4 ms·
I switched from an XPS 13 to an M2 Air recently. The differences are striking. I have my XPS 13 browsing HN next to my M1 air. That's all the XPS is doing, f
by duxup 4y ago
I switched from an XPS 13 to an M2 Air recently. The differences are striking.
I have my XPS 13 browsing HN next to my M1 air. That's all the XPS is doing, firefox browsing HN. My M2 has multiple docker containers, a collection of office apps open, browsers, vs code... and so on.
My XPS battery will barely last until 1pm if it isn't plugged in, and the fan kicks on for no apparent reason... It will last a little longer if I manually set it to "best battery life" but even that can be surprisingly ineffective for no apparent reason sometimes.
My M2 Air will last nearly two full working days (I haven't pushed it that far but so far it appears it would make it), the battery life is crazy. I go into the office and I don't even think about plugging it in, I know it will do fine.
I don't know what it is about macOS and using their M chips but the efficiency is amazing to me.
I even had a docker container freak out on my Air recently. It pegged a CPU core to 100% for a good 45 minutes. Temp skyrocketed. But I was on another virtual desktop and I didn't notice a thing. The OS ran smooth, vscode, node and everything else was running smooth. It wasn't until I looked at the status bar that I saw the CPU and temp had skyrocketed. I found the container responsible, killed it, and temp dropped quickly. Even under non ideal situations the Air performed well.
With my XPS the moment I put it down I think about where I can plug it in. If I pick up my XPS to quick order some Tacos and it wasn't plugged in from the start I feel like i"m in a race to get the order in "Come on, hold on, I need tacos!!!"
With my Air I don't even think about plugging it in, that's a completely new experience for a laptop for me.
I don't really understand the benchmarks and such that I've seen, but the every day user experience has been like night and day.
- smoldesu 4y ago> It pegged a CPU core to 100% for a good 45 minutes. Temp skyrocketed. But I was on another virtual desktop and I didn't notice a thing. I reckon this is more of a heterogeneous architecture thing than a MacOS/Apple one. When you run a processor-intensive task, Grand Central Dispatch will assign it a relative priority and then, on new M1 chips, delegate the process to a core cluster. While one heavy program runs, another can operate alongside it on the efficiency cores or even another P-core cluster. I've noticed this behavior as well on Alder Lake. There are several times I've booted up Bitwig with something like Elden Ring running in the background, and had no idea it was open while I worked on music.
- duxup 4y agoYeah it could absolutely be something that happens elsewhere outside Appple land. I tell that story more as a sort of indirect mention of some of the internet drama over "throttling" / general user experence rather than a story about what MacOS does. I really don't know what was responsible for everything still running smooth when that incident happened. For all I know Docker on Apple Silicon might be doing something there too to keep things from getting entirely out of hand.
- smoldesu 4y agoDocker does a lot of weird stuff in MacOS, it's totally beyond my wheelhouse. I am glad that Intel/Apple are pivoting to this new architecture though, it kinda reminds me of the jump to quad core systems back in the day. With AMD's switch to heterogeneous designs coming a few years down their roadmap, I'm really curious how they're going to compete. Early Zen 4 benchmarks are wicked scary so far, so I'm pretty excited to see what they come up with. All-for-all though, this next generation of CPUs is going to be awesome. Everyone is finally doing their own thing, and actually getting somewhere: - Intel is working on process enhancement and bumping nodes to make fast, heterogeneous x86 CPUs - Apple is focusing on density above all else, optimizing for a more efficient, streamlined heterogeneous ARM package - AMD is doing things "the old way", with a tick-tock schedule for process bumps and IPC optimizations to their homogeneous x86 CPU - Bonus: there's also a bunch of Chinese manufacturers fighting for dominance over the homogeneous ARM CPU market (mostly for use in servers).
- freemint 4y ago> Bonus: there's also a bunch of Chinese manufacturers fighting for dominance over the homogeneous ARM CPU market (mostly for use in servers). Please tell me more or tell me where i can learn more.
- asdajksah2123 4y agoSnow Leopard (which introduced GCD) looks even better in hindsight.
- GeekyBear 4y ago>If you’ve been following any of my articles about the performance of the cores in M1 series chips, you’ll have come across the term Quality of Service (QoS), which can have major impact on how fast code runs on processors under macOS. In addition to each process being given a priority, a number that can be changed using the command tool renice, some years ago Apple introduced another setting, the QoS. This is set for each process, and can be one of four discrete values from 9 (the lowest, for background tasks) to 33 (the highest, for tasks involving user interaction). https://eclecticlight.co/2022/01/07/how-macos-controls-performance-qos-on-intel-and-m1-processors/ https://eclecticlight.co/2022/01/07/how-macos-controls-perfo...
- kitsunesoba 4y agoThe CPU/SoC's efficiency is likely the core driver behind this difference, but I believe that Windows exacerbates the issue. I recently installed Fedora 36 on my Tiger Lake (i5-1130G7) ThinkPad X1 Nano, and while the machine has never had particularly good battery life, it's more "calm" under Linux on average. Even while setting things up with various things running its fan didn't kick on and it didn't get warm like it typically would under both the Windows 10 installation it shipped with, as well the current upgraded Windows 11 install. Additionally, while I haven't yet actually tested it, GNOME under Linux estimates that it'd get somewhere in the ballpark of 8-8.5 hours out of a full charge when running in "battery saver" mode, which is a good hour or two longer than Windows' estimate in its low power mode. Of course the M-series devices I've used destroy the ThinkPad in terms of battery life, regardless of the OS it's booted into though.
- MaxikCZ 4y ago> Windows' estimate in its low power mode. Am I the only one not bothering with Windows' estimates at all? It will happily tell me I have two hours remaining and shut down after 40 minutes, without me touching the PC at all. I had this or similar experience with every windows laptop I ever used.
- duxup 4y agoI certainly don't trust them. 30% battery life may as well be near death on my windows laptops. As for hours of use in marketing material I wonder what they'll claim when they actually get close to their current estimates? Just lie about it more? How will we know if they're getting close to the truth?
- LoganDark 4y agoMy laptop does a hard shutdown if the battery goes below 95%. It's gotten to the point that I've had to configure it to hibernate at 98%. This is not very nice on the laptop vendor's part. This laptop is less than 2 years old.
- throwthere 4y agoI have a similar experience coming to m1 mba from an xps13. I had some buggy code change monitor/recompiler running that pegged a cpu core at 100%. The palm test would get hot and the battery would go to like 10% after a working day. Those were the only way I knew somerhing was up.
- asdff 4y agoWhat time do you start browsing with the xps? 9 am making it 4 hours or so of life. That's pretty pathetic and it almost sounds like you have some background processes going on that are sinking your battery life and kicking on the fans. I put in a new battery in my 2012 mbp and I get about 6 hours ish browsing a very light website like HN (sinks like a stone on JS heavy websites of course). No fan ramp up either although I pin them to minimum 2000rpm on this computer. CPU stays at 50-60*c according to my fan controller.
- duxup 4y ago7 or so. So longer than 4, but for just browsing IMO it should last much longer.
- tails4e 4y agoI've a macbook pro, 2019. I find office 365 uses 100% of one cpu so reguarly (at least one of outlook, excel or PowerPoint will be acting up) That I get 1.5 hours battery. How does office behave so well for you? The cpu hardly makes a difference there, is the program is cpu hungry battery will be used
- fingerlocks 4y agoDo you have Defender installed? That’s the culprit for me on my work Mac. Keep ‘top -o cpu’ running and look for wdavdaemon blowing up, or just set a cron job to kill it every hour.
- tails4e 4y agoThanks, will take a look out for that.
- duxup 4y agoThat's one thing I haven't installed yet. Just to get up and running quick while I was getting setup I installed the office apps as PWAs rather than go through the application install process and ... kinda left them that way. But doing that they haven't caused any issues. Granted Teams, while on a video conference, will eat battery, but it handles a few meetings a day just fine overall. I should install those apps one day ...