5 ms·
> Given that the people who claim ownership and ensure distribution of this map have historically been white and rich representatives of the countries in the no
by rayiner 4y ago
> Given that the people who claim ownership and ensure distribution of this map have historically been white and rich representatives of the countries in the northern hemisphere
This sounds like post hoc race baiting. The Mercator projection was devised in 1569, when Mediterranean countries like Spain, Portugal, and Italy were immensely powerful and pioneers in exploration. Many of the explorers who drew the first world maps came from those countries. If they cared about the relative size of the countries, why would they adopt a projection that makes Scandinavia look so much larger than Spain and Portugal and their holdings in Latin America?
In an effort to find a race angle, the article overlooks important history. The Mercator projection was adopted because it preserved bearing lines for marine navigation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_world_maps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Early_world_maps. World maps were developed primarily by seafaring explorers, so this became the dominant projection, not just in Northern European countries, but pretty much everywhere.
- notahacker 4y agoThe idea that retaining a map which distorting the sizes of countries is a Eurocentric conspiracy against equatorial countries was originally made by Peters when pushing his equal area projection in the 1970s and 80s It's a pretty tendentious argument though, since in addition to it obviously not being the original intent, people don't draw the conclusion that Greenland is a mighty state, the US is subordinate to Canada and the Middle East is a small and inconsequential backwater from map projections, and if people did gauge power and wealth from map projections, the Mercator projection would actually understate the actual relative power and influence of Western Europe anyway (and Peters massively overstates arid underpopulated regions and is barely any better at putting India's sixth of the world population in context). Plus of course, the Mercator projection is still better for local navigation anyway.
- vinay_ys 4y agoThe maps I care about are Google Maps and Apple Maps and the maps used in school classrooms. If I were to zoom out all the way to world map view in Google/Apple Maps, clearly the intent isn't to do navigation but to get relative geographical position/size understanding of various land and water masses. For this, in this era, I would expect them to provide a different projections that are better suited for these purposes.
- scoot 4y agoI agree on your first point, but not your second. In the fourth paragraph it says: "Its purpose was to be used for maritime navigation and it served this purpose well since throughout the projection North is up and South is down, while local shapes and directions are maintained. So when using this projection on a map scaled for navigational use it's easier to find your way." The "solution" presented in the article looks an absolute mess to me though. Surely the better answer is a globe (real or virtual)? Those have existed in schools and homes for almost as long as maps. My children grew up with a LeapFrog globe, and at a young age gould find every country on the planet, by country or capital name. Great fun and highly recommended.
- xyzzyz 4y agoGlobes of size useful for navigation are too big to be convenient when actually navigating. You cannot flat pack globes. They’re just impractical for this purpose.
- scoot 4y agoYou're conflating two different topics. The article asserts (correctly) that the Mercator projection, while useful for navigation, distorts the globe at a macro scale when used for educational purposes. A globe solves that problem.
- xyzzyz 4y agoAh, yes, sorry, I got confused by this thread. Yes, globes are great educational tool. I think it’s actually valuable to show all of globes, Mercator, and the weird equal area projections, just to teach about trade offs.
- toast0 4y agoIt's hard to look at a whole globe at once. It's also hard to have enough globes to see how political boundaries have changed over time. Flat projections are needed for educational purposes too.
- thrown_22 4y ago
- MichaelCollins 4y ago> The Mercator projection was adopted because it preserved bearing lines for marine navigation Specifically, Mercator preserves angles, making it possible to plot courses on the map using a protractor. Attempting this on a map with a non-conformal projection would be a nightmare.
- wolverine876 4y agoYes, though only a tiny percentage of people who use Mercator have ever plotted a course using a protractor.
- whoisburbansky 4y agoIt’s called path dependence; same reason that the Space Shuttle boosters’ width is constrained by the width of two horses’ rear ends put side by side.
- richwater 4y agowat
- paganel 4y agoNot the OP, but after a few web searches I can say he/she was alluding to this [1]: > When you see a Space Shuttle sitting on its launch pad, there are two big booster rockets attached to the sides of the main fuel tank. These are solid rocket boosters, or SRBs. The SRBs are made by Thiokol at their factory in Utah . The engineers who designed the SRBs would have preferred to make them a bit fatter, but they had to be shipped by train from the factory to the launch site. The railroad line from the factory happens to run through a tunnel in the mountains, and the SRBs had to fit through that tunnel. The tunnel is slightly wider than the railroad track, and the railroad track, as you now know, is about as wide as two horses' behinds. I have no idea if that's the real story behind it or not, but it sounds plausible enough. And OP's more general allusion to path dependence [2] is even more interesting, even though less anecdotic. [1] https://www.indiatimes.com/trending/wtf/viral-twitter-thread-horse-ass-railway-track-space-shuttle-376805.html https://www.indiatimes.com/trending/wtf/viral-twitter-thread... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Path_dependence
- wolverine876 4y agoWith loaded issues like racism, more baseless claims just make the problem worse. What we need is evidence, and unfortunately there is almost none in this HN discussion. I've learned nothing about the issue. More broadly, systems can be discriminatory: Using the maps as an example, imagine if a projection made the US look tiny; I don't imagine it would sell well. But if one makes Africa appear tiny, the map may persist for a long time. That's how systems can be discriminatory and how we can decieve ourselves, without conscious intent. Also, there are plenty of people, especially in the past and also in the last few years, who have openly and aggressively expressed intent to discriminate based on race and similar factors, and we can add to that the more subtle expressions. We have plenty of evidence of widespread motive and we should expect many outcomes to match their stated intent. Many people in minority groups have told me, for years, that a large number of people in the US will always deny racism, in every instance. They might say something acknowledging racism generally, but in every specific instance they actively reject it has happened and oppose any action. An argument can always be found (for anything, of course). It's politicized - it's not related to the facts or reason, every claim becomes a political battle that must be won. I didn't believe it at first, but it certainly has been born out, from my perspective. It's a situation that obstructs knowledge, bringing people together, and solutions, and not entirely incidentally: Politicizing any issue is an obvious way to make it similarly intractable (e.g., climate change). EDIT: Maybe it's like any innovation, such as in tech - people react with outrage to any change, as we know well on HN. Which brings us back to facts: People can come up with a plausible argument for anything; hard facts are the scythe that cuts away the 99.9% that is nonsense; that's why science and courtrooms rely on them.
- drekipus 4y agoHave you thought that maybe the hard fact is that the map was made because it's useful and not because of racism?
- HowardStark 4y agoThis completely misses the first point the parent comment made. Even if we agree that the map wasn’t _made_ with racist or discriminatory intent, and hand sound reasoning for existing as it did (preserving angles as another comment mentioned), it doesn’t mean that it’s continued use isn’t discriminatory. The parent comment is explaining that it perhaps became ubiquitous because white/colonial powers happened to be over-represented in scale. And once it is ubiquitous, it can be tough to walk backwards to something like the tetrahedral projection in the OP because anyone who does so in, say, America, would be diminishing America’s physical presence on projection maps.
- tptacek 4y agoPlease don't pick the most provocative thing in an article or post to complain about in the thread. Find something interesting to respond to instead. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html This is one of at least 3 comments on this thread you've added to elevate the dumb political argument and, intentionally or not, strangle any conversation we could have had about geography, navigation, topology, culture, or history. It's the opposite of curious conversation; it's hemlock for curiosity.