3 ms·
Some courses really are required bullshit to some students. A lot of professors don't realize this, but if you teach a required course, it is simple math to sa
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
Some courses really are required bullshit to some students. A lot of professors don't realize this, but if you teach a required course, it is simple math to say that some of your students just don't need to learn what you are teaching. Sure, a lot of students do need it but don't think they do, but a good fraction of the class does not need to learn the content you are teaching.
The only remaining question is how to engage these people. I have seen good approaches to that problem and really, really terrible approaches, and it seems that most professors go for the terrible approaches. Unfortunately, engaging people who don't want to be there is a lot harder than just having a bunch of required tests.
These students are not all wrong that some courses are BS hoops to jump through. Meet them in the middle. Teach them something.
- busyant 4y agoI know a lot of what I teach is not really relevant to students who aren't chemistry majors--I even say this UP FRONT at the beginning of the course. I tell the students that they should think of the course as a way of assessing whether they can think logically and critically about "weird things." Because life is full of weird things that need logical and critical analysis. In general, they appreciate my candor. That being said, in my experience, the students who cheat often delude themselves into thinking that they understand the material--and they really don't.* Then they seem shocked when they take a certification exam (where they have to leave phones at the door and are closely monitored) and they bomb the exam.* * I'm speaking in generalities here. I'm sure there are some cheaters who are being "smart" about their cheating.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIn the time I was at school, I heard of a lot more cheating than would be justified solely by people conserving time. I have recently seen studies that argue that 50-80% of students cheat at some point, and something like 10-20% cheat in every course they take. Personally, when I conserved time, I just accepted the bad grades - it was easier than trying to cheat and not get caught. The OP was talking about students cheating because they are not engaged with the material. I think that's only part of the problem with cheating: there are lots of other factors, like pressure to get a high GPA.
- Izkata 4y agoOne of my psychology professors had an alternative: The course I took was required for psych majors, but was also interesting-sounding and worked as an elective for non-psych majors, so at the start of the semester she announced to every one of her students that psych majors should switch to the 3-days-a-week one to get the in-depth knowledge they'll need for the rest of their major, and non-psych majors should switch to the 2-days-a-week one to get the watered-down version. The two classes would explicitly be held to different standards, because this way the non-psych majors wouldn't have to keep up with the psych majors. And the psych majors were warned that if they tried to take the easy out, they'd fall behind later on.