5 ms·
People who choose what they believe have an entirely different understanding of the concept of belief than I do. Belief is something that is inflicted upon me b
by pessimizer 4y ago
People who choose what they believe have an entirely different understanding of the concept of belief than I do. Belief is something that is inflicted upon me by my environment, not something I choose based on the lifestyle I want or the people I want to associate with. Consumer belief?
If I could choose my beliefs, I would choose to believe in an almost completely different set of things. All of my beliefs would be self-serving, I'd be really happy about how everything was going every day.
The reason I can't do this is because it would be really damaging to the people around me, and to society. I can't choose to ignore that.
- jason-phillips 4y agoWhile I appreciate your perspective, the construct you described allows one to invalidate others' beliefs as being "wrong" because they don't adhere to the same reference point as yourself. > All of my beliefs would be self-serving This is not a true statement. Why cannot one choose what one feels to be the most appropriate construct after careful inspection and introspection?
- bombcar 4y agoOnce you realize you know way less about everything than you thought you did, and much of what is “known” is future conjectures with many parts, you realize you can select the optimistic view.
- actionablefiber 4y agoI'm not sure I follow. I agree with what GP wrote. Their second paragraph is written in the first person. It's not a claim that everyone would do the self-serving thing. I would do the same as GP. I'd choose a set of beliefs that help me sleep at night and that make me a hoot at dinner parties instead of a Debbie Downer. I can't simply choose to do that, because those beliefs come from my experience with and observations of the world along with my deeply-held values.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jason-phillips 4y ago> I can't simply choose to do that, because... To delve a little deeper, this statement shows that it's still a _choice_, even though the choice is apparently a refutation of choice, which is interesting. Asserting that this construct simply _is_, where choice isn't there or doesn't exist, doesn't pass the smell test. The fact that one may choose to live a life only for oneself were one left to one's own devices is simply commentary about that individual. But again, one may choose not to do that.
- actionablefiber 4y ago> To delve a little deeper, this statement shows that it's still a _choice_, even though the choice is apparently a refutation of choice, which is interesting. Worldviews and beliefs are answers we come up with to the difficult questions that life asks. If you've done any work to come up with those answers, then your beliefs are built on top of a lot of observations, introspection, and analysis. For me to change my beliefs I would need to discover some kind of mistake I've made in my work or some important piece of information I was missing. How can you casually choose a different belief set unless your original beliefs were not built on anything substantial to start with?
- jason-phillips 4y agoYour perspective is totally valid to me. I'm not going to tell you you're wrong, because you're not. At least not in the "I'm right and you're wrong" way. I don't casually choose a belief set. I've deliberated this for decades. My beliefs, or more accurately the code that I live by, is just that, my code. I have a choice in the matter, it doesn't come from somewhere else where it's inflicted upon me. I formulated it. > For me to change my beliefs I would need to discover some kind off mistake I've made in my work.... Not to beat a dead horse, but I think that this again speaks to the fact that it's a choice.
- dredmorbius 4y agothe construct you described allows one to invalidate others' beliefs as being "wrong" because they don't adhere to the same reference point as yourself Belief based in empirical evidence is at least bound to that evidence. Belief unmoored from empiricism --- blind faith or revelation --- suffers no such limits. Your criticism would apply all the more so to same, with the further failing that others' beliefs are "wrong" because they ... are simply revealed or adopted faiths. Which is frequently observed. If my evidence-based belief differs from your evidence-based belief, then we can compare evidence. Evidence does not have to be directly experienced (though for various reasons of psychological evolution we tend often to more highly weight that which is); we can also rely on evidence presented by other trustworthy witnesses. There are numerous social institutions dedicated to precisely this (science, courts, journalism, politics, ...)
- jason-phillips 4y agoThe factory owner and the factory worker can look at the same set of data and arrive at completely different world views. The Empire Did Nothing Wrong™ Was Lucifer actually incorrect in his position in the Garden of Eden? I'm pointing out how completely different and valid perspectives can be derived from the same set of data, the same circumstance. The problem arises when one claims their perspective was "inflicted" upon them by some uncompromising, external agent, which implies there is no choice in the matter, which is absurd because there most certainly is. I don't think you're wrong, by the way, I just see things a little differently.
- dredmorbius 4y agoThe factory owner and the factory worker can look at the same set of data and arrive at completely different world views. My comment allows for that. Many-sidedness, a/k/a Anekantavada (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekantavada https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekantavada). But many sidedness is not the any sideness which revealed or blind-faith belief permits. Experiential understanding is bound to and by that experience. Further, the cases you're referring to largely discuss social relational worldviews which are informed by status, standing, and affiliation within a society or culture. There are of course non-social instances of multiple interpretations, such as wave-particle duality, in which how one looks at a phenomenon influences the model arrived. at. Factory owner and worker at least have beleif and understanding grounded in experience, and might be convinced of or sympathetic to the validity of views generated by the alternate experience. Your "which implies there is no choice" is reading meaning to my comment I did not intend and disagree with strongly. The fact that people see things differently, that is, arrive at different conclusions based on different empirical evidence or experience is in fact my point.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago"There is always too much information; the problem is knowing what to believe." - Quote from a spy novel I read a long time ago; I may have butchered the quote a bit. Anyway, the point is, there is data out there that leads to pessimism. Absolutely. There's plenty of it. There is grounds for pessimism. But there is also data that leads to optimism. There's plenty of it, too. So you choose your belief by choosing which set of data to pay more attention to. (Except it's not that simple. You're choosing which set of data you think is more credible, or more relevant, or more important, or reflects a more accurate picture of the situation. But there still is an element of choice - you choose which data set to pay more attention to, and that data set usually winds up being the one you consider more valid.)