4 ms·
The physical nature of sexuality isn't an issue that affects many > the frequency of intersex is almost certainly less than 0.02% is the quote in the paper.
by defrost 4y ago
The physical nature of sexuality isn't an issue that affects many
> the frequency of intersex is almost certainly less than 0.02%
is the quote in the paper.
( More broadly, the 'restricted' definition falls just under that percentage:
> "conditions in which chromosomal sex is inconsistent with phenotypic sex, or in which the phenotype is not classifiable as either male or female", the prevalence of intersex is about 0.018%
)
However on a societal scale it is sufficient number of people to present issues that need addressing.
1 in 2,000 is 10 in 20,000 is 100 in 200,000 is 1,000 in 2 million (the ~ pop. of my state capital city) is 10,000 at least in Australia (now well past 20 million).
This is more than enough to justify the changes to the Australian passport system made decades ago, expanding what was previously a forced binary choice to better represent actual reality.
And yet, our author of the linked paper still moves to claim:
> This has not stopped the misconception that “sex is not binary” from spreading, ...
mere paragraphs after agreeing on the frequency of the clearly non binary people.
- fallingknife 4y agoBinary with a 0.02% error rate
- defrost 4y agoBetter discription (roughly) of the purely physical case. ie. Not binary - and can't be accurately represented as such on medical forms and other places with things matter. You might also say these cases are much more frequent than gold in the crust.
- Retr0id 4y agoYou are writing a client for an API, to be deployed at scale. The API returns objects of type A or B, but occasionally returns something else - not as an error, it's just what happens to be in the server's database. You'd still write code and test-cases to deal with the not-A-or-B instances, right?
- thrown_22 4y ago>You'd still write code and test-cases to deal with the not-A-or-B instances, right? I've seen this one before. It was called the something something solution and was very popular in Germany a while back.
- fallingknife 4y agoBut this is not an API and it is a disorder so equivalent to an error. But who says you wouldn't want to handle it in either case?
- implements 4y agoSex, the process in humans where anisogamy (sexual reproduction involving two types of gametes that differ in size) produces new humans is a binary one. Notwithstanding disorders of sexual development (‘intersex’) there are only two gametes, and hence only two sexes.
- OrangeMonkey 4y agoYour math is slightly wrong. .018% of 2000 is about 1/3 (.36). So, its 1 in 6k and 3600 in Australia. The numbers are miniscule and I believe arguments made using this group and trying to apply it to society as a whole is likely not made in good faith. I would be willing to bet that most people who bring up intersex individuals when talking about a 'sex binary' would be unwilling to agree to: "We have male, female, and medically-intersex as the sex."
- thrown_22 4y agoSimilarly we have one headed and two headed individuals. Therefore we must use the plural they as the default pronoun as to not cause offense to people already struggling with acceptance.
- defrost 4y agoI skimmed his paper and then reread other papers I have on intersex .. the frequency estimates vary but we're ballpaking. The key thing is that is lower bound as 0.18% comes from a fairly well accepted restrive definition of intersex, there's a larger pool of "commonly accepted as intersex". So, we can at least agree that these people exist. > I believe arguments made using this group and trying to apply it to society as a whole is likely not made in good faith. That's your belief of what others are trying to do and I believe you may be misrepresenting and casting as homogeneous these "others". Your in good comapny here, the author of the paper does the same in his initial paragraphs when casts "feminists" as a near monolith with a predominant belief. Clearly he hasn't gotten out much. Fo my part I'm a pragmatic data science, mainly geophyics with a dash of consulting. I take issue with livestock tracking software that cannot accept by design in breeding patterns - this is something that happens in reality. I also take issue with older versions of religuos genealogy programs that cannot deal with cycles in a graph representation of a family "tree" - as abhorent as fathers having offsring with daughters may be it's a reality that must be dealt with in order to correctly document Pharohs, Royalty, and various families from the backwoods. In the same manner it's just poor software practice to restrict fields for Sex: to a simplistic two value entry when clearly the real world is different to that imained or desired.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- raxxorraxor 4y agoI think that allows the conclusion that sex is binary. 1 in 2000 people are born with limb defects and still humans remain a bipedal species. You can still add it to the passport and use different titles and whatnot. But the science is pretty clear about why and how many sexes there are. There are some plants and animals that can change sex if the environment forces them to, but humans don't have such mechanisms. Guppies and weed come to mind, perhaps there is an ancestor of humans that could do that as well.
- soco 4y agoYou are right, yet the society is struggling exactly with what to add to the passport. And if you think about, why exactly do they need the gender/sex in the passport at all, in the age of biometrics? Isn't this a moot discussion? People fighting about a useless point, that's all what I see.
- thrown_22 4y agoWe're not. We're struggling with the decision of letting a one handed man identify as two handed and vice versa. The utter most ridiculousness of this mental gymnastics is calling women "womb carriers", that the sex treated as a baby incubator would have a problem with this is beyond some people apparently.
- jl6 4y agoI imagine border control find it helpful to have sex on the passport because in 99% of cases it’s an easily observable identifying characteristic.
- Hitton 4y agoSame logic could be used to say that: No, humans ackchyually don't have 46 chromosomes, because you see these rare mutations or defects can cause them to have different number. Sometimes exceptions are just that, exceptions.
- soco 4y agoFine, the discussion is only what we do about the exceptions? Sweeping them under carpet is not okay - exceptions are still citizens of the country and entitled to the same rights. What if there's a one born with two heads, should the country force them to chop one off because the passport has only room for one picture? Even if it's only one person, that person has the same right to travel freely as anybody else, so it needs a solution.
- blueflow 4y agoThat a classification exists does not imply everyone has to comply to it. Either you classify as female, or you classify as male, maybe both, maybe neither. I don't know if you observe that too, but when i ride in the tram, i see individuals who neither pass as male or female. Not due to queerness, its because they have ambiguous bodies and don't perform their gender via their clothes or makeup or something like that. I'd argue that gender nonconformity was always there.
- wizofaus 4y agoThat's the solution then - Male & Female should be checkboxes not radio buttons.
- unglaublich 4y agoSaying that sex is not binary because there is <0.02% intersex prevalence is exactly the type of ideological mental gymnastics that the author aims at.
- AvocadoPanic 4y agoThat paragraph does not describe the frequency of 'non binary' people. It describes the frequency of chromosomal sex appearing inconsistent with phenotypic sex or where phenotypic sex is indeterminate on observation due to rare pathologies. It's biology not ideology.