3 ms·
Yes...but various scaling issues & quantum weirdness & a load of other miseries were ramping up (with each shrink) long, long before 3nm. That's part of why th
by bell-cot 4y ago
Yes...but various scaling issues & quantum weirdness & a load of other miseries were ramping up (with each shrink) long, long before 3nm. That's part of why the auto industry can't "just build a fab" for the ~30x larger feature size that their chips need.
- jrockway 4y agoI don't think that's what's stopping them building factories for outdated processes, rather it's "after you clear the backlog, there will be no high-margin items to produce". So everyone is just waiting instead. You could make a microcontroller on a 3nm node if you wanted to, but first you'd have to design a new core, and then tell people to pay $100 per chip instead of $0.01. TL;DR: the chip shortage is an economics problem, not a physics problem.
- bell-cot 4y agoAccounts vary, but the chip shortage looks like it will end up costing the auto industry ~~$10 billion in profits. If any major automaker could "just build a fab" - in the sense of "the physics & engineering of ~90nm chip manufacture are pretty simple & cheap, so $250M and 6 months will get us a good-enough fab", then at least one automaker (or A-list supplier) would have done so. If a new fab paid for itself 10X or more before the backlog cleared - no sane CFO would much care whether it was worth keeping open after that. (Edit: Yes, trying to read things in a different way - "weird quantum artefacts" at 3nm have nothing whatever to do with the automakers' problems.) (Edit2: Here is the point which I was originally trying to make: "Chip manufacturing, even at 3nm x ~30 = ~90nm, is still extremely difficult. That fact is a big part of why the automakers did not attempt chip manufacturing, even at ~90nm.")
- jrockway 4y agoWell, I don't think the logistics of 90nm chip manufacture are simple or cheap. It's still pretty high tech stuff, people aren't doing it in their garage. I don't know why automakers didn't engage their partners here to expand manufacturing. I am sure they asked, and the companies that can build 90nm fabs decided not to. Maybe it doesn't make sense after the backlog is cleared, maybe they like the higher prices? And if a car company wanted to start manufacturing chips themselves, they'd have to hire engineers, license patents, work out bugs, etc. and the risk is that the shortage is completely gone after you do all of that. (And, all this during a pandemic. If they wanted to use wood to build the physical building containing the fab, there was a shortage of that. So, a lot of problems to solve, and 10 billion dollars starts looking like a small number.)
- xenadu02 4y agoThe problem for anyone wanting to build an older generation fab is cost. It costs (within an order of magnitude) the same to build a modern fab as it does to build one for a process 1-5 generations back, maybe more. You have a roughly similar backlog for equipment too. For your troubles you get far fewer chips per wafer so your cost per chip is higher. And the chips are slower and use more power. That makes it much harder to get any kind of payback on a depreciating asset that only gets more out of date. You also risk demand for your new 45-nm or 90-nm fab dropping off toward zero in 10 years. Historically older fabs would see a drop-off in business as new chips were designed for new processes so as time went on there was more and more capacity available for cheap on the older nodes. That cycle is and has been slowing down though so there isn't much slack even for older fabs. I'm not sure where the market will end up. If the current shortages are a temporary backlog + hoarding then things will work themselves out within 1-3 years and anyone starting lots of fab construction risks bankruptcy - something that has happened multiple times in the past as keeping a fab idle is equivalent to burning it down so you end up having to dump chips at cost or even a small loss. On the flip side if the recent disruptions are merely accelerating an existing trend then anyone kicking off fab construction stands to make a lot of money.