4 ms·
> First, evidence-gathering goons can turn off a computer (for transportation) without realizing it’s encrypted, and thus can’t get back at the data (unless the
by pavel_lishin 15y ago
> First, evidence-gathering goons can turn off a computer (for transportation) without realizing it’s encrypted, and thus can’t get back at the data (unless the arrestee gives up his password, which he doesn’t have to do);
I thought that if they had a warrant, you had to give up the password, much as you'd have to give up the key to a locked door in your house?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- cheald 15y agoThe Fifth Amendment precludes that. > No person shall...be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself Courts have previously upheld passwords as self-implicating information, which you cannot be constitutionally compelled to provide. > in In re Boucher (2009), the US District Court of Vermont ruled that the Fifth Amendment might protect a defendant from having to reveal an encryption password, or even the existence of one, if the production of that password could be deemed a self-incriminating "act" under the Fifth Amendment. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Boucher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_re_Boucher Boucher ended up having to unlock the hard drive, because he had previously unlocked the drive for border agents. Had he refused, the court likely would have held that he could not be compelled to produce the password or the hard drive contents. A warrant gives law enforcement the right to gather evidence, but doesn't compel you to provide it. If you won't provide it, they are authorized to take it by force. In the case of encryption, they don't have enough (legal) force to take it. Therefore, they are entirely dependent on the accused cooperating to gather that information, but the accused cannot be compelled to cooperate under the Fifth. This is scary for them, because it means that they can't legally compel you to give up the information, and they can't gain access to it by force. A wholly uncooperative defendant is effectively unassailable.
- potatolicious 15y ago> "you cannot be constitutionally compelled" The US government has frequent shown that they have no qualms against unconstitutionally compelling individuals...
- cheald 15y agoIndeed. Hence the "(legal) force" qualifier. I wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that targets had passwords "coaxed" out of them.
- hugh3 15y agoBoucher ended up having to unlock the hard drive, because he had previously unlocked the drive for border agents. Had he refused, the court likely would have held that he could not be compelled to produce the password or the hard drive contents So it sounds like the actual legal question here, of whether the government can compel you to hand over your password in the general case, has never actually been tested?
- cheald 15y agoIANAL, so I'm unqualified to say, but the way I read the ruling was that they decided that you can't be compelled to hand over your password, but because Boucher had already unlocked the drive for law enforcement once, doing so again would not further incriminate him. So, they forced him to unlock the hard drive without disclosing the password. As I understand it, if he had initially refused to unlock the drive, then he couldn't have been compelled to unlock it again, under grounds that it could be self-incrimination.
- flyt 15y agoIt's a legal gray area because a password is something in your brain and compelling you to reveal the password can be interpreted as testifying against yourself. If you refused to give the police a key they could use physical means to extract the safe contents but there's no way to take data out of your soft tissue.
- oniTony 15y agoThat might currently be the case for UK. Though it's quite reasonable to forget a password, especially in a high-stress situation of an interrogation. Extra hilarity ensues when there is actually _no_ password for a TrueCrypt volume that _does not_ exist, and one fails to provide a working password. That is, while one can prove that there is no physical key to a door on the person, there is no way to prove that one does not know the password.
- cheald 15y agoDoes the UK have an "innocent until proven guilty" provision? If so, wouldn't the onus be on the prosecution to prove that the accused does in fact know the password? You can't prove a universal negative, so the only way that becomes a prosecutable offense is if the initial assumption is of guilt rather than innocence, no?
- dredmorbius 15y agoYes, it does. That's where the US tradition comes from. It's originally derived from Roman law. It's contrasted with Napoleonic code, in which innocence must be proven. It is or was the basis of law in countries conquered under Napoleon, and/or their colonies (e.g.: Mexico).
- oniTony 15y agoNot sure, but there are cases of jailtime. > "Drage was convicted of failing to disclose an encryption key in September." [1] Though it says that he "failed" to disclose a password when asked. Not clear if he was unwilling or unable, and if such a distinction even matters. (It's unclear if the use of the term "refusal" was an actual action, or a journalistic spin. It might come down to needing to be very careful about word choice in such situations; "I would like to speak with my lawyer first" seems like the most appropriate answer). [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-11479831 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-11479831
- fleitz 15y agoYes if you use a lock with a key you can be forced by the court to produce it (if they can satisfy a judge that its in your possession), however, if you use a combination lock you cannot be compelled to testify as to the combination. (IANAL, that's just what I've read)