6 ms·
Well-known indeed (at least, I followed it with keen interest when it came out), but I think it's good that this resurfaces as I really don't think it got enoug
by tripzilch 15y ago
Well-known indeed (at least, I followed it with keen interest when it came out), but I think it's good that this resurfaces as I really don't think it got enough attention the first time around.
Personally I think the most worrying bits of data are first the time stamp, and second the printer serial number.
I say serial number is second because in a criminal investigation phorensics can also get a "fingerprint" of the printer by tracking imperfections in the way it's printed.
But the timestamp of when something was printed is definitely new information that otherwise would not be there and in certain circumstances would not want to be leaked.
- _delirium 15y agoBut the timestamp of when something was printed is definitely new information that otherwise would not be there and in certain circumstances would not want to be leaked. In particular, not only leaked to police, but in the case of printers where the dot pattern's been decoded, to anyone who might care when your document was printed.
- Natsu 15y ago> I think it's good that this resurfaces as I really don't think it got enough attention the first time around. No argument there. I just thought I'd share a lot of what's already known so that we don't have to rediscover it.
- tripzilch 15y agoAbsolutely! If you hadn't posted those links, I would have ;-)
- sliverstorm 15y agoWhy is it a Bad Thing(tm)? Is this more tin-foil-hat stuff...?
- hugh3 15y agoI don't know. Apparently a lot of the people here are master criminals, because they seem to be awfully paranoid about the idea that police detectives can, if sufficiently motivated, deduce some information about their activities. (These sorts of folks must really hate Sherlock Holmes stories.) Personally, as a law-abiding citizen, I'm really not too concerned about being the target of a police investigation, and if I ever am the target of a police investigation I'll be happy to hand over as much evidence as possible since it will assist the police in ascertaining the truth that I am not, in fact, the guilty party.
- lisper 15y agoYou assume that the police care if you are guilty or not. They don't. The quality metric that police work towards is not finding the actual perpetrator, it is finding someone who can be convicted, or, even better, strongarmed into confessing and/or accepting a plea bargain. As a (mostly) law-abiding citizen myself I wish it were otherwise. But it isn't. See e.g. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
- ianterrell 15y agoYou assume that the over three quarters of a million US law enforcement officers act uniformly. What's the statistical significance of a youtube video? (Edit: The question's phrasing is for effect; I'm well aware there are egregious abuses documented in number greater than one. But I'm still not convinced that with the non-uniformity of the LEO population between different jurisdictions, etc, as well as the non-random selection bias, that all the accounts we have of LEO malevolence provide statistical certainty that police, overall, are bad.)
- lisper 15y ago> You assume that the over three quarters of a million US law enforcement officers act uniformly. No, I don't. It only takes one less-than-perfectly-honest cop or prosecutor to totally destroy your life. Just ask Troy Davis. (Oh, wait, you can't. He's dead. He was recently executed for a crime he (almost certainly) did not commit.) Being convicted of a crime you didn't commit may be a risk you're willing to take, but your snide remarks are not justified merely by the fact that others choose not to share your risk posture.
- SteveArmstrong 15y agoThe article postulates that there isn't a timestamp in the pattern of dots because the pattern is consistent on a specific printer, regardless of when the print happened.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"I say serial number is second because in a criminal investigation phorensics can also get a "fingerprint" of the printer by tracking imperfections in the way it's printed." I know they used to be able to do that with typewriters, but can they do it with printers as well? I would suspect the imperfections of being too chaotic, or at least easy enough to change by changing the cartridge.
- SageRaven 15y agoI think it was a Purdue group that documented fingerprinting techniques on scanners and printers. Seems that stepper motors have fairly unique characteristics among models and even individual devices (though, with less accuracy).
- electromagnetic 15y agoAnything helps. Even if you can say it was printed on a Cannon over a HP can potentially narrow things down. I personally don't see what the huge deal is. I mean we're not going to get hauled off for disseminating communist literature and I don't think anyone plans on printing currency. So I don't know where the huge privacy concern whatever comes from, because unless you regularly forge time stamps on documents then I really don't know what the issue is.
- barrkel 15y ago* Government whistleblowers * Large corporation whistleblowers (may have resources to hire PIs with connections to track) * Civil dissent: think Arab Spring, not communist literature. The technology is not restricted to populations living under liberal regimes.
- SageRaven 15y agoIt's too late to edit my post, but I located the group responsible for this research: http://cobweb.ecn.purdue.edu/~prints http://cobweb.ecn.purdue.edu/~prints