3 ms·
How are marginal sales taxes regressive? Only the wealthy can spend more, so only the wealthy would get taxed more.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
How are marginal sales taxes regressive? Only the wealthy can spend more, so only the wealthy would get taxed more.
- croon 4y agoBecause poor people need to spend a larger portion of their money just to live.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSee https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32563944 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32563944
- whiddershins 4y agoThe poorer you are the higher a percentage of your money you typically spend.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe margin is not based on the percentage of your income/wealth that you spend, it is based on the amount you spend. Like income. For example, $0 to $50k per year spend is taxed at 0%, then $50k to $100k is 10%, etc. Although a continuous exponential function is preferable than discrete cliffs.
- whiddershins 4y agoAre you saying that is how VAT works? Because I have no idea how any could keep track of all that.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoNo, marginal sales tax is not in effect anywhere. Assuming electronic payments, I could see it being relatively easy to track everyone’s spending since bank accounts/credit cards/etc would be tied to tax ID #s. Of course, there are all sorts of issues with possible downsides and jurisdictional issues.
- ironSkillet 4y agoSuppose a poor person makes $20k a year, all of this immediately spent on necessities and taxed, say at 5%. So their net tax rate is 5%. Now imagine a rich person making $200k, spending $100k taxed at 10% because of marginal increases, and saving the rest. The rich person also pays a net tax rate of 5%.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSo you increase the tax rate for higher spending amounts, and/or lower the tax rate for lower spending amounts.
- washadjeffmad 4y agoThat's neolib hoo-ha. Most of society is pay gated, where increasing costs are required in order to maintain your current standard of living or day to day operations. We're living that right now with inflation and supply chain scarcity. The wealthy have what they need and can afford to wait or shop around. The immediacy of need for a one car household to replace their only vehicle puts them at the whims of a highly fluctuating car market. A wealthy household can afford regular maintenance, more reliable cars, or just to Uber around every day. At scale, we can't buy the computer components we need at a price that isn't a huge markup of what we paid three years ago, which either gets passed on to customers or means we have to limit our service offerings. Instead, we're suspending some operations and waiting it out while we rework some designs. We're about as big and wealthy as orgs get and can survive it.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> Most of society is pay gated, where increasing costs are required in order to maintain your current standard of living or day to day operations. The cash benefits tax rates can also be increased. As a rough outline: UBI to ensure minimum quality of life Marginal sales tax to tax luxury purchases more than necessity purchases Estate tax to prevent too wide of wealth gap. The goal would be to incentivize income and disincentivize profligate spending. If one does not want to be at the whims of a highly fluctuating car market, then they have to plan accordingly. But in the worst case, the UBI will be the safety net, and whether or not that means they can afford a car is up to society. > At scale, we can't buy the computer components we need at a price that isn't a huge markup of what we paid three years ago, which either gets passed on to customers or means we have to limit our service offerings. Instead, we're suspending some operations and waiting it out while we rework some designs. We're about as big and wealthy as orgs get and can survive it. I am not sure how this relates, but I think this is getting more into anti trust rather than personal taxes. Either way, I think society should reward businesses (or individuals) that invest in robustness/redundancies/resiliencies.