4 ms·
The interesting thing for me about the past are how present the human frailties are, which inform both the past and the present. Woodrow Wilson was naive. You'
by ggm 4y ago
The interesting thing for me about the past are how present the human frailties are, which inform both the past and the present.
Woodrow Wilson was naive. You're telling me there's no naive politicians any more?
Charles Dickens personifies "do as I say, not as I do" and we're not allowed to remark on Victorian hypocrisy as it informs contemporary mores?
Who made you the history police? You want to tell people not to pull down statues? Or, only the ones we could judge by civil war era morals?
Sure. If it's an essay do what your teachers ask. Out here in the unreal world, we draw comparisons all the time.
(I am the proust reader and the dreyfus affair reader who posted a Trump reference above)
- Cupertino95014 4y ago
- ggm 4y agoThat isn't all I said, and that isn't all I think. Stop writing ad hominem.
- Cupertino95014 4y ago> Who made you the history police? You want to tell people not to pull down statues? I think you were the one who started ad hominem. I just suggested treating the past as the past and you got offended.
- ggm 4y agoI think you wrote with more malign intent and used language to dismiss my comment. You're right: it IS an asinine comparison and said better by you, I might have acknowledged it. I've been assured by others I write ad hommy and I will take it on the chin, but I suggest you take that lesson too. You made a put down. You didn't reflect on any other part of what I said, you used "trope" as a dismissive, contextually put-down phrase. Historians in historiography debate the approach to the past. Framing the past in terms of present day issues is normal. Dreyfus echoed in French politics beyond the early 1900s and the path through Vichy, the pre Vichy antisemitic popular press, the popular front, postwar politics, right down to Le Pen is an example of there being no time contemporary politics in Europe is not heavily informed by the past. What has happened in America in the press and in the polity is going to echo in domestic and international politics for just as long. The one thing you cannot accuse Trump consistently of is Antisemitism. That aside parallels are everywhere.
- ggm 4y agoThe original comment being taken out, I remark that they made some valid points.