMeat 4y agoRenters pay property tax indirectly because most landlords select rents high enough to cover their mortgage, insurance, maintenance, and property tax.
- bdcravens 4y agoYes, it's easy to spend $10 a day on tolls just driving around Houston unless you're intentional about avoiding them.
- SllX 4y agoGood point about the tolls. So in Northern California, if you cross the Bay Bridge or the Golden Gate Bridge as part of your daily commute—assuming a 5 day/week workweek in the office for historical purposes but as a caveat, this may be inaccurate in the present—you can easily spend between $1500 and $2K/year in bridge tolls. BART is also an option, but is in the same ballpark at about $1500-1700 depending on how many days of the year you work and that’s assuming a West Oakland to Embarcadero commute so it only goes up from there if you live and work further from those stations. Maybe you end up not having to pay for parking on the other side though if you live near the station, although some people end up having to pay for parking at a BART garage. Transportation is expensive.
- cozzyd 4y agoYes but you don't pay for gas/maintenance/depreciation/accident risk you take BART. At the IRS rate that works out to about $5/day just for the length of the Bay Bridge, not including any extra driving on either side. Driving is expensive.
- SllX 4y agoWell yeah, like I said: > Transportation is expensive.