4 ms·
FWIW, I agree most prose works great and think you're right that the technical book experience is where it's most clearly lacking (not being able to quickly fli
by slipperyp 15y ago
FWIW, I agree most prose works great and think you're right that the technical book experience is where it's most clearly lacking (not being able to quickly flip to an appendix or back / forth 5 pages is a big annoyance of mine).
There are ways I think it works poorly for prose, though, too. The most obvious example to me is the George RR Martin Fire & Ice books. When I'm reading those, I very frequently want to flip from a section of the book to the maps of the world described in the book. I read a physical copy of the first two books but went to Kindle (both the 3rd generation Kindle and Android app) for the third and it's tedious to set a book mark, navigate to marks and notes, find the map, and then navigate back to the bookmark. Additionally, the map images in the ebook are of such low quality that they are nearly unreadable. Lastly, there's an appendix of the families represented in these books at the back (who's who). When reading the first two books, I often would consult that, too, but once I'd done that with the Kindle book, it made it really painful to switch back and forth between reading on my phone vs. my kindle, because the "sync" function is "sync to furthest page read" - which is at the end of the book, not my current place in the book.
All of the above gripes with that book would be plain to see for anyone who bothered trying to read the book on a kindle - and it should be obvious to the kindle team that "sync to furthest page read" breaks when a book has an appendix / index or something that readers are likely to consult.
- brnstz 15y agoInteresting you mention Fire & Ice, I read the first three primarily on Kindle for iPhone. I did get into the habit of bookmarking my current page to reference the maps and appendix. Generally my biggest problem with "sync to furthest page read" was reading while underground (subway). Usually I just fire up the iPhone briefly so it will sync forward if I want to read on a different device. There is also the "Book Extras" section which, for Ice & Fire, includes content from Shelfari with some appendix info and does not break the furthest page read. It would be nice if the official appendix and maps were included in a similar format.
- slipperyp 15y agoI worked around the syncing but it was tedious. Primarily I would read on my phone on the bus during commutes and want to use my Kindle at home. However, having viewed the appendices of families, I could not simply sync. This was tedious, but less tedious than lugging around that tome :) I think annoyances like that are really about the software, though, and I expect it to continue to get better, though the changes in Kindle have not been on details like that, they've been the library lending thing, getting some free books into prime, and lending. I'd love to see some smaller fit & finish. I haven't noticed the "Book Extras" you mention and will have to investigate - thanks for the tip!