4 ms·
I will try it at some point, but I have... feelings... about its abuse of open source licenses software as a learning set. Also I work in Rust these days, and
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
I will try it at some point, but I have... feelings... about its abuse of open source licenses software as a learning set.
Also I work in Rust these days, and use CLion. Not sure if it would be much help in that environment.
- bayindirh 4y agoI left GitHub on the spot, and moved to Source Hut the day Copilot released.
- MichaelMoser123 4y agosomeone can still mirror your stuff on github. I wonder if they should make a special open source license, that disallows use of the source code for the purpose of training something like Copilot.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> I wonder if they should make a special open source license, that disallows use of the source code for the purpose of training something like Copilot. Since Microsoft uses material for copilot outside of licensing on the basis that it is Fair Use, that would probably have no effect in practice on whether or not the material is used in training something like Copilot. For that to matter, you’d first have to win a lawsuit on the basis that training something like Copilot requires permission of the copyright owner of the training material, to invalidate the premise of Microsoft’s action.
- MichaelMoser123 4y ago> Since Microsoft uses material for copilot outside of licensing on the basis that it is Fair Use, that would probably have no effect in practice i think that any formal violation of an open source license would be very bad in terms of public relations - even if they can claim fair use.
- bayindirh 4y agoThey got it covered. Passed the responsibility to user in their official documentation.
- int_19h 4y agoIt's not really an issue when you're a large software corporation; you already have mechanisms in place to check for license compliance in everything that ships, including F/OSS plagiarism checks. I think that's the part that people who don't think it's worth the money aren't getting. This kind of system is godsend for the likes of Infosys, TCS etc. So the immediate threat is to the jobs there - but the side effect is that it'll make it all even cheaper, so we'll see more "outsourcing to the cloud", so to speak. Often to the obvious detriment of quality, but that doesn't seem to matter in this market.
- shagie 4y agoOf note, a non-human cannot hold a copyright. Anything generated by copilot, which if it is a derivative work, is not something that copilot can hold the copyright on. From the auditor's perspective it doesn't matter if you copied it out of stack overflow, from some GitHub search, or copilot. You, the human, didn't check the license / plagiarism detecter. It is you, the human, claiming copyright on the work you are creating which may incorporate material from other sources. Copilot isn't claiming fair use. You could argue that the model that copilot runs from is a derivative work (and this is going to be interesting when it gets to the courts, because, frankly no one will come out the 'winner' on this when trying to explain it to a judge) - but that's not the code that a human is claiming to be their creative work and is ultimately the license violation. Personally, I (not a lawyer), believe that copilot is on ok ground - but anyone using it needs to do their due diligence in verifying that the code that they've incorporated is licensed appropriately - just as if they've copied something from Stack Overflow - who knows where that copied was copied from. I have less concerns with identifiable code from copilot than humans not caring about the licenses of their source material in creating human generated content.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI don't care about all the handwaving here, it comes down to this. The moment a fragment of code from a GPL'd or AGPL'd project shows up almost verbatim in someone's closed source or non-copylefted, etc. project, and someone proves it, sparks are going to fly. And it's probably already happening, just people haven't discovered it yet. How many years did the Oracle/Google lawsuit go on for? And in the end about a handful of a lines of code only tangentially related to the issue at hand? Part of the lesson from that must be: employers should be telling their workers to say TF away from Copilot or things like it. And be careful in general when browsing source. License literacy is critical. I don't touch it because I need to feed my kids. I don't need my career exploded. Overcautious? Maybe. I'll let someone else find out. I make a living in and around open source software.
- bayindirh 4y ago> The moment a fragment of code from a GPL'd or AGPL'd project shows up almost verbatim in someone's closed source or non-copylefted, etc. project, and someone proves it, sparks are going to fly. I'm hoarding popcorn and can't wait for that, honestly. > License literacy is critical. It's beyond critical, but most people I have talked says that they see the right to copy and use any code they see online. They don't care. Building this open source corpus was not easy, and we need to defend it too. This is a culture.
- pabs3 4y agoDidn't it already happen that it spat out a function from Quake? And they then dealt with that by banning the particular function. ISTR that Amazon's version of copilot has licensing info output too.
- gopher_space 4y agoIf it's your creation you can make your own license. Copy and paste a license you like and add a few lines. This fact solves many "we need this lib but it's too open" problems. The author can make a special license just for you if they want.
- bayindirh 4y agoAs in this example: https://web.archive.org/web/20130203112329/http://dev.hasenj.org/post/3272592502 https://web.archive.org/web/20130203112329/http://dev.hasenj...
- bayindirh 4y ago> Someone can still mirror your stuff on github. It is the nature of the beast, however I make my stance clear and stand by my principles. It is equally important for me.
- scoot 4y agoI guess any "abuse" is the fact that any code reproduced verbatim doesn't carry the license under which it was originally published. But the reality is that what Copilot is most useful for is (semi) intelligent autocomplete, and generating functions that almost certainly exist as StackOverflow answers. It won't do any thinking for you when it comes to the bigger picture.
- sidlls 4y agoHow is it abusive?
- Guest42 4y agoIt was trained using source code whose licenses don't permit such usage.
- skybrian 4y agoThis is unclear. I have never seen an open source license that was explicit about this. Seems like a grey area. It's not even clear how often training machine learning algorithms on code results in copyright violations. CoPilot does have a setting to detect and disallow direct copying, but how well does it work? This legal uncertainty is enough that I wouldn't advise using it, but maybe people who use it will be fine?
- int_19h 4y agoIt's messy enough it's likely to end up a Supreme Court case in US (and I wouldn't want to be a party to it). Europeans will probably preempt that with legislation.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sidlls 4y agoIn what sense? Copilot isn’t a derivative work in the sense these licenses usually are understood to mean. And given that they’re open source code bases I expect licenses to explicitly disallow things, and consider anything not explicitly disallowed as permitted.
- teddyh 4y ago> Copilot isn’t a derivative work in the sense these licenses usually are understood to mean The phrase “derived work” is, IIUC, a phrase from copyright law. And you’d have a hard time convincing me that Copilot-generated code is not a derived work from its training data. > And given that they’re open source code bases I expect licenses to explicitly disallow things, and consider anything not explicitly disallowed as permitted. That is very much not how copyright and licences work. Copyright law gives the copyright holder the exclusive right to make copies of the work, making derived works, (and to do some other related things, like making a public performance of it, etc.), so to do any of those things, you need explicit permission, i.e. a license from the copyright holder to do it. A license is not a list of things you are forbidden to do; on the contrary, it is a list of things you are permitted to do, which you would not otherwise be legally allowed to do according to copyright law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wokwokwok 4y agoIt works fine in clion with rust. The completions are often more “similar to stuff I’ve typed before” rather than “generate this working function”, and it’s not an order of magnitude improvement over just regular intellij completion. …but I find it’s generally better. Up to you if you consider it worth the cost of paying for it, and the macro completion is so-so, but “its rust so copilot can’t do it” isn’t really true.