4 ms·
Proust's writing of the explicitly Jewish character Bloch in "lost time", has anger and inner conflict which I think speaks to his own emotions. The casual anti
by ggm 4y ago
Proust's writing of the explicitly Jewish character Bloch in "lost time", has anger and inner conflict which I think speaks to his own emotions. The casual antisemitism of others, speaks to to his experience. Bloch is distinctly unlovable and has characteristics of the of-the-time antisemitic tropes. Swann is an inferred jew. It's an indistinct quality, and he is definitely damaged goods in the story arc. I would think Proust identified with bits of both Bloch and Swann.
The Dreyfus affair speaks to present time in "fake news" but also, in the division lines inside parties where a commitment to truth overrides other concerns. Cheney has little in common with the democrats. She just had a personal Rubicon crossing moment. A man who is antisemitic, finds evidence of a miscarriage of justice against a Jewish officer, exposes it and is banished to an outpost in Tunisia is a literary/historical example of the fate Cheney is bringing forward.
Most of the people in the center of the Dreyfus Affair are opportunists. Even Zola. Can we not see elements of this in Trumpism and current politics?
Guy Chapman's book on Dreyfus is the factual one I enjoyed the most. It's older, there may be better more recent appraisals. Robert Harris captures the feverish spying between the armed forces of the time, and competition between agencies inside the state. Even "Papillon" has its Dreyfus moments, Henri Charriere writes of the devils island prisoners making souvenirs to hawke to the credulous- each said to be "once belonged to Dreyfus"
Some of the factual elements of the detective story in Dreyfus are strongly filmic: the paper tests in the fakes are Hitler-diaries level crude it becomes blindingly obvious it's a mishmash of real and faked writing. The cynical double dealing of the agencies offering plea bargains knowing he's innocent to save face.
Dreyfus served his country post rehabilitation in WW1.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nl 4y agoGood comment. I was going to point to the Robert Harris book too and the clear parallels with fake news. I'd add the current popular blaming of "the elites" by populist politicians has uncomfortable echos too. I also like this piece in the linked article: On one side were the Dreyfusards who defended reason and believed that France’s identity was defined by the abstract principles of equality and liberty. On the other side were the anti-Dreyfusards who deified unreason, convinced that France’s identity was rooted in la terre et les morts—the soil and the generations of dead buried in it.
- ggm 4y agoThe Terre and Les morts side, that's where Vichy had roots.
- tarakat 4y ago> the Dreyfusards who defended reason and believed that France’s identity was defined by the abstract principles of equality and liberty. This makes sense as long as you don't think about it for longer than 30 seconds. Is every country, every person, striving towards the abstract principles of equality and liberty then "French"? Did being French hold no meaning when they were still a monarchy? Was everyone on the wrong side of the French revolution then not French, but some other nationality? And is Jewish identity likewise meaningless outside of a commitment to some abstract principles (and if so, which ones?), or do they, unlike the French, get to define it with other criteria, such as kinship and shared history?
- WastingMyTime89 4y ago> Did being French hold no meaning when they were still a monarchy? Absolutely none. People were first and foremost from their region and each region had its own laws, customs and often language. What French view as the French identity very much is a post-revolutionary idea which was mercilessly spread through the eradication of regional cultures and languages and the standard curriculum by public schools during the nineteenth century.
- pyrale 4y ago> What French view as the French identity very much is a post-revolutionary idea which was mercilessly spread through the eradication of regional cultures and languages and the standard curriculum by public schools during the nineteenth century. While there's no doubt that unspeakable horrors were done in the name of forging a collective narrative later on, it's also wrong to claim that's the origin of the french identity. During the _états généraux_ people who had a strong regional bond also sought to collaborate and build alliances outside of their group (e.g. the _club Breton_ [1], which grew into the _club des Jacobins_). Collaboration and common interests forged a new identity overlapping existing identities. If this process hadn't happened, there would never have been new revolutions happening simultaneously across France in the 19th century, way before the 3rd republic's schools opened. That process is pretty similar to post-revolution US colonies growing (and figuring out the details, and, at times, arguing about it) a new sense of common future on top of their existing independent identity. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_Breton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Club_Breton
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoUmberto Eco's The Prague Cemetary touches on this too (and a lot of other interesting stuff).