4 ms·
US immigration policies for Indian and Chinese nationals has been a blessing for their home grown tech ecosystem. There is no path to a green card or citizenshi
by paxys 4y ago
US immigration policies for Indian and Chinese nationals has been a blessing for their home grown tech ecosystem. There is no path to a green card or citizenship for anyone who immigrated in the last ~15 years, and the top 5% talent that used to come over by default is now working at or founding companies at home instead. This is directly correlated to the number of tech unicorns in these countries growing exponentially in the same time period (0 in India before 2010, 100+ in 2022).
- dixie_land 4y agoThanks to "consulting" companies' abuse of H1B. We should've just have a stack ranking of H1B candidates, based on income (and severe penalties for regression in comp, so you can't just do it for the visa). This would immediately break companies like Infosys that simply spams the lottery system with bogus applications.
- paxys 4y agoThe current system is in place only because all of the US companies that benefit from cheap labor provided by the likes of Infosys have lobbied for it.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoI doubt it is cheaper at all. H-1B applications must pass the prevailing wage test, i.e. applicants cannot earn less than the prevailing wage for their position at the chosen employment location. Companies like Tata, Infosys, WiPro, etc. need to maintain a part of their workforce in the US for certain projects anyway, so they slave away these applicants with draconian contracts. It's not that they pay them significantly less than any other, but the fact that they can guarantee a 3 to 5 year headcount for their larger US based projects, with a larger talent pool to choose from, if needed.
- geebee 4y agoA shortage at a certain wage level probably indicates that the prevailing wage is too low. So targeted visa programs designed to provide more workers at the prevailing wage can suppress wage growth, which, over time, really is no different from a reduction in wages. This is why a lot of people, like me, favor high levels of general immigration but don't support targeted visas like the H1B. I'm especially opposed to visas that are controlled by the employer and restrict the personal and economic freedom and mobility of immigrant workers in the US. If employers are lobbying for visas that allow someone to work in the US only on the condition that they remain in a specific role at a specific company at a specific salary, that should raise all kinds of red flags. You're allowed to be a software developer in the valley, but you'll be deported if you try to open a small business or enter a different profession or even change employers without new "sponsorship"? I find it remarkable that so many people don't see the egregious problem here.
- kiratp 4y agoI only see one role here that is even ballpark for a SWE in SF. https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=&job=software+developer&city=san+francisco&year=2022 https://h1bdata.info/index.php?em=&job=software+developer&ci... The prevailing wage test fails to account for stock and bonuses and is basically a joke.
- mattnewton 4y agoHow could it not be cheaper- H1B applicants have to perform their jobs virtually under threat of deportation. How are they negotiating for regular raises or stock refreshers in that situation? How often are they changing jobs due to poor working conditions or personal growth if their sponsorship could be jeopardized?
- diebeforei485 4y agoThe previous administration wanted to do this, but it was way too late and they ran out of time to implement it properly - https://insights.dice.com/2021/07/07/trump-h-1b-rule-could-have-raised-visa-wages-now-its-dead/ https://insights.dice.com/2021/07/07/trump-h-1b-rule-could-h... Soviet-style labor lotteries are not a good system. Those "consulting" companies know how to abuse that system.
- 8note 4y agoIt'd be better to have a dedicated tech visa -- h1b handles a wide variety of roles that have different salary ranges
- amf12 4y ago> Thanks to "consulting" companies' abuse of H1B. They found the "loopholes". Given that the system is being abused, the government hasn't made much effort in fixing it.
- spangry 4y agoWhy doesn't the government auction H1B visas? If H1B numbers are capped then they are a scarce resource that should be price-rationed so they are allocated to their most productive use (i.e. to companies that are willing to pay the most). It would also mean more of the gain from bringing over H1B workers would accrue to the public instead of private companies, which would increase public support for immigration.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aprdm 4y agoAnd for Canada
- xuki 4y agoI don't know about India, but China's policy to block US big techs is the reason why China have the tech companies they have today.
- thatfrenchguy 4y agoThere is a path though, you can marry someone who is from any other country but India (even if they are not going for a EB-2/EB-3, have a green card, or are a US citizen). You can cross charge your employment green card to your spouse, some of my Indian colleagues have done this, it’s super rare because of cultural expectations though.
- screye 4y agoYeah sure, let's go ahead and facilitate the 2nd biggest decision of your life (country you work in) by compromising on the biggest decision (marriage) of your life. While dating across cultural groups to find the one, is rewarding in its own right , being that materialistic with your choice in partner is probably going to make for shaky foundations of a relationship.
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago> by compromising on the biggest decision (marriage) of your life. I don’t see how that’s a compromise though? The cultural expectations are just different for folks from India: no parent from France is expecting their kid who decided to move to another country to be with a French person, and 90% of immigrants from India end up marrying another immigrant from India, even if they more to the US in their early twenties.
- screye 4y agoI don't think this matches standard wisdoms. Culturally, 'Western Europe + USA' are more similar to each other than Indian sub-cultures among themselves. In most cases you are interacting with other white people coming from christian cultures. Even the People-of-Color that white people do date tend to be deeply integrated into western culture to the point where they're more culturally white than Indian. In terms of cultural exchange, most of the effort to integrate is being put in by the Indian. (replace Indian with any non-western cultural group). The extent to which the cultural exchange is unidirectional isn't even funny. There isn't a lot of great data on this, but limited dating data tells us that it is actually white people (esp men) who have strong intra-race-dating preferences as compared to Asians or Latinos. [1] [2 Table 3] [1] https://imgix.bustle.com/inverse/be/92/f8/14/fb8b/44a7/9f63/0cc944edfb9b/a-quartz-infographic-exposes-some-uncomfortable-truths.png?w=710&h=806&fit=max&auto=format%2Ccompress https://imgix.bustle.com/inverse/be/92/f8/14/fb8b/44a7/9f63/... [2 Table 3] https://www.mit.edu/~6.s085/papers/racialPreferences.pdf https://www.mit.edu/~6.s085/papers/racialPreferences.pdf
- margalabargala 4y agoFrankly, at the end of the day, this is better for Humanity as a whole. People are coming to the US, learning about technologies, and bringing those back to other countries with plenty of people willing to use them. In the longer term, this will result in more, better technology, all over the world. There will be more net good than if all such technology were concentrated in the US, though the US will have less domestic benefit than it would have otherwise.
- time_to_smile 4y ago> There is no path to a green card or citizenship for anyone who immigrated One thing I find really strange as an American, is that while our immigration system could be improved, in both China and India there is absolutely no way for a US Citizen to get permanent residency. Not "it's really hard" or "takes a long time", but short of maybe being a billionaire or world famous athlete, a non-Chinese/Indian simply cannot permanently immigrate to these countries. It doesn't matter if you marry someone who is a Chinese/Indian citizen, doesn't matter if you have kids with them, etc there is zero possibly you will be able to immigrate to these countries.
- triceratops 4y agoThat doesn't seem to be true for India, at least.[1] People legally resident for 12 years can apply to naturalize. And spouses can just register to get citizenship. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_nationality_law#Voluntary_acquisition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_nationality_law#Volunta...
- SloopJon 4y ago> There is no path to a green card or citizenship for anyone who immigrated in the last ~15 years I'm no expert, but I don't think this is quite right. For an applicant with a bachelor's degree, the cutoff date is February 2012 for India, and April 2018 for China: https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/visa-law0/visa-bulletin/2022/visa-bulletin-for-september-2022.html https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/legal/visa-law0/v... With an advanced degree, it's December 2014 for India and April 2019 for China. Please correct me if my understanding is incorrect.
- digianarchist 4y agoYou're assuming linear progression. The priority date moves forward very slowly. An Indian born person applying for a Green Card today will likely be retired or dead before their priority date becomes current.
- Ao7bei3s 4y agoAdditionally, the chargeability dates can and do move backwards too (search for "eb2/eb3 retrogression"). Make it make sense.