4 ms·
You don't have an absolute right to arbitrary speech. I can't, for instance, do a public reading of a copyrighted work. I don't see why this case requires cons
by vkou 4y ago
You don't have an absolute right to arbitrary speech. I can't, for instance, do a public reading of a copyrighted work.
I don't see why this case requires constitutional review any more than, say, the concept of copyright.
- yieldcrv 4y agohave you ever noticed how legal analogies online often have fundamental flaws? the first amendment to the constitution does not modify the original constitution, specifically article 1 section 8 of the constitution where by Congress has the power to enact laws to “promote the progress of science and useful arts, by securing for limited times to authors and inventors the exclusive right to their respective writings and discoveries" if you think of another analogy let me know
- vkou 4y ago> have you ever noticed how legal analogies online often have fundamental flaws? Yes, they do, and none have more flaws than people trying to equate <speech plus behaviour that is not speech> with <speech>. > the first amendment to the constitution does not modify the original constitution Where in the first amendment does it say anything of the sort? It's a pretty short one, only one sentence long, but I can't seem to find it. When two parts of the document contradict eachother, it's not at all clear to me why you are giving precedence to the older one. To me, it seems that the more recent document should be the one that carries more weight. But if we're going to go with the oldest one, I'd remind us that American law is based on precedents made in English common law, long before the United States was founded. Perhaps we could plumb millenia-old legal cases for precedents that the constitution and its amendments should not be overriding... And besides, speech is a fundamental human right, far more important than the development of arts and science. You can't have the latter without the former.