7 ms·
Unconscious bias in media interviews with female top managers
- Ozzie_osman 4y agoThey are talking about media interviews, not job interviews (which may not be what you expect if you're seeing this on HN)
- zx8080 4y ago"What journalists has to do with job interviews??"
- verisimi 4y agoUnconscious bias occurs everywhere, with all people, all the time. What of it? What I see is a great example of how 'science' can serve political agendas; an example of an answer seeking a question. If you study 'unconscious bias' with regard to women, or race, or age, or whatever other worthy cause, what do you think you will find? The answer is baked into the question! I've no doubt you could also study unconscious bias from a Marxist perspective too, but how does this help us understand anything, except our own preconceived biases in undertaking the study?
- jonsen 4y ago"As communications experts, we can make an important contribution to an equally authentic and individual representation of women and men in their leadership positions by uncovering biases and creating awareness." What exactly is bad about this agenda?
- kaczordon 4y agoI think because it’s assuming an outcome before the results? I’d say everyone is for people of both genders being treated equally.
- eulenteufel 4y ago> I’d say everyone is for people of both genders being treated equally. But this is not true, historically, and still today. Most people in (in some cultures) may be for treating genders equally in a lot of aspects, but I don't have to go very far on the web or IRL to find people who are not for equal treatment of genders. But for everyone who does want to treat genders equally, learning about unconcious bias should be helpful. Learning about unconcious biases enables you to question your behaviour in order to actually treat genders equal instead of just agreeing that they should be.
- boppo1 4y agoWhat about people who, themselves, do not want to be treated equally? I have found that most women I interact with do not necessarily want to be treated equally, they want to be treated with dignity and respect. These are sometimes, but often not the same thing.
- eulenteufel 4y agoSure if people want to be treated differently go ahead. But observing some women wanting to be treated differently (this step can go wrong!) and then applying that treatment to other women is a whole different thing.
- sokoloff 4y agoI see plenty of examples where gender-blind treatment does not appear to be the goal of people. Some of these are biased against women while others are biased in favor of them.
- Banana699 4y agoBecause it's one-sided and unscientific. The kind of feminist-infected soft fields that make up those terms and agendas (HR, "Communication Studies",...) only really care about women, and by 'caring' about women I really mean they care very much about how easy it's for women to be corporate drones while thinking it's "Empowering". Have you ever heard about "Unconscious Bias Against Men"? Of course not, nobody gives a shit about men. It's unscientific because the conclusion is already formed before the data is gathered. Women get more questions about family than men? That must mean that the interviewers think women are baby factories unfit for work, SEXISM. Women get less questions about family than men? That must mean that the interviewers think career-driven women are barren and childless and without prospect for having a family of their own, SEXISM. No matter what happens, they have already made up their mind, women are oppressed. The "experiments" and the "data" is just a dress up game to make it look as if they're doing serious science.
- boppo1 4y agoI think you're close but missing some important info. An enormous amount of women have faced unfair (or worse) situations with negative (or worse) personal outcomes for just the fact of being women. We can fairly call that oppression I think. The promoters of the disputed language, in light of the priors, mis-apply* probable reasoning such that for any case of a negative outcome for a woman, it must be oppression. *in some cases intentionally, in some cases unintentionally
- Banana699 4y ago>An enormous amount of women have faced unfair (or worse) situations with negative (or worse) personal outcomes for just the fact of being women. You can replace 'women' in this statment by any number of other group tags and still preserve the truth of the statment : -------- An enormous amount of men have faced unfair (or worse) situations with negative (or worse) personal outcomes for just the fact of being men, like - forced military service, - genital mutilation (amusing fact : searching this term in google only turns up results about female genital mutilation in all pages), - and child labor. I leave it as an exercise to you how you can correctly apply the template to a random group label of your choosing. -------- So 'Women Most Affected' sentiments like yours serve only to illustrate the curious asymmetry with which injustice against men and injustice against women are treated. An asymmetry that, while not created by feminism and allied ideologies, is certainly much exploited and streamlined and stroked by them. >The promoters of the disputed language Oh, but it isn't a problem of language. The inherent delusion of feminism is that women are especially oppressed, in ways that fundamentally differ quantitatively and qualitatively from men. Expressing this delusion in any language will output biased and dumb nonsense, lobbyism dressed up as 'fighting for justice'. In other words, you can't say 'Women Most Affected' in more intelligent or naunced language. Every way of expressing a delusion will turn out to be ridicoulous and unfair and easily-detected.
- boppo1 4y ago'Biases' is a poorly defined term. So is the goal of 'creating awareness. In most cases, given historical persecution of 'othered' identities, people understand that agenda as a positive thing and it certainly is. However, it also gives cover to people to play power games, treat others like shit, and feel morally righteous about it. "I'm just expanding your awareness about your unconscious biases. I'm helping you."
- wesleywt 4y ago
- Crabber 4y agoThe term "unconscious bias" is based on the (false) assumption that every group of human is exactly identical. It is 100% a political term that is shoved at people to make them feel like a bad person for noticing differences where there actually are differences. If you want to eliminate "unconscious bias" you are trying to create a society where women talk to men in the exact same way that they talk to other women, women act the exact same way around attractive men as they do around ugly men, adults talk to a 5 year old the same way that they would talk to a 95 year old. i.e. a delusional utopia that is completely detached from nature and reality, and which has never existed in any society.
- refurb 4y agoThis guy gets it. "Unconscious bias" is so embedded in corporate-speak today that nobody has stopped to actually challenge its existence or the proposed solutions. Plus the "evidence" for such bias is so shaky ("Bill said I'm raising my voice, but he only said that because I'm a woman") it can be "found" or "dismissed" very easily, depending on what political goals you have. I find it odd that we attempt to somehow reshape the innate human psyche (which is constantly taking in information and making assumptions based on them), rather than just enforce workplace rules around how you treat people. Seems like a bit more direct, objective and actionable than diving into some deep conversation about "unconscious bias". But regardless, the real answer why this is being discussed is: 1) HR is told it needs to be done [usually because some other company is doing it], 2) it provides cover again lawsuits if employees sue over workplace harassment and 3) it's a moneymaking business for the consultants that teach these class [a lot of money].
- xiphias2 4y agoIt’s also profitable for both companies and governments (income tax) to make women delay staying with a baby at home and focus on work instead in their most fertile and productive age (late 20s, early 30s). For men you don’t need extra motivation, as they are not making this choice anyways. They can feed the lie of ,,having lots of time to have a baby later’’, and I’m seeing many women at age 40 realizing that no man wants to start making a baby with her at that age, because it’s just biologically not practical.
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoThe whole point of science is to eliminate unconscious bias. Eliminating unconscious wrong beliefs about the world is literally why science is a thing.
- boppo1 4y agoSure, but many would argue that social science regularly fails to meet contemporaneous standards for epistemological rigor that physical sciences do. Try to quantify or define unconscious bias. How many dimensions does it have? Are there any provable social laws (in the sense of theorem::law, not lawyer::law)?
- Kye 4y ago>> "Sure, but many would argue that social science regularly fails to meet contemporaneous standards for epistemological rigor that physical sciences do." Many would argue, but what's their qualification? Where's the meta research implied in your comment that supports your view that social science regularly fails to meet contemporaneous standards for epistemological rigor that physical sciences do?
- boppo1 4y agoI don't have meta research. It is unnecessary given any individual can make the observations themselves by trying to answer the questions I asked. Physics, math, chemistry, they all obey laws and phenomena can rigorously proven (more or less). There are no identifiable social axioms. Science is not about expert qualifications, it is about asking questions.
- neilv 4y agoThis is for German media. Does anyone know of good similar research on US media? I first noticed sexism in the US business press around the start of dotcoms, in how Kim Polese was sometimes portrayed. I mentioned it in a comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29062715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29062715 I even saw it around then with how a popular science education program treated a female colleague. For all the other scientists featured on the show, it was about the work, until they got to her, then they switched format, to having the show's host in practically a romantic candlelight dinner with the female scientist. (I think there's probably a place to affirm that people can do science and embrace whatever other aspects of human experience that they choose, but this particular show's context I think might've sent an unintended message to kids, that a woman's looks are more important than her work.)
- xbar 4y agoI don't know of any. I wonder if the German gap in unconscious bias between female executives and female entrepreneurs holds true in the US.
- HL33tibCe7 4y agoI noticed something similar recently when watching women’s football during the Euros. The commentators - who by the way aren’t sexist, this isn’t a conscious thing - would make comments that they would _never_ make about a male player. My (least) favourite example, among many: “her mum is in the crowd tonight and would be so proud”.
- formerly_proven 4y agoThe wonderfully simple German language has a nuance with pronouns where you can use an article as a pronoun, which is something you might do when referring to an animal. I noticed commentators doing this a lot when referring to female athletes, but when they talk about male athletes they use normal pronouns. And a lot of comments in general that just make you think "WTF?".
- 7steps2much 4y agoDo you mean f.e. using "die" or "eine" instead of "sie"? If so then I can chip in with similiar observations down in Austria and southern Germany, though overwhelmingly with males, using "der" instead of "er". Though of course I may have missunderstood what you are actualy referring to.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sebzim4500 4y agoI've definitely heard that said about a male player, I'm not sure why you think they wouldn't. I haven't even watched much football, only Euros and World Cups.
- sokoloff 4y agoIt’s extremely common in college (American) football to mention that a player’s family is attending and often cut to showing them. I’ve seen it in NFL and MLB games as well.
- bronikowski 4y ago
- zx8080 4y ago> unconscious bias How much unconscious in journalist's understanding that it'a a man or woman is in front? From what I see, women usually talk differently with women than with men. Probably it's natural (or not?).
- psychphysic 4y agoIt also doesn't make sense as a claim. Who's said it's unconscious? It might not only be entirely conscious but desirable.
- fzfaa 4y agoAnd men also talk differently with other men than with women. And that's completely natural and adequate and not something that has to be fixed.
- listless 4y agoNot sure why this is getting downvoted - it’s ABSOLUTELY true. And if you think it isn’t, ask yourself, would you rather see a female counselor or a male one? I personally prefer to talk about personal topics with women. I don’t feel as comfortable opening up on that stuff around men - even though I am one.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- buzzwords 4y agoI have to say, I do think I have judged my female managers more harshly than I have my male ones. Maybe it was because it was easier to communicate with male ones. Anyone else retrospectively think they might have been unfair to their female managers?
- kentrado 4y agoMixed bag. I had good ones and bad ones. However, the bad ones were worse than bad male managers. I noticed that they were exceptionally aggressive. Perhaps I am better at enduring bad male managers than their female counterparts.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoIt's fairly common for women to come across as aggressive for doing exactly the same things a man would.
- AdrianB1 4y agoThis is because historically aggressiveness is a male attribute, so when it is present in women it stands out and the perception is amplified. It is the same when a woman is as tall as a man, for example.
- buzzwords 4y agoIs the reverse true too? Female attributes on a male is amplified?
- rauljara 4y agoIt does seem like things are getting better, but certainly when I was growing up almost any behavior the slightest bit feminine in a male was called out as “gay”. The phrases “act like a man” or “real man” are often not just valorizing masculine traits but admonishing feminine ones. So, I’d say very yes.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoI hired my boss, she was the best boss ever.
- pc86 4y agoWhat does this have to do with journalists' treatment of women executives and founders?
- KingOfCoders 4y agoI'm not a journalist.
- pc86 4y agoYeah that's my point. Your comment doesn't have anything to do with the article.
- AdrianB1 4y ago> When interviewing female top managers, female journalists address private topics such as family or childhood more frequently than male journalists. This is just a sign that male journalists are self-censoring when taking interviews, not that they are not interested. We do the same with job interviews, it is obvious when doing panel interviews and some interviewers are men and some are women: the women can ask anything they want, while for men it is considered inappropriate to ask some questions.
- Tepix 4y agoBut why don't the women ask these questions to male managers then? It's clearly a bias.
- fatherzine 4y agoBiology is biased. Basic stuff, pregnancy and lactation. Then there are emotional issues, the special bond between the mother and her infants, which can lead to life-long emotional disability issues, if not handled properly. See e.g. https://positivepsychology.com/attachment-theory https://positivepsychology.com/attachment-theory "This provided a clear indication that emotional attachment in infancy, gained through cuddling, affected the monkey’s later responses to stress and emotion regulation (Herman, 2012)." Sadly, we run our society by Powerpoint, obsessively focusing on a handful of poorly measured metrics. We have trained entire generations to reflexively point out any differences in those metrics as "bias", with a very negative connotation. Edit: Consider using a less charged word, e.g. "difference". It is only human to give women space to be women.
- kleiba 4y ago
- rob_c 4y agoIsn't this the risk of "free form" rather than pre structured interviews and something that is easily fixable by changing interview style?
- bobcostas55 4y agoI don't really understand on what basis they're making the claim that these differences are due to unconscious biases. The entire thing seems to be completely made up.
- treis 4y agoI agree. I tried to dig into the methodology. Best I can tell they rated on 84 points and showed the handful that were different. Also ignored what the person being interviewed said. That seems like an odd omission given that they have a significant impact on where the interview goes.
- todd8 4y agoNote that their website[1] depicts twice as many working women as men (more precisely 9 women and 5 men). Perhaps due to an unconscious bias? [1] https://fgsglobal.com/what-we-do https://fgsglobal.com/what-we-do
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- norwalkbear 4y agoI'm not surprised. People are different. I've been part of studies throughout the game industry, the highest performing engineering teams are usually males of similar cultural background. But it's so unpc, we avoid hiring them directly. We usually hire them thru their consulting groups for the very difficult engine tasks
- karpierz 4y agoWhere did you get that from the article? It's not saying "women are different than men", it's saying "journalists treat female managers less professionally than male ones".
- pc86 4y agoAnd also that "journalists treat female executives at established companies more critically than female founders" which is an interesting and perhaps somewhat counterintuitive point.
- yrgulation 4y agoProbably wanted to push for this: “males of similar cultural background”. Cant even begin to imagine the toxicity of that place.
- muglug 4y agoHaving spent 20 years writing code, I have no idea how to measure “performance”. Is it “lines of code written”? Is it “technical debt addressed”? Is it a measure of how many engineers grew in those roles? Does it measure how many engineers burned out after a year? Does it measure projects with reasonable starting estimates? Does it focus only on the products that sold well, or does it also include games that bombed?
- norwalkbear 4y agoWhen it's industry specific it's easier to measure. Game engines are very specialized beasts that have a very high degree of math, physics, and algos for shortcuts. Then getting it working on very specific hardware.
- _8j50 4y agoIs it really unconscious? Isn't it a given that how you come off would dictate how others interact with you? And isn't it obvious that women have different countenance than men? I am not justifying it mind you, I am just pointing out that gender is not special in this rather explicit bias that you are expected to be a certain type if a person based on appearance. I hope it isn't appropriate to say this but I would be interested to see how biased interviews are when the woman is a lesbian who wears masculines clothing (jeans or plaid shirt or a manly suit). Would they still ask about family and such?
- Robotbeat 4y agoIsn’t the incentive of journalists to report an interesting story part of the blame, here? Female execs are less common. So a journalist might be interested in sprucing up the narrative of their article by doing more background on “what it’s like to be a female executive in a male dominated field” (etc). Journalists are not purely focused on objective, fact-based inquiry. They’re almost always trying to weave a story and if there’s something socially unusual (for a given context) about someone, they have incentive to ask about that. More clicks for a human interest story about a “woman in a man’s world” than yet another male executive. I won’t make a value judgement about whether or not that’s appropriate here, but I think that’s a pretty important part of the equation if we’re going to consider this individual sexism or not (because it has to do with the incentives in journalism generally, not necessarily with individual journalists). I’m sure the question “Have you experienced sexism in your workplace?” is more commonly asked of female executives.