4 ms·
> Meanwhile we have had no problem sourcing candidates since we can pull from anywhere in the world, we have some incredible people all over the world that we w
by lm28469 4y ago
> Meanwhile we have had no problem sourcing candidates since we can pull from anywhere in the world, we have some incredible people all over the world that we would not have gotten otherwise.
How do you handle taxes ?
For example in Europe a German company can't hire a French dev if the german company doesn't have a legal entity in France, it quickly gets out of control both in term of paperwork and cost. The dev can't be a freelancer because a freelancer with a full time, fixed hours, single customer is illegal in many places
Also let's say you have an American company with 200 german employees but no office on german soil, does that mean they don't pay any local tax because technically they don't operate their business in the country ?
I feel like a lot of loopholes which were seldom used will promptly be closed once they become widely used
- bearjaws 4y agoWe use a service called Deel, but we are US entity and that helps in many cases. Essentially they have companies in most countries and you pay them (deel) directly and then they payout to your staff. This also simplifies benefits for healthcare, taxes, retirement. If you find it helpful, heres my referral code https://deel.com/referrals/Michael-n53jPEZJ https://deel.com/referrals/Michael-n53jPEZJ
- andrewingram 4y agoHow are preferential equity schemes handled? i.e in the UK, best case tax rate on equity is 10%. But if you're not on government-approved scheme, you'll get taxed at around 55% in the event of a meaningful exit. When I've raised this previously, the point has been dismissed as "45% of lots is still lots", but if you're doing an expected returns calculation and considering other jobs (like a large well-paying org with RSUs) it becomes quite meaningful.
- lm28469 4y agoWhat happens when an employee is fired or quits ? Does he qualifies for unemployment benefits ? And who pays for it ?
- vladvasiliu 4y agoIt probably depends on the local laws, but here in France, such a company would employ you and pay all the taxes that go with your employment contract, like social security, health insurance, unemployment, etc. Unemployment benefits are paid by the state, through the taxes that are levied on those who are employed.
- jcims 4y agoI feel like this will continue to evolve until we get something akin to virtual countries, where I pay fees/taxes into some virtual substrate that manages my access to services regardless of where I am.
- lm28469 4y ago> where I pay fees/taxes into some virtual substrate The thing is that you're supposed to be tax where you live to finance the public infrastructure you use, pension schemes of locals, &c. I know a few of wantrepreneurs who live abroad, bill under an Estonian "e company" , don't pay taxes locally and on top of that illegally get unemployment benefits from their home country This trend has to cease and with the new "remote first" mentality I can imagine it won't stop anytime soon
- jcims 4y agoSure that happens today, in part because it's so painful to 'do the right thing'. I stayed in San Diego for a month last year and didn't pay a single penny of income tax to the city. Meanwhile my home city was paid for my income and I was a lightweight customer during that month. I think the idea would be something along the lines of creating virtual citizens that live in the locality and meet all of the obligations of the locality, and the company just handles swapping the association of these citizens to real people when the time comes. So then when you show up with your passport from Roamatopia all of the paperwork has been done to make sure you are pulling your weight. Obviously this can be gamed as well but I like the idea.
- ghaff 4y ago>I stayed in San Diego for a month last year and didn't pay a single penny of income tax to the city. States are starting to crack down on income taxes for non-residents working there. Obviously in many cases they have no way of tracking but if you're there on business (and have expenses), Concur for one offers companies an audit service. The rules vary by state but if you spend enough time in a state and pass some threshold you can be on the hook to file income taxes. (A lot of the original impetus for these sorts of laws was to tax entertainers and pro athletes.)
- cube2222 4y ago> The dev can't be a freelancer because a freelancer with a full time, fixed hours, single customer is illegal in many places. In many countries where that's the case, it's fine if the company you're freelancing for is foreign (IANAL). Because as you say, there's no other simple way to do it. Though you can also use services like remote.com.
- arijo 4y agoI thought services like remote.com would help solve those problems ..
- vladvasiliu 4y agoI have a friend who's physically in the UK and works for a US company. I was interviewing for a remote job in the UK while being physically in France. In both situations, the setup is a local company (possibly self-owned) that bills the actual company. So you're not UsCorp's employee, you're an YourOwnCorp employee, and UsCorp is YourOwnCorp's client. This way, all taxes and related issues are handled locally. Sure, there's overhead, but from what I've seen it's worth it.
- lm28469 4y agoHow do you deal with health insurance, pension, unemployment benefits, &c. ? Sounds like a massive headache
- vladvasiliu 4y agoIt isn't, really. Sure, there is some paperwork to set everything up. But once that's done (and you can pay someone to do it for you), it's pretty much smooth sailing. The biggest "hassle" is closing the accounts for the year and sending them to the Administration, and those have to be signed off by an actual accountant. But this takes like 1 hour per year, it's not that bad. Regarding health insurance, etc you can either get your own, private one or have it bought by the company. It's the same thing if you're a full-on employee: if you're not happy with the coverage the employer has, you can get your own on top of it. When you're your own boss, you can choose what you want straight away. All this may vary depending on the type of company you set up (there's no such thing as "freelance" as far as the law is concerned). This will also have an effect on pension – if you only pay yourself in dividends, there's no pension. Sure, there are a few things to be taken care of, but if you invest a few days and do your research, it's a good tradeoff. The other approach, as siblings said, is to use some kind of "shell company" that does this for you. But from what I've seen, their cut is ridiculous, so it's absolutely not worth it. NB: this comes from France, but I expect the situation to be roughly similar in other countries.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- cossatot 4y agoI work for an Italian nonprofit from the US, after I moved back from Italy for family reasons. I'm a full-time contractor. I (or my 'employer') have to prove to the Italian government that I am a US taxpayer, but beyond that it's fine, and at least from my perspective much easier than dealing with the Italian government otherwise (those who know the language and system may feel different of course). I am very happy not to be throwing a huge chunk of my paycheck into the Italian pension system since I have never intended to retire in Italy, so it was simply a gift to the government of those lovely people. I'm not sure how much variability there is with this kind of setup within EU member countries. Also let's say you have an American company with 200 german employees but no office on german soil, does that mean they don't pay any local tax because technically they don't operate their business in the country ? The American perspective on this is that the employer pays employment taxes for their employees (but not contractors), and the employees/contractors are responsible for their own income taxes, wherever they work (US or abroad). Surely the German employees would report and pay their income tax? Taxes are not a tithe to the Church. They are not a moral obligation. They are a payment for past, present and future government services. If you (or your family) are not receiving services from that government, then you shouldn't be obligated to pay them. Pay for the services from your own government. It is good to question how much of the tax burden should be paid by employers vs. employees, but the idea that some tax burden is split by different parties in different nations is not a new one. For example, international trade has been occurring for as long as nations have existed. There is no shortage of precedent to draw from. The dev can't be a freelancer because a freelancer with a full time, fixed hours, single customer is illegal in many places This might actually be what may changes rather than the 'closing of loopholes'. From what I have understood after talking with German in-laws, these laws are nominally to prevent the abuse of workers who are denied the rights and benefits of full employment. From a workers' rights perspective, this makes sense for 20th C. laborers, but not really for 21st century knowledge workers who could be getting paid >2x working from Germany for an American company compared to what they would be able to get working domestically. So in practice, this type of law can keep wages lower and give more control to German companies at the expense of the workers, so you know who will fight the changes to the laws to preserve the status quo. But if tech/knowledge workers who wish to have better remote employment opportunities can band together to pressure their elected officials, then this could change.
- badpun 4y ago> For example in Europe a German company can't hire a French dev if the german company doesn't have a legal entity in France, it quickly gets out of control both in term of paperwork and cost. They can - they just have him as a contractor, not a permanent employee. Source: I'm a Polish contractor contracting for a German startup.
- lm28469 4y agoBut then you have no job security, pension, &c. which is like half of the benefit of working for a wester EU country
- badpun 4y agoAs an entrepreneur (contractor) in Poland, you get free state-provided healthcare. You're also paying mandatory contributions to state-provided pensions (equivalent of US social security). It's true there is no job security, but in return you pay 17% in total tax burden on your income and not 40-50% you pay in Germany. The rates are also much higher than full time salaries, so in the end you take home probably twice what your German colleagues take, while having a fraction of their costs of living. Do that for 10 years and you end up with $1 million in the bank, which is enough to retire early in Poland.