3 ms·
Will pay-per-mile be a buzzkill for American road trips?
- ew 15y agoInstead of a per-mile tax it would probably be more productive to just increase vehicle registration costs by $250, which is the average fuel tax paid each year per vehicle.
- dalke 15y agoOr as the article says: "The best and least complicated solution is to raise the fuel tax, which hasn't changed since 1993." But apparently the politics to put GPS trackers in every car, or odometer-based taxes, is apparently easier than raising taxes? Ahh, right, 238 Representatives and 41 Senators (all Republicans excepting 2 and 1 Democrats, respectively) have sworn a pledge that they will refuse any such action. Even may the bridges crumble underneath our feet, they will not raise taxes on us.
- protomyth 15y agoThe problem there is that you are punishing people buying more efficient, lighter vehicles that don't damage the roads as much as an SUV.
- mahyarm 15y agoMake the registration increase in proportion to vehicle weight. 0.10 per pound. Easy, fair, obvious and we have weight stations everywhere already for trucks. Incentivizes car manufacturers to make lighter cars too.
- danielharan 15y agoThis also rewards light gas guzzlers. Hiking the tax on gas is simple and can be adjusted as the car stock gets more efficient - and this rewards the most efficient vehicles.
- dalke 15y ago"No, really. I took the seats out months ago. And the spare tire and jack. And I always drive with 1/16th of a tank of gas." There, saved ya' at least $5!
- evan_ 15y agoSurely there's already some kind of database of the gross vehicle weight of every model of car for safety standards, there's no need to weigh every single car on the road.
- dalke 15y agoYes, that can be used as a proxy for the actual weight, but weight itself is a proxy for the amount of impact the vehicle has on the road. Someone with a 5 ton RV who uses it twice a year to drive to Florida for the winter has less impact than someone with a truck weighing 4 tons who drives around the county all day, with a full load of tools and other equipment. Unlike a fuel tax, a weight tax would affect the RV owner more than the truck owner, which doesn't seem right. If someone reworks VW Beetle into a stretch version, or adds armor to a BMW, then are they charged based on the original weight or the current weight?
- jerrya 15y agoThe article states we already pay per mile, via gas taxes. This means drivers pay different rate per mile, depending on how efficient their car burns gas, which is presumably itself a function of engine as well as chosen tires and weight of the vehicle, ie, how the car impacts the road. The article then says legislation is needed to change us from paying per mile, to paying ... per mile, but in a way which is a hell of a lot more intrusive to the driver: cell phone tracking. I remain unconvinced this is not about tracking and is about paying for the roads. What's wrong with just increasing the gas taxes appropriately?
- protomyth 15y agoI submitted this article because it is "yet another politician thinks up hard technology solution to problem" article. The problem statement here is pretty simple. 1) gas tax will not cover road and bridge repairs 2) people have more fuel efficient vehicles 3) gas tax is spent on non-road items 4) gas tax hasn't changed in years It seems like a simple thought to just raise the gas tax and stop spending the money on anything but roads. After all, a sub compact causes less damage than an SUV. Surely the SUV should pay more, which it does through simple physics by needing more energy to move. The second problem with a mileage tax that is paid monthly or yearly is the working poor. Public transport isn't and won't be universal in the US (like I said in another thread the closest bus stop to me is 90 miles away). The current gas tax works because it is a judgement at the pump with no long term commitments. Never mind the privacy concerns or that cutting down people's area of commute adds to unemployment. The crux of this is electric cars need to pay a road tax also. How that is going to be handled is going to be the big problem.
- jdludlow 15y ago"You can't drop off the grid. Ten years from now, it will be virtually impossible to drive a car that doesn't have an electronic signature," said Neil. My sawzall and soldering iron beg to differ. In Minnesota, we waste hundreds of millions of tax dollars that are supposed to be use for roads on choo-choo trains that run in the red year after year. I won't be shedding any tears over their self-made budget shortfalls.
- potatolicious 15y agoIt puzzles me that roads are never expected to break even, much less turn a profit - but trains and buses are. In the end it's all just transportation infrastructure, and society will end up subsidizing it in any case.
- digikata 15y agoPay for mile is too much cost overhead for precision accounting, both in terms of government, and individual citizen costs. That's not even touching the privacy implications. The simple thing to do would be charge pre-pay fixed annual rates as a function of ranges of mileage and vehicle weight. No GPS needed. No gov't offices trying to buy map data and assign different rates per road segment, mapping your gps tracks to roads... issuing post-facto speeding tickets...
- kijin 15y ago> The best and least complicated solution is to raise the fuel tax... [snip] Many members of Congress would likely oppose any kind of tax hike. So, it's supposed to be easier to introduce a brand-new surveillance-and-taxation scheme than it is to increase an existing tax? What kind of a country is this?