3 ms·
My engineering and physics intuition came from understanding the math behind it. For example, I've seen a lot of handwavy explanations of how jet engines worked
by WalterBright 4y ago
My engineering and physics intuition came from understanding the math behind it. For example, I've seen a lot of handwavy explanations of how jet engines worked, but understanding eluded me until I went through the math in jet engine class.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoDifferent strokes for different folks. Michael Faraday was brilliant and driven, but his intuition did not come from understanding the math as he was famously math-illiterate. On a personal note, the subject I had the most trouble with was classic electromagnetism (calc-based freshman physics): It was the first time I hit a wall/limit on what I could grasp. The wall was because I could never couldn’t develop an intuition for the physics behind it.
- dannymi 4y ago>The wall was because I could never couldn’t develop an intuition for the physics behind it. On the off chance that you can understand German, check out chapter 9.1.1 Fluidvolumen und Divergenz (until and including chapter 11 Erhaltung der Energie), in the book Einführung Theoretische Meteorologie by Michael Hantel (ISBN 978-3-8274-3055-7). It even uses a car analogy ;) You will understand fluid dynamics, and by extension electrodynamics, like you never did before. And it will teach you the physical intuition first. This book was such a lucky find for me ten years ago. Equation (11.3) is the fluid analogon to the continuity equation (in electrodynamics that is: ∂/∂t ρ + ∇⃗⋅J⃗ = 0)--and you can see how, physically, you get to it, and what the parts and the whole mean. Lots of diagrams and geometry and simple analogies make that take about 30 pages.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tekla 4y agoCan you elaborate? Im and Aero and while there is a defo a bunch of math involved suck, squeeze, bang, blow is pretty much the gist of how jet engines work and I don't find it really all that hand-wavy, its just a funny way of describing gas pressure and velocity graphs.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe hand-wavy explanations never explained why the exhaust went out the back rather than the front and the back.
- melony 4y agoDo elaborate. The most funky differential I know comes from EE's Maxwell eqns (how capacitors work, and weird ideas about "ground").
- WalterBright 4y agoThe compressor up front produces enough pressure to prevent the exhaust going out that way. Another way to see it is you cannot start a turbine by dumping fuel in and igniting it. The turbine has to be spun up first, usually with an electric motor. The Me262 engines had an ingenious tiny gas engine in the nacelle which served that purpose, complete with a little handle to start it! Next time you're on a jet, watch them do the engine start. You can see it slowly gaining speed, then suddenly it dramatically speeds up - that's when the fuel gets squirted in and ignited. Anyhow, jet engines look deceptively simple. But they are real masterpieces of engineering.