17 ms·
Am not a censor, I agree with this. What people call “free speech” is really “free mouth utterances” with basically no consideration of whether or not what is b
by Spivak 4y ago
Am not a censor, I agree with this. What people call “free speech” is really “free mouth utterances” with basically no consideration of whether or not what is being said is actually a sincerely held belief being expressed in good faith. Because the belief that current public discourse is anything at all a marketplace of ideas or some collective Socratic circle is also extremely naive and juvenile.
By making no distinction between (picking an obviously repulsive view) a post that outlines someone’s argument why they believe black people are predisposed to be thieves and some photoshopped stock photo of a black kid stealing watermelon and fried chicken with the caption “ni**, right?” [1] we just let hate, and the irl consequences, spread while choking off actual speech. You kill the very thing you wanted to protect with free speech in the first place.
Free speech should be measured in “freedom as in liberty” instead of “freedom as in anarchy.”
[1] This was, not even exaggerated, real content you could find on some now banned subreddits, one of them rhymes with moon town.
- ipaddr 4y agoAn obvious repulsive view is a subjective statement that changes based on the listener. Imagine by John Lennon is a great example that caused many to ban him for suggesting a world without religion was ideal while others are emotional moved by it.
- Spivak 4y agoWe’re not disagreeing on this, I picked a broadly agreed on repulsive view because I wanted to have an example of a gross view that still deserved protection because it was made in good faith.