2 ms·
The slightly insightful practical points mixed in with the misleading economic points set off my alarm bells to the point that I have a hard time believing the
by mindslight 4y ago
The slightly insightful practical points mixed in with the misleading economic points set off my alarm bells to the point that I have a hard time believing the lede is is truthful. The economic points are misleading because obviously it's cheaper and easier to release energy from concentrated stored chemical energy rather than capturing it from diffuse solar radiation. The point of the subsidies is to encourage developing the economy of the harder thing, for longer term reasons that aren't reflected in the instantaneous economics. Focusing on the instantaneous economics brushes aside the larger goal, in favor of emotionally appeals to saving money.
From a practical perspective, yes gas is miles ahead of coal. Just like if you're concerned with nuclear radiation, building new nuclear plants to replace coal plants is a win. Shouting down new gas plants in favor of keeping existing coal running is doing a terrible disservice. But this piece fallaciously extrapolates the comparison between gas and coal into outright condemnation of renewables, which smells like regressive fossil fuel industry FUD.