3 ms·
GlueLam is fantastic, in the right context. I've seen large church spans in it which were modernist takes on old craft, beautiful both as wood and engineering.
by ggm 4y ago
GlueLam is fantastic, in the right context. I've seen large church spans in it which were modernist takes on old craft, beautiful both as wood and engineering. I still like massive Oak beams, but I like GlueLam too.
Plywood is fantastic. Look at the Mosquito! But more seriously, it was a designers dream from the day they got it "right" for tensile strength and glue/moisture issues.
MDF is kind of meh. It weighs a tonne, and it sucks paint up like a builder in the bar after work. But it has it's place. Damp.. nightmare.
(had work done on a wooden house in Qld, it made extensive use of GlueLam for structural support, Plywood for rigidity and wind shear load bearing, and MDF for routed patterns: walls and ceilings in Qld used (and still often are) made of (vertically joined, in the case of walls) Tongue-and-Groove or "vee-jay" and is very hard to get at old dimensions, and lumber from a "restoration station" (recycling centre) is very exy now. So for mixing new build with old build, MDF+router == same width pattern of VJ grooves.
If its structural and hidden (or not, if you like it's look) then manufactured wood is really great stuff.
- walterbell 4y agoGluelam was in the news recently after a bridge collapse in Norway, root cause not yet determined, https://www.lifeinnorway.net/wooden-bridge-collapse/ https://www.lifeinnorway.net/wooden-bridge-collapse/ & https://www.dezeen.com/2022/08/17/norway-timber-tretten-bridge-collapse/ https://www.dezeen.com/2022/08/17/norway-timber-tretten-brid...
- mc32 4y agoThere was another that also collapsed a few years earlier —so it seems outdoors applications would not be recommended.
- civeng 4y agoCovered wooden bridges last hundreds of years and they are very beautiful. Maintenance is required (as with everything) but life cycle cost is really good especially for shorter spans.
- ggm 4y agoGlueLam hasn't existed long enough for the glue-lamination aspect to be understood for climate, the way solid timbers are. I wanted to believe composites of all kinds had better lifecycle but it turns out Nature has some tricks up its sleeve which we don't yet entirely emulate, when it comes to longevity. Down in Tasmania there are thousands of tonnes of flooded forest woods, which are being dredged up 50 or 60 years down in the cold dark dam-water, and being turned into exquisite furniture and musical instruments. I'm told almost petrified Kauri Pine can be the same, other woods turn into something magical when left alone for a long time. Put GluLam to the same test, It's probably not happy outcome.
- civeng 4y agoAgree! The wet dry cycle at some point seems almost certain it would cause delamination. I'm surprised those failed bridges aren't more protected, it does seems risky, it seems they should be kept out of direct weather. Also agree glulams dont have a 100+ year track record, but it's getting there. They solve so many other issues such as efficient utilization of low grade and sustainable wood...so count me a cautious but excited proponent. Good story about the Kauri Pine, that looks like a pretty cool tree!