3 ms·
ICS's core apps can be as slick and beautiful as they want, but app developers need to keep up, and I'm not convinced they will. I have a Windows Phone, largel
by untog 15y ago
ICS's core apps can be as slick and beautiful as they want, but app developers need to keep up, and I'm not convinced they will.
I have a Windows Phone, largely as an experiment at seeing if I like it or not. The UI is amazing on the core apps. The People, Music and Email apps are second to none. But almost every third party app I download gets something wrong (often most things wrong), and it's very jarring when you're expecting things to match a very defined UI flow.
The fact that Android already has a ton of existing apps might make this even worse. Ditching the menu button and swapping it for an action bar is a great idea, but how long until all the app makers change their apps over? I think this is less of a problem on the iPhone because Apple vets their apps so heavily (and rejects ones that do not obey UI guidelines), but neither Google nor Microsoft seem to do that.
- ConstantineXVI 15y agoWinPhone has the "problem"[1] of going down a rather different UI path vs. Apple and Google. You see this in a less extreme form on Android quite a bit, where apps will use (often badly-made) custom iOS-style widgets (the bottom nav bar, usually) that just don't fit in Android's patterns. WinPhone has even fewer patterns in common, thus when a dev tries to bring over iOS or Android patterns, it shows. [1] It's a "problem" as it's not what devs/users are used to working with, not a problem because of flawed design (FTR, I rather like it)
- wallflower 15y ago> Ditching the menu button and swapping it for an action bar is a great idea, but how long until all the app makers change their apps over? If you don't go the ActionBar, ViewPager (swipe between views) route, your app will quickly begin to look dated. For the definition of "dated", I am using Google Music as the reference for current Android user experience. Plus, upgrading the app forces the developers to move to the current state of the art Loader (instead of AsyncTask) and Fragments (instead of activities)