4 ms·
I don't think a regressive tax would do anything to reverse the growing wealth gap in the U.S.
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
I don't think a regressive tax would do anything to reverse the growing wealth gap in the U.S.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoRegressive taxes are fine if they are offset by a universal cash benefit. The purpose of a tax can be to curb some type of behavior, such as carbon emissions or water usage or road usage. If it happens to be regressive, then that can be solved by giving everyone $x. And then you recoup via marginal income/marginal sales taxes.
- actionfromafar 4y agoAren't "handouts" a hard sell in the US?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYes, I do not expect any substantial movement for wealth redistribution on the federal (nationwide) level.
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoEven if you ignore the resistance to handouts the idea that the federal government in its current state or any reasonably probable future state could pull off administrating said handouts without it devolving into a bunch of special interest BS and partisan bickering and actually accomplish the goal of making a VAT a regressive pain in everyone's butt is just laughable. Look at healthcare spending. Look at social safety nets. Look at defense. Odds are that any spending in an attempt to make VAT less regressive would wind up looking a lot like those and having most of the same problems because it would be subject to the same sets of perverse incentives from top to bottom.
- Wyoming23 4y agoNot really. Every time a new handout gets created, there is a predictable round of complaining from the fiscal conservatives, but fiscal conservatives make up only about 10-15% of Republicans and 3-5% of Democrats so inevitably the handout eventually gets passed, perhaps with a name-change or some token constraint, but then once established becomes normalized and permanent.
- zmgsabst 4y agoYou’re still disproportionately burdening the middle class versus wealthy, causing a bi-modal distribution. A lot of these schemes to “help the poor” in fact “cement feudalism” by destroying the middle class to the benefit of elites.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhy do the marginal rates have to be set to disproportionately burden the middle class versus the wealthy? I would think an exponential function would easily prevent this.
- zmgsabst 4y agoIn the context of sales tax, any politically possible tax is going to burden the middle class more as they spend more as a fraction of their income. Income taxes don’t have that, as they’re a progressive tax. The idea you’ll have an “exponential function” in the tax policy is pure lunacy that’s not politically tractable, though.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoA marginal sales tax is not a tax based on the fraction of your income/wealth that you spend, it is simply based on the nominal amount of spend. Obviously this whole idea is politically impossible as it would result in huge wealth redistribution, but it is funny that with all the technological innovations, a simple exponential function for determining taxes is considered to not be feasible.
- zmgsabst 4y agoYes — the nominal amount spent is a different fraction of their income for different income brackets, leading to a regressive tax. Your final point is a non-sequitur: The objection to an exponential function isn’t the technical complexity, but the behavior of exponential functions. You’re just dressing up “seize the wealthy’s money” in fancy math. Though, you’re also understating the complexity of having such a variable tax and the second order impacts you’re likely to cause. Edit — replying here as I hit my posting cap: We care because our goal is a prosperous society for our citizens, for which we need a robust and active middle class. We don’t exempt those goods from taxes (as we do with the essentials). My point has been that your vision for taxes creates a bi-modal distribution between rich and poor by laying a heavy tax burden on the middle class, until they wither — essentially creating feudalism. A healthy society (with progressive taxes) creates opportunities for the poor to advance their well-being out of poverty by not over-encumbering the path to a middle class life. Regressive taxes are antithetical to that.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoYou're still taking significantly less from the wealthy. Where then is money for the universal cash benefit coming from?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoWhy would significantly less money be taken from the wealthy? You set the marginal rates, or the parameters of the function for determining the marginal taxes equal to however much is needed to cover the costs.
- benj111 4y agoI think the idea is, say the average person uses 100 gallons of petrol a year. You add a $1 tax to each gallon, thereby costing the average person $100 per year, but you give them $100 back. The average person is no better or worse off, but it's an incentive to use less fuel. You could make the argument either way that this fall's more on the rich. They tand to have more bigger cars, bit then you could argue that the poor have older less efficient cars, but it isn't really aimed at wealth. I suppose the key is that any party can arrange their lifestyle to avoid being worse off.
- colejohnson66 4y ago> The purpose of a tax can be to curb some type of behavior, such as carbon emissions or water usage or road usage. They're to collect money for the government so that it can do things (or just sit on the money if you're a king). King George didn't tax the colonies because he wanted them to stop doing things; he did it because he wanted the money. In more modern times, a government raises taxes to pay for new roads or whatnot. Using taxes as punishment is just a nice benefit that the government can wield.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThat is why I wrote “can be”. For example, variable rate tolling. Free to drive on an empty road in the middle of the night, but very expensive during peak traffic times to reduce chances of gridlock and incentivize spreading out demand to non peak times, or disincentive using the road period.
- ImPostingOnHN 4y agothat would make the refund, and thus the system as a whole, regressive to avoid this, the refund would itself need to be progressive, giving back to some more than others, which sounds like a worse version of just progressively taxing in the first place
- throwawaymaths 4y agoNeither will a progressive tax. The core wealth gap problem is we systematically steal from the poor
- zmgsabst 4y agoI would say it’s because we burden the middle class — causing a bimodal distribution (wealthy and poor) without any means of upwards mobility because small businesses are regulated and taxed beyond what they can sustain.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoNo, we steal from the poor via stuff like an onerous legal system, fines, fees, and most importantly, inflation.
- chasd00 4y agoThe ever shrinking middle class pays for everything. The poor are too poor and the rich have the resources to figure out how to avoid paying.
- throwawaymaths 4y agoThis is a misconception. Everything is paid for by inflation. This hits the poorest the hardest.
- Wyoming23 4y agoThis common sentiment isn't really true in general, but led to a great deal of amusement for me in a previous life in wealth management. We constantly got clients who were newly rich and believed there were all sorts of tricks and loopholes that would allow them to avoid paying taxes. They'd come to us with ideas about trusts, shell companies, charitable organizations, loans, whatever, and inevitably leave frustrated and disappointed when they learned the really was no way to use their new wealth without the government first taking half.
- marcus0x62 4y ago(Admittedly without putting any real thought into this,) it seems like it could be made less regressive by excluding necessities that make up the vast majority of a low income family’s budget, having a “medium” rate on some other categories like consumer electronics, and a “high” rate on luxury goods. Quotes because I have no idea what “medium” and “high” would need to look like for the numbers to work. Some states with sales tax (Texas and Florida come to mind) already do something like this by excluding groceries from their sales tax program.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThese kinds of roundabout ways to help the poor always end up with complications that waste time and resources at best, and open up avenues for corruption at worst. https://taxfoundation.org/sales-tax-grocery-tax-exemptions/ https://taxfoundation.org/sales-tax-grocery-tax-exemptions/ I always try to advocate for KISS, keep it simple, stupid. Want to help poor people? Give them cash. Want to prevent political fighting about who constitutes poor people? Give everyone cash. And then take back based on marginal income/property/sales taxes.
- benj111 4y agoIs vat actually regressive at all? The more you spend, the more you pay. I see the wisdom of removing tax on necessities. But after that it's essentially everyone's choice what they buy. The issue seems to be that things that only the wealthy can take advantage of are under taxed.