3 ms·
Ask HN: If something of yours was just flagged and it shouldn't be
If you see someone's post has been flagged or is dead you can vouch for it, but if your own post is flagged and you think it is wrong that it should be - so wrong that you think it is damaging to the community if content of this nature should be flagged - what do you do?
- superchroma 4y agoHope people like what you posted enough to save it, I guess.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoif somethings get flagged really quickly, like someone with an agenda wants to get rid of it, that can be difficult.
- brudgers 4y agoThe agenda is keeping HN HN.
- robin_reala 4y agoYou email the mods: there’s a contact link in the footer.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoah ok, thanks, never thought to use that.
- night-rider 4y agoIf the post is political flame-bait it usually gets flagged. That's not what HN is for. Anyway if the story is serious enough it usually surfaces to the front page typically under a new guise or covered by another news outlet. The truth rises to the top.
- brudgers 4y agoIf the story of concern is the Salon article about Christian homeschooling, my gut wouldn't consider it "necessary for HN's health" because my gut leads me to believe that the intersection of fundamentalist Christian homeschoolers and HN'ers is small (though I believe a bit of overlap exists) and therefore the article is unlikely to cause changes in child rearing techniques. That leaves it mostly in the preaching to the choir category at best and an attractive nuisance for commentators in the average case. I ask myself what are people supposed to do with it other than get upset one way or the other? I mean the article has sparked deep passions in you. Good luck.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agoMaybe, I guess I feel it's a reasonably big social issue covered in depth and if you can't discuss those because somebody gets upset then I start to think hey, there's something slightly unhealthy in that. I mean I have had things flagged in the past that I thought, huh, some people are real delicate about their feelings and didn't complain but I think this seems a bit weirder - maybe because of the religious angle, but the article does hit more than just religious homeschoolers. on edit: actually no it didn't spark deep passions in me, I live in Denmark so I don't have problems with homeschooling. I thought, uh interesting I post it. Then I saw quick traction and then flagged and I thought WTF? Who would flag that unless... huh, well I just wasn't expecting not to be able to discuss stuff on HN because Christians were offended. It seems somehow... wrong.
- brudgers 4y agoLiving Denmark, do you have a dog in the fight? Living in Denmark, what experience do you have with a constitution that prohibits state religion? Posting things that are going to make people upset is a trolling behavior. Not saying your post was trolling, only pointing out it was flagged dead by the community. Maybe because there’s plenty of internet — as in almost all the rest of it outside HN — where people can’t wait to engage on the topic.
- bryanrasmussen 4y ago
- brudgers 4y agoIf the story of concern is the Salon article about Christian homeschooling, my gut wouldn't consider it "necessary for HN's health" because my gut leads me to believe that the intersection of fundamentalist Christian homeschoolers and HN'ers is small (though it almost certainly exists) and therefore the article is unlikely to cause changes in child rearing techniques. That leaves it mostly in the preaching to the choir category at best and an attractive nuisance for commentators in the average case. I mean what are people supposed to do with it other than get upset one way or the other? YMMV. Good luck.