5 ms·
I wonder if this has value for commercial pilot training. i.e. Instead of sticking them straight into a proper simulator, you loan them 15k worth of consumer t
by Havoc 4y ago
I wonder if this has value for commercial pilot training.
i.e. Instead of sticking them straight into a proper simulator, you loan them 15k worth of consumer tech for home. Not as a replacement, but as intermediate step
- BossingAround 4y agoRight now, I don't think so unless companies like Boeing start building their own simulators on top of FSX. Right now, a pilot must be certified to fly a plane, which might include simulator hours. The airplane manufacturer then builds their own simulations, as far as I am aware. It's a great question though to wonder whether it wouldn't be cheaper for companies to build the simulators on top of something like FSX. Create something like the upstream training where you can train, until you get to the "production" simulator from the manufacturer, where you simply prove you have the required knowledge as a pilot.
- zokier 4y agoConsidering that Lockheeds Prepar3d is a tweaked version of FSX, I'd imagine that doing similar thing with FS2020 would be possible too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- doener 4y agoI talked to a certified German pilot about that. He said that pilots right now use two different kind of simulators for training. 1. Simulators which have a 1:1 copy of the cockpit and use the https://www.prepar3d.com/ https://www.prepar3d.com/ software from Lockheed Martin (based on a very old MS Flight Simulator software, I think originally 2006). These simulators however are not a perfect simulation of the physics and are only used to practice communication between tower and pilot and between pilot and co-pilot. Hours spent in this simulation do not count as flight hours. A simulator like that costs around 250.000 euros and can be tried out by everybody in Berlin for example: https://www.mydays.de/geschenkidee/airbus-320-berlin https://www.mydays.de/geschenkidee/airbus-320-berlin 2. A simulator also with a 1:1 copy of the cockpit with very basic graphics, but very accurate simulated physics model. These kind of simulator moves and behaved almost exactly like the real plane would do. Such a simulator costs, if I remember correctly, about 15 million euros. Hours spent in this simulator count as flight hours during pilot training – at least in Germany.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat might be true for Germany, but for US/FAA, the high-5-figure/low-6-figure training devices from Redbird are able to be logged (as sim time) and that time credited towards practical experience for required ratings. https://simulators.redbirdflight.com/products/topic/simulators https://simulators.redbirdflight.com/products/topic/simulato...
- trasz 4y agoNo idea about MSFS, but X-Plane, its main competition, is developed by a small consultancy company and I believe I remember them mentioning commercial support on their website.
- textide 4y agoFlight Instructor here. MSFS and its predecessors are invaluable in pilot training, particularly for the Instrument rating. The value is in the modeling of navigation systems, noot so much the scenery or exterior of the aircraft. Set visibility to 1/2 statute mile, ceiling at 300ft and practice full approaches to your heart's content. I recommend shutting off the ATC that ships with MSFS and using VATSIM or one of the other 3rd party human ATC systems available. Use Airnav.com for free US charts. At $200/flight hour, spending $1000-2000 on a high end PC, rudder pedals and decent joystick and throttle will save students money. MSFS doesn't replace training, but helps in handling the mental load of instrument flight.
- kuon 4y agoAs a pilot, I'd say that for learning how to fly it's near to useless, except if you have a really good setup with force feedback and similar. The first time I took off in a pipercub, I had thousands of simulator hours behind me (arguably way older than fly sim 2022), and I don't think I handled the plane better than someone with no experience, it was a new surprising feeling all the way. But. For instrument training, multi tasking, navigation and radio, fly simulators give you the real thing, it's a really nice tool for that. You can have replica of the whole instruments with very realistic rendering and this helps a lot. For radio, there are a lot of pro air nav controllers that hang around VATSIM and you can have the real thing from your PC.