3 ms·
TechCrunch messes up the math on sexism
- davidcann 15y agoI would think that math aptitude has very little to do with developing great products and companies, so I don't understand this argument. It doesn't even have much to do with many types of programming.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- yummyfajitas 15y agoFrom the article: "I'm not attempting to claim science currently knows everything about this topic. The only point I'm making is that it does not take "really extreme" differences in aptitude or innate preferences to account for gender differences in high end professions." This is a counterpoint to Eric Ries, who claims: "Here in Silicon Valley, we’re looking for the absolute best and brightest, the people far out on the tail end of aptitude...How far apart would the two populations have to be to explain YC’s historical admission rate of 4% women? It would have to be really extreme." The only point is to do the math and demonstrate that small differences can add up to a lot if you have highly selective filters. I chose mathematical ability as an example because a) it's fairly well studied and b) Eric Ries cites a slideshare presentation which also uses it as an example. (However, the data used in the presentation are about 20 years older than mine.)
- zacharypinter 15y agoWhether it's math aptitude or an aptitude in some other tangentially related field, I think the idea is that men in general tend to have more variance in their distribution, though the mean ends up being about the same. "Small differences in the distributions of men and women don't allow you to predict much about any individual trait of a randomly selected individual. But when you limit yourself to the far tails of probability distributions, they do. " So, he's saying that by being more selective for a field that men have greater variance in, you're more likely to find more men at the far tails.
- lomegor 15y agoI'm not sure if this article is trying to say that those small differences account for the differences between the percentage of men and women in YC, or if it's just disproving the mathematical aspect of the TechCrunch article. I'm not saying either of those articles is right, but clearly none have shown why that difference exist.
- luchak 15y agoThe lengths to which this article goes to construct a model sympathetic to the author's views are incredible. It takes data showing a greater variance among males than females: - in mathematical ability - among schoolchildren - on a standardized test and generalizes them to: - many different types of abilities - among the Y Combinator applicant pool - on the Y Combinator application process Not only that, but by its end, the article is postulating a model in which literally one in a million people have sufficient aptitude to be accepted by Y Combinator - whether they're interested in it or not! Even if you grant the author all of those assumptions, plus the risk aversion thing, you're only down to 13% women, three times what TechCrunch says Y Combinator actually accepts. I guess you could add another independent 99.9th percentile ability requirement, but then you're talking about one in a billion people being Y Combinator worthy. Or you could try to find a different, more tilted risk aversion statistic -- but at that point I think we'd be cherry-picking citations to fit a conclusion. So, sure, if you accept a whole raft of dubious assumptions, you can explain the 4% acceptance rate by aptitude alone. But enough dubious assumptions can explain almost anything.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNot only that, but by its end, the article is postulating a model in which literally one in a million people have sufficient aptitude to be accepted by Y Combinator - whether they're interested in it or not! Why do you feel this is unreasonable? Do you think there is some huge pool of people good enough for YC who just don't get in? Maybe the true numbers are 1 in 100,000, but I'd be surprised if they are much higher than that. In any case, I'm not attempting to claim my assumptions are correct. The only point I'm making is that small differences in underlying probability distributions can have large effects in the composition of people accepted into a highly selective program. I.e., Eric Ries is making the fallacy of the excluded middle: "either aptitude/preference differences are huge, or else they don't explain much." This is simply mathematically incorrect.
- Mz 15y agoI thought you had a point. Professional basketball comes to mind, where it's incredibly unusual for someone to be of "normal" height. A height difference gives you an advantage which I suspect creates a positive feedback loop (advantage leads to more enjoyment, which leads to more practice...etc) and remains a significant factor even when all other things are equal (like innate talent).
- Mz 15y agoDoes anyone know the two following stats: What percentage of applicants to YC are female? Acceptance rate in terms of applicant pool for each gender? (ie "10% of all male applicants are accepted vs 14% of all female applicants" -- and I chose to skew it that way intentionally because I am betting if there is a gender based selection bias it is probably in that direction) These statistical analyses are meaningless outside of that context. If it just so happens that only 4% of the applicants are female, then why should the gender balance of final selections be any different from that?