4 ms·
I’d rather a world where anyone and everyone is free to write stories about these characters as they wish. There is no sane framework for using state violence
by sneak 4y ago
I’d rather a world where anyone and everyone is free to write stories about these characters as they wish.
There is no sane framework for using state violence to enforce property laws over who is allowed to write stories over fictional characters. These characters don’t belong to anyone.
- Asooka 4y agoWhat do you think about separating author's rights from copyright? That is, separate the right to distribute copies from the right to make derivatives?
- simmerup 4y agoThe problem is that Tolkien was an exceptionally good story teller with a clear idea of his universe. These remakes however get made by people being paid to spin out low tier content based on the IP that Tolkien painstakingly created. They’re coasting on his work and will tarnish his creation just to make a quick buck. It’s a shame. They should make their own IP instead, but of course that’s too risky in the pursuit of profit.
- optimalsolver 4y agoI believe Tolkien envisioned people adding their own works to his mythology. At least that's what I remember from reading his biography some years back.
- DocTomoe 4y agoWell, yes, and no. > In 1966 a fan of his stories wrote to him detailing a 'sequel' to The Lord of the Rings that he planned to write. Tolkien forwarded the letter to his publisher denouncing 'this young ass' for his 'impertinent contribution to my troubles' and asking for their lawyers to write a suitably-worded letter refusing permission. [1] I can't help but wonder if Tolkien, if he was alive today, would think of modern writers "working with his material" in similar terms.
- permo-w 4y agoI think you’re slightly confusing the right to write stories about these characters, and the right to sell your stories about these characters. I’m not fan of copyright laws either, but this is a misrepresentation
- djbebs 4y agoIt's not though.
- permo-w 4y agoit is. you’re perfectly allowed to write stories about any characters you want, doing anything you want, you’re just not allowed to sell them
- TheCoelacanth 4y agoNot just sell them; you're not allowed to share them with other people. Non-commercial fanfic often slides under the radar, but it is not legal except in the unusual case where the copyright holder has given explicit permission.