4 ms·
What!? This is just incorrect. They aren't creating light from vacuum - they are simply creating light in exactly the same way that antennas create light. Ant
by ars 15y ago
What!?
This is just incorrect. They aren't creating light from vacuum - they are simply creating light in exactly the same way that antennas create light.
Antennas create light (electromagnetic energy) by vibrating electrons at the same frequency of the light they want to create.
Here they are also vibrating electrons at the frequency of light. "several billions of times a second" - frequency of microwaves? Ghz. Exactly the same.
Accelerating an electron (actually any charged particle) creates light. For example: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchrotron_radiation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchrotron_radiation You can shake the electron, force it to curve, anything and it will radiate light.
I've often thought that this would be an awesome way to make a laser if you could find a material you can vibrate fast enough.
- tsotha 15y ago>I've often thought that this would be an awesome way to make a laser if you could find a material you can vibrate fast enough. Isn't that a free electron laser?
- ars 15y agoBasically, yah. Although I was thinking more of vibrating the electrons in place, the principle is exactly the same.
- Sharlin 15y agoUmm, I'd like to give the scientists involved a benefit of the doubt. The probability that they don't know what they're doing is much lower than the probability that a popularized article about their study is incomplete and/or inaccurate. The actual paper is available at arxiv and is quite readable: http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.4714 http://arxiv.org/abs/1105.4714
- ars 15y agoWell the actual experiment was awesome - full credit for that. I just don't buy that you need to explain it using virtual photons that bounce of the mirror. They do write: "A mirror moving in a finite EM field then losses energy as the screening currents will emit EM radiation, as in an antenna." And then say you need vacuum fluctuations to explain it still happening without an EM field. And explain it as the vacuum having a random EM field that is acting on the mirror. I guess that's not quite the same as "virtual photons bouncing on a mirror". But since a charged mirror requires no extra field, and since their mirror basically is charge, I really don't see the need to bring in virtual photons here.
- aufreak3 15y agoIt would be very surprising if quantum mechanics didn't add up to the normal classical world we experience or to classical theories we use because they work. The story and explanations at the small level can have a totally different nature though. Another way to put it might be this - you say "accelerating electrons creates light", but how? Classical electrodynamics is one explanation, but it cannot explain all related phenomena. At small enough levels, you find details (like photons appearing in pairs) that need a different sort of theory to explain it. What then would you say about the path integral explanation of a mirror that needs all sorts of particle creation and destruction, including particles moving backwards in time, to explain what the mirror "does" even when it isn't moving?