3 ms·
I think that beyond 20km the horizon is between the laser and the drone. Maybe aircraft-mounted lasers could defend the carrier over a wider area. If each dro
by kragen 4y ago
I think that beyond 20km the horizon is between the laser and the drone. Maybe aircraft-mounted lasers could defend the carrier over a wider area.
If each drone costs US$50 then you can launch 180 million drones for the cost of an aircraft carrier. I don't think increasing the number of lasers from my 5 to 10-20 is going to help much.
I don't know what is needed for a munition to damage an aircraft carrier, but I feel like once it's on the deck it's already past the strong defenses and into the soft targets. It could be as simple as a wheeled robot that runs around stabbing random people, or a poison gas canister that fills the interior of the ship with mustard gas, or hundreds of hand-grenade-sized mini-claymores that deploy to random parts of the ship and conceal themselves quietly until a sailor happens to walk by.
- dogcomplex 4y agoShaped charges can blast a sizable hole through any material, likely big enough to fly the next drone through. Only so many hits to get through a hull.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, in a realistic scenario, if the carrier can take out 360 drones before the drone wave reaches it, the adversary would launch 700 drones, not 361. I hadn't even thought about hitting the carrier in the same place over and over again. But supposedly carriers aren't even designed with thick armor?
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoIf drones are so magically cheap, the carrier deploys its own magically cheap defensive drone swarm to protect itself when attacked by drones and remains unscathed.
- marshray 4y agoWhat if a defensive drone swarm, to be effective, must be generations more advanced than the attacking drone swarm? There could be an interim period of many years where very important stuff is very vulnerable.
- dogcomplex 4y agoWould expect this to be the dominant countermeasure in the case where drones are a significant threat, yeah. Though actually I'm coming around to the idea that a bunch of AI-targeted flak guns are sufficient, and that carriers are probably fine either way due to how close a series of missiles containing the swarm would have to get anyway.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, that's the future I'm pointing to: the aircraft carrier itself is no longer militarily relevant, because what counts are the drone swarms. But there's no particular reason to expect that this future will be a Mohist one in which peace is ensured because magically cheap defensive drone swarms make every fortress impregnable and thus combatants' home territories always remain unscathed; at least as likely is a Second Variety future in which drone swarms are more effective for attack than for defense, perhaps even after all the human combatants are dead.
- dogcomplex 4y agoNope, ain't that thick (< 1 inch). Probably built with multiple expendable flood chambers though, so swarm would likely need to make its way through the first hole. Plausible a single shaped charge does enough damage, but more likely some single-digit of hits needed. Swimming + flying cheap drones doable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FC9EJhs0pc0&ab_channel=RutgersToday https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FC9EJhs0pc0&ab_channel=Rutge... At (wild overestimate) $1k per drone an attacker can wield 13 million drones for the equivalent cost of an aircraft carrier, not including ongoing expenses.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThe sort of shaped charge you could put on a thousand dollar missile could probably pierce small holes in the hull of a ship (too small to fly anything through, that is fantasy. Shaped charges are bigger than the holes they make.) But even hundreds of holes like that that wouldn't sink a ship. Not least because the ship is filled with sailors trained in damage control, and that sort of damage wouldn't be particularly hard to patch up. Clearing the flight deck with antipersonnel warheads would probably work better, but I wouldn't count on that to keep a carrier out of action for very long. If you really want to sink a ship, either use proper anti-ship warheads or don't bother trying.
- giantrobot 4y ago> If each drone costs US$50 then you can launch 180 million drones for the cost of an aircraft carrier. In a world of frictionless pulleys and spherical cows yes, in the real world, no. In the real world aircraft carriers and their attendant battle groups do not just park within visible range of a coast. Your drone swarm needs to find the carrier's battle group, get within launch range for your $50 drones (without being shot down), maintain some sort of identification of the carrier (or whatever ship), and then make a terminal approach. A carrier's air group maintains a perimeter hundreds of miles away from the carrier group. Not just fighters flying CAP but AWACS planes keeping track of the airspace. No one is going to hide a million drones launching towards a carrier group. It would be unlikely hide even a hundred drones. A drone carrier large enough to launch a non-trivial number of suicide drones is also unlikely to go undetected. Even if everything went right and someone managed to damage an aircraft carrier with a drone swarm, the carrier group alone has enough land attack weaponry to seriously hurt the source in retaliation. A nuclear response to an attack of a US carrier would not be outside the realm of possibility either. Attacking a US carrier group is a really dumb idea even if you've got a really clever weapon.
- kragen 4y agoYou don't have to hide the million drones if the carrier group doesn't have enough firepower to destroy them all before they reach the carrier. But you might be able to, if they're small enough. Or underwater. If you can provoke nuclear retaliation, you win twice, at least to the extent that anyone can "win" a battle nowadays: first, you sink Enemy A's carrier (or, more realistically, permanently incapacitate it), and second, you draw Enemy A's nukes onto Enemy B's territory where you launched the drones from.