4 ms·
What is the point of republishing it on Github? They (GitHub / Microsoft) will just remove it and ban it again after announcing it. A better way instead, would
by rvz 4y ago
What is the point of republishing it on Github? They (GitHub / Microsoft) will just remove it and ban it again after announcing it.
A better way instead, would be to do what all other projects like GNOME, KDE, Tor, wireguard, etc have done before and that is to just self-host the repositories instead.
- oceanstone 4y agoHopefully the government can identify any forks that achieve meaningful TVL and taint the coins
- ipaddr 4y agoWhat would that for you? Why the hope?
- encryptluks2 4y ago
- oceanstone 4y agoI'm hoping the government makes money laundering harder. North Korea laundered a billion dollars through Tornado: https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/currencies/north-korea-launder-treasury-ethereum-us-billion-sanctions-tornado-cash-2022-8 https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/currencies/north-ko...
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIt may sound a little odd, but you do not think existing AML regime is already working in overdrive mode punishing regular people ( all while actual big fish manage to get away undetected or, worse, protected )?
- EddySchauHai 4y agoThat's almost 0.3% of the money estimated to be laundered in the US through traditional means, and 0.05% of the estimated money laundered globally.
- acdha 4y agoIt is a much larger percentage of North Korea’s total economy, however, and I think that’s going to turn out to be the primary motivation here: not that OFAC woke up one morning and said that Tornado Cash is public enemy #1 but that the people watching North Korea saw that ransomware proceeds were being laundered using this specific system and wanted to stop it.
- absolutelynobo 4y agoAnd AML wastes tens of billions of good dollars in GDP and revenue per year through added monitoring costs, insurance, enforcement expenses, etc. If AML were 90% effective, it’d be supported; but it’s more like 0.1% effective.
- coolspot 4y agoUS govt has banned Tornado Cash the organization, not code of Tornado Cash. Github complies to sanctions by removing all repositories owned by sanctioned organization. Doesn’t mean you can’t have a copy of their code.
- oceanstone 4y agoThat's good to hear, because the code itself should be considered free speech
- toomuchtodo 4y agoPlatforms have the right as is to deplatform undesirable speech, including code. Social media platforms do this daily (speech, not code). Freedom of speech protects you from your government. It does not guarantee you a platform.
- DennisP 4y agoSo now we'll find out whether this platform is choosing to deplatform this particular speech, now that it's more clear that they're under no legal obligation to do so.
- notch656a 4y agoI don't really blame them if they are. The risk:reward for offering essentially a free service to take legal heat on something this "hot" seems like a bad tradeoff for github. Seems like the kind of thing better hosted on some financially fire-walled shell company's website where any losses from a protracted legal battle can fall off into oblivion.
- sp332 4y agoI think you're talking about the first amendment. There are principles of free speech that go beyond just what's legal.
- 4y ago
- cmroanirgo 4y agoThe author explains why it's on GH. > I’ve worked with this code as a researcher and I use it to teach my classes, so it’s important to me that it stays easily-accessible on a major site like GitHub. (This is not the only copy, in fact it’s a fork of someone else’s.)
- seestem 4y agoI think this is about proving a point. The point being "code is free speech" and to not let GitHub / Microsoft slide and set a precedent that takes us back 30 years.
- mimon 4y agoWhether code is protected speech or not is utterly irrelevant. Microsoft is not the US Government and has no free speech obligations to anyone. There are already many forms of protected speech that are banned from GitHub, this is not proving anything.
- feet 4y agoJust like any other platform, Microsoft is a private entity and is not required to provide a platform for people they don't agree with. Anyone is free to host their own repos on their own servers
- protonbob 4y agoJust because someone is a private entity and they are not required to host something doesn't mean that they shouldn't be a good example.
- feet 4y agoBusinesses will act in their best interest to protect their profits. That's the base of capitalism. If we don't like that we need to enact regulations
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rstephenson2 4y agoThey might also be banking on this giving Microsoft cover to not take it down. With the original takedown, Microsoft would be worried that the relative nobodies disappear with Microsoft left holding the bag. If Microsoft instead knows that it’s backed by the EFF who is itching for a Supreme Court fight, they might instead tell the USG “here’s their mailing address, you guys settle it in court”.