5 ms·
History of Yard Lumber Size Standards (1964) [pdf]
- h2odragon 4y agothe long answer to "why is a 2x4 board actually 1.5 inch by 3.5 inch" considering the inputs, modern lumber is a stunningly consistent and reliable product.
- bradly 4y ago2x4 in the rough is 1.5 x 3.5 inch when milled square. Depending on the moisture content when milled and how it is stored/dryed there could be considerable stray from the full, nominal size.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoI’m glad my 16 foot ladder isn’t measured this way.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y ago> stunningly consistent Except now they've found a new way to cheat by putting excessively large radii on the corners of construction grade lumber.
- matthewaveryusa 4y agoI thought the radii was a feature because right angles are more difficult to slip into place and tend to splinter more. You're probably right that it's a cost-saving measure though.
- zeitgeistcowboy 4y agoThe wood in the radii is lost to sawdust. Perhaps they sell this sawdust as a product, but it’s more likely just to make it easier to handle and less likely to get damaged or damage something else.
- DrPhish 4y agoIt’s a “coproduct”, the value of which is roughly inverse to the price of lumber and other finished manufactured end products. It goes into things pulp and paper, pellet stove fuel, cogen plants and if useless for anything else, the “hog” in the basement of the mill. Fun fact: any contamination of chips with plastic or metal makes the value of a load as large as a rail car worth zero, so QC are super anal about keeping it out
- petee 4y agoI don't see this as a cost saving - the radius isn't material that would make it onto another piece of lumber, it'd be the waste between rectangles. In addition, keeping a machine tuned and sharp to cut the radius costs money. I would assume two possible reasons: the radius reduces stress concentration, and facilitating handling and packaging (think splinter fall-off debris, and likelyhood to bind up on a sharp edge)
- avar 4y ago> it'd be the waste between rectangles. It's certainly not being wasted, you can e.g. break it up and use it as material for an OSB, sell it as sawdust etc.
- dmckeon 4y agoI worked in a retail lumber yard in the mid-1970s and learned to be very patient with crochety old pharts who complained that "a 2x4 used to be a full 2"x4" dagnabbit..." Am now a somewhat crochety old phart myself, and was surprised to find that 1.5" x 2.5" actual (2"x3" nominal) is considered adequate for some studs. Source: https://www.homedepot.com/p/2-in-x-3-in-x-96-in-Select-Whitewood-Stud-845000/100038668 https://www.homedepot.com/p/2-in-x-3-in-x-96-in-Select-White... Am pleased to see that effective hacking has a long history: > Dimension was fitted into place by the carpenter, more often than not with his hatchet.
- jefftk 4y ago> Am now a somewhat crochety old phart myself, and was surprised to find that 1.5" x 2.5" actual (2"x3" nominal) is considered adequate for some studs. You can frame a wall with 2x3s 16" on center as long as it's not load bearing. That seems pretty reasonable to me, since it doesn't need to do more than hold up the drywall, partition the space, and stand up to people bonking into it.
- rascul 4y agoMobile homes often use 2x3.
- at_a_remove 4y agoIn Fire Walk With Me, there was a deleted scene, now available on The Missing Pieces, involving a confused man who believed he had been shafted out of some wood versus the lumber yard. I had never given it much thought but the scene more or less goes over the why.
- mc32 4y agoAmish mills still sell actual 2”x4”s.
- walterbell 4y agoAre those wet and rough cut (unplaned)? https://amishofethridge.com/the-amish-have-great-lumber/ https://amishofethridge.com/the-amish-have-great-lumber/ > The 2x4 you purchase at the Amish sawmill is considered wet lumber and is full size but will shrink while drying. The 2x4 from an Amish sawmill will measure a true 2 inch x 4 inch measurement on a tape measure.
- orthoxerox 4y agoThey are. Wet lumber is still sadly the norm in Russia for construction work, and 2x4 are still 2x4 there (or rather, 50x100).
- bombcar 4y agoBy L. W. SMITH, Wood Technologist and L. W. WOOD, Engineer Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture Strangely appropriate.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hpkuarg 4y agoEvery day there's more evidence that we live in a simulation. ;-)
- tschwimmer 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nominative_determinism
- moistly 4y agoWell, it is farming. The farm is huge and the growing season is measured in decades and centuries. Harvesting is contracted-out.
- walterbell 4y agohttps://www.harvarddesignmagazine.org/issues/45/nominal-versus-actual-a-history-of-the-2x4 https://www.harvarddesignmagazine.org/issues/45/nominal-vers... > Size standards, maximum moisture content, and nomenclature were agreed upon only as recently as 1964. The nominal 2x4 thus became the actual 1½ x 3½, imperceptibly, a fraction of an inch at a time. It was a 34 percent reduction in actual volume; as those in the trade would say, it’s “selling air.” > Today, everyone in the construction industry knows that nominal size is not actual size—despite the fact that the 2x4 designation persists in the marketplace. So, why does the awareness about the “slimming” of its actual size matter? For one, we must dispel any notion that the current size is a perfect utility equation of structural performance in terms of strength-to-size ratio. > Instead, let’s recognize that the evolution of the 2x4 resulted from economic compromise based on simplifying differences and creating a nationwide standard for customers. It is utility optimized for construction speed—speed in shooting together single-family light-stick stud homes which represent more than 90 percent of the residential housing market.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- supernova87a 4y agoThat source was so much clearer and succinct a read than the long PDF with every historical anecdote. I mean, maybe if you're a wood enthusiast you could muster up the enthusiasm to read the 60 page dissertation ...
- walterbell 4y agoAgreed, but the dissertation got more upvotes, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32532933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32532933
- elif 4y agoThank you for providing this text. I don't know why HN even permits the linking of pdf's if they can be a vector for arbitrary execution and privilege escalation.
- ceroxylon 4y agoI used to really admire the forest service, before I learned that they are basically the harbingers of destruction for old growth forests. They have butchered far more than they protect, and primary forest is being harvested to this day with their blessing.
- jeffbee 4y agoThe mission of the USFS is to provide forest products to Americans in perpetuity. If you imagined they were a conservation agency, that was just your imagination. The only conservation mission of the USFS is to operate forests in a long-term steady state of growing and harvesting.
- Taniwha 4y agoSadly does not explain why it's a "2x4" in the US, and a "4x2" elsewhere (before elsewhere gave up inches)
- Daub 4y agoI believe most carpenters in the UK would still say '2 by 4' and '2 by 1'. Odd, as those values are pretty much meaningless, as they refer to the original size of the timber before it was planed down. In this sense, those dimensions have now become terms.
- civeng 4y agoWhere do people refer a "2x4" as a "4x2"? Sincere question. I have heard it, but only in the way of inferring that it was being used in an abnormal or "flat" orientation, such as for a floor truss assembly
- ggm 4y agoGlueLam is fantastic, in the right context. I've seen large church spans in it which were modernist takes on old craft, beautiful both as wood and engineering. I still like massive Oak beams, but I like GlueLam too. Plywood is fantastic. Look at the Mosquito! But more seriously, it was a designers dream from the day they got it "right" for tensile strength and glue/moisture issues. MDF is kind of meh. It weighs a tonne, and it sucks paint up like a builder in the bar after work. But it has it's place. Damp.. nightmare. (had work done on a wooden house in Qld, it made extensive use of GlueLam for structural support, Plywood for rigidity and wind shear load bearing, and MDF for routed patterns: walls and ceilings in Qld used (and still often are) made of (vertically joined, in the case of walls) Tongue-and-Groove or "vee-jay" and is very hard to get at old dimensions, and lumber from a "restoration station" (recycling centre) is very exy now. So for mixing new build with old build, MDF+router == same width pattern of VJ grooves. If its structural and hidden (or not, if you like it's look) then manufactured wood is really great stuff.
- walterbell 4y agoGluelam was in the news recently after a bridge collapse in Norway, root cause not yet determined, https://www.lifeinnorway.net/wooden-bridge-collapse/ https://www.lifeinnorway.net/wooden-bridge-collapse/ & https://www.dezeen.com/2022/08/17/norway-timber-tretten-bridge-collapse/ https://www.dezeen.com/2022/08/17/norway-timber-tretten-brid...
- mc32 4y agoThere was another that also collapsed a few years earlier —so it seems outdoors applications would not be recommended.
- civeng 4y agoCovered wooden bridges last hundreds of years and they are very beautiful. Maintenance is required (as with everything) but life cycle cost is really good especially for shorter spans.
- helge87 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEOnIpO7Xgw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LEOnIpO7Xgw
- SulphurSmell 4y agoFront page of the .pdf shows a neat lumber gauge in action. It's designed to fit on your finger and allow rapid checking of common dimensions. You can still buy these...or, in this case, an excellent reproduction here: https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop/tools/hand-tools/marking-and-measuring/calipers/58701-lumber-thickness-gauge?item=50K6301 https://www.leevalley.com/en-ca/shop/tools/hand-tools/markin...