4 ms·
Hard to address without getting overtly political, but much of it comes down to what happened with the rise of right-wing mass media. "Indoctrination" is not t
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Hard to address without getting overtly political, but much of it comes down to what happened with the rise of right-wing mass media. "Indoctrination" is not too strong a word to use. If Fox News had never existed, the Republican Party would have had to invent it.
Some would argue that the loss of the FCC's Fairness Doctrine contributed, but I see that as a non-starter. It would never have applied to cable news or to the Internet, only to broadcast media, and in any case it would only have given the fallacy of "both sides-ism" more credibility than it has already.
As far as what it will take to restore the status quo and return at least a veneer of civility to partisan politics, I have no idea. It probably can't be restored. A good start might be to force news outlets to declare themselves as either "News" or "Entertainment," rather than the unholy hybrids we have now that exist to spread lies, incite violence, and issue misleading talking points under the guise of commentary. But that has obvious 1A implications. Again, it could have been justified as a public-interest requirement for over-the-air broadcast outlets, but that ship has sailed.
- jfengel 4y agoIf Fox News had never existed, the Republican Party would have had to invent it. The Republican Party did invent it. It is owned by an Australian media magnate, but its first CEO was Roger Ailes, a media consultant to the Republican party.
- r00fus 4y agoWhy do you think the Fairness Doctrine wouldn't have been applied to cable/internet (eventually)? TBH, I think the loss of Fairness Doctrine, Citizens United decision, etc are all skirting the real issue: the concept that corporations are people. Not enshrined in law, but from old Supreme Court decision in 1886. Make corporations non-people (or limit their personhood aggressively) and you can actually punish them effectively without a corporate death penalty which is never used.
- CamperBob2 4y agoThe ability of the FCC to exercise enforcement power over broadcast content, seemingly in defiance of the First Amendment, is a tradeoff that OTA broadcasters have to accept in exchange for their station licenses. In exchange for being granted a legally-enforced monopoly over a given frequency for a given geographical area, they agree to carry programming that's considered to be in the public interest, and to adhere to strict content regulations. Cable networks and websites don't require these monopoly privileges, so they aren't, and shouldn't be, required to adhere to broadcast content standards.