4 ms·
I read the full whistle-blower complaint, and the whole story from his perspective (and the crazy statement from Agrawal) looks like it's not B. Instead, it lo
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
I read the full whistle-blower complaint, and the whole story from his perspective (and the crazy statement from Agrawal) looks like it's not B. Instead, it looks like it was a culture clash with his manager.
He seems to have tried to escalate things to people above Agrawal nearly constantly. He was hired by Jack Dorsey, and felt accountable to him and to the board, but he reported to Agrawal, who believed that Mudge had a responsibility to follow the chain of command very rigidly.
I have previously had managers who want you to rigidly follow the chain of command, and if you are a "hacker" type, they are a shock (and you are a shock to them). They are often very interested in controlling information that goes upward and how mandates flow downward through them (both to control their reputation and make sure everyone gets information in "proper context"), to the point that they see it as an attack on their position to even speak with their manager. A "hacker" would rather put the information in front of the people who need it, instead of filtering it through the hierarchy.
At the first opportunity Agrawal had to clean house, he cleaned out Mudge because he didn't want to work with him. House cleaning is normal for a new CEO. From Agrawal's perspective, Mudge did a terrible job, since he wanted to circumvent Agrawal.
- pueblito 4y ago> He was hired by Jack Dorsey, and felt accountable to him and to the board, but he reported to Agrawal, who believed that Mudge had a responsibility to follow the chain of command very rigidly. With $10mm cash bonuses on the table it’s extremely obvious why Agrawal would insist on being MITM
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWhen you think your job is to tell your boss's boss (and their promotion committee) why your boss is doing a bad job, you're not in for a happy time.
- barking_biscuit 4y agoWhich sucks because plenty of times it's true.
- leaflets2 4y agoWould Agrawal get cash bonuses? If ... Under what conditions? (Anywhere to read about that?) Aha, eg: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10258453/Twitters-new-CEO-Parag-Agrawal-paid-12m-bonus-make-changes-faster-Jack-Dorsey.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10258453/Twitters-n... So his performance bonuses is more than 10x his salary - incentives to fake good numbers and hide the bad stuff, indeed!
- jonstewart 4y agoI wouldn't paint with too broad of a brush in this instance, however. Yes, mudge is the ur-hacker, but also: he worked at BBN and DARPA (where he was extremely effective) and elsewhere. He probably has the most experience of any technical/hacker on the planet of working with executives in large organizations. Agrawal's memo, in contrast, reeks of insecurity. The combination of how he's treated mudge and Rishi Sunak and the potential consequences of this complaint (particularly if FTC investigates and finds Twitter has not been following the consent decree) boxes him into a corner -- he won't be able to recruit the talent to solve these security problems and will be seen as an impediment to compliance/mitigation. I could easily see the FTC et al insisting on his resignation as part of a settlement. It's an own-goal.
- crb 4y agoWhat's the story with Rishi Sunak? Assuming you mean the candidate for Conservative Party leader and thus UK PM, I wasn't aware of such a connection.
- groby_b 4y agoRinki Sethi. OP meant Rinki Sethi. (CISO of Twitter until January, left at the same time as Mudge)
- jonstewart 4y agoOh, yes, thank you! I can't edit my comment anymore, but, yes, Rinki Sethi, apologies for the confusion.
- ginger2016 4y agoThank you for the clarification, this got me confused too!
- colechristensen 4y agoA security lead who didn't try to raise major issues around a bad boss would be doing a bad job.
- 4y ago
- Maursault 4y ago> I read the full whistle-blower complaint The content of the complaint is all that matters, and it should be judged on its own merits. It never matters who said what, and attempting to make it matter is ad hominem fallacy; it is what is said that matters. That said, I can't quite fathom why Twitter's cybersecurity matters any more than the cybersecurity of any of the myriad of online forums, HN included: the "data" simply isn't all that important; it is all public, it is all talk, and talk, as we know, is cheap. Say Twitter is completely overrun by foreign state actors who delete everything. The outrage is going to be minimal. "Dang, I really enjoyed mouthing off on Twitter. Oh, well."
- leaflets2 4y ago> Say Twitter is completely overrun by foreign state actors who delete everything. That's not what's dangerous. Instead, dangerous things include manipulating the algorithms so that "news" of ones choice get lots of visibility. Then a foreign state can influence the elections
- Maursault 4y ago> Then a foreign state can influence the elections I think this is bollocks. 23% of Americans say they use Twitter. 61% of Americans voted in the last Presidential election. So with my bad math, say a foreign state somehow gets every possible Twitter users vote going their way, at best it's going bamboozle 14% of weak-minded Americans. That's at best, the perfect and unbeatable score. The reality is that most Twitter users are not obsessed with the platform, and most Americans are not on the fence with their votes. This concern is not really supportable.
- leaflets2 4y ago14%, even just 4%, is a lot, can be enough to decide an election. Often the parties are close to 50% each. In addition to that, the manipulators / nation states don't attack only via Twitter, and, everything combined ...
- _vdpp 4y ago
- trasz 4y agoI guess the basic question to be asked here is how come nobodies like Agrawal get to make decisions like that.