4 ms·
Assuming these genetic causes fully explain autism (ie. there are no environmental factors), does that suggest that the percentage of the population with autism
by londons_explore 4y ago
Assuming these genetic causes fully explain autism (ie. there are no environmental factors), does that suggest that the percentage of the population with autism has remained approximately constant throughout recent history because it is caused by random mutations?
- autosharp 4y agoNo. All mutations are random. In the past, ASD might have been more or less adaptive than it is today.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoTo be clear, mutations are random, but polymorphisms are not.
- atwood22 4y agoThere is a correlation between the father’s age and ASD. People are having kids older now, so the answer is no, it’s unlikely that the percentage of people with ASD is constant throughout history.
- stu2010 4y agoThis paper is looking at both inherited genes, that is genes that you get from your parents, and de-novo mutations, that is a mutation that only the offspring has, that wasn't directly copied from a parent. We've known for a while that autism is highly heritable. This paper builds on a large body of work that links specific genes to autism's heritability. I haven't dug into the specific breakdown, but my understanding is that a majority of genetic variants associated with autism are inherited, rather than the random de-novo (new) mutations.
- bena 4y agoHere's a fun one. We will never know how common dyslexia was throughout history. Literacy is recent. In the 1970s roughly 35% of the population was still illiterate. Go back further and you're looking at 10% or less. Most signs were pictorial. A blacksmith was denoted by an anvil, a tailor by a spool and needle, etc. If you were dyslexic, you'd never know. Autism is likely in a similar boat. Those individuals with less disruptive traits could probably find themselves doing well. Possibly joined the priesthood where they can apply their focus creating manuscripts. Or become hermits, where they could live somewhere less stimulating. Whereas those individuals with highly disruptive traits were probably treated quite poorly. Crammed into sanitariums or confined to monasteries to exorcise whatever evil spirit may have possessed them. Or simply died from being rejected by their families. We can't really know. We can probably safely assume that while our knowledge of autism is new, it itself is not new.