5 ms·
Some remakes are better (Wizard of Oz, Ben Hur), most are worse (The Mysterious Island). But none destroy the books, so don't worry about it. Though I am surpr
by WalterBright 4y ago
Some remakes are better (Wizard of Oz, Ben Hur), most are worse (The Mysterious Island). But none destroy the books, so don't worry about it.
Though I am surprised that with all the wealth of books out there for inspiration, how bad Hollywood movie plots are.
I saw a preview of The Call of the Wild remake, where the sled dogs are racing away from an avalanche. The whole thing looks like a Disneyworld ride. That's not the theme or point of the story at all. Too bad.
- findalex 4y ago> Some remakes are better (Wizard of Oz, Ben Hur) I'll have to disagree :). The only remake that was better to the original is John Carpenter's "The Thing".
- mrob 4y agoWhich are your favorite versions of The Wizard of Oz and Ben Hur? I've only seen the famous versions (1939 and 1959 respectively), which are both remakes.
- findalex 4y agoThanks for the correction - I was in fact talking about those two versions. I’m glad no one was putting the most recent Ben Hur dumpster fire over the classic.
- gertrunde 4y ago"Man on Fire"? (The 1987 original is rarely seen).
- croes 4y agoScarface?
- WalterBright 4y agoYeah, that remake was better!
- WalterBright 4y agoYou haven't seen the silent Wizard of Oz. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0016544 https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0016544 or the 1929 Ben Hur. Yes, the sea battle and chariot race in the 1929 version were great, but the rest needed a remake. The remakes after the 1959 version were all "what were they thinking" pointless. Jackson's "Lord of the Rings" remake was much better than the earlier animated version. Jackson's "Hobbit" trilogy was just unwatchable. It seems like after the huge success of LotR, everyone around Jackson said nothing but "yes sir, yes sir, three bags full sir!"
- macintux 4y ago> Jackson's "Lord of the Rings" remake was much better than the earlier animated version. It lacked the immortal “Where there’s a whip, there’s a way” marching song from the animated Return of the King, so that’s debatable.
- 5555624 4y ago"The Maltese Falcon" -- Huston's version, with Bogart, is much better than the pre-code 1931 version.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoBut they will left me with a bad taste in the mouth. Somebody is taking a dump of something I cherish, with no care for its beauty and with money as a priority. It feels like somebody broke my trust or some social contract and walked away with the benefits and little consequences. It may sound stupid, and it's definitely irrational since it's just a movie, but sometimes after I see this kind of action, I experience it as a personal insult for some weird reasons.
- dalbasal 4y agoWell... Novels tend to be written one person. They get written at that person's pace. Sometimes authors stop for years, then return to books. A lot of them have tons of uncompleted chapters, scenes and such sloshing around. Films are a group effort. They're produced by a company. They hire people, set schedules. All that results in different strengths and weaknesses. Thematic consistency or artistic integrity tend to be strengths of the solo artist. Hence the difference in quality between novel and film story quality. Also, a lot fewer films get made. That means there are a lot fewer people who get to try, and the chances of exceptional quality goes down.
- throwaway4aday 4y agoI think you're forgetting the role of the editor when it comes to publishing a book. Novels without editors are more often than not incomplete, rambling, and inconsistent. Perhaps a veteran author could pull it off but that would be due to the time they've spent in dialogue with others over the course of several publications allowing them to internalize an editorial critique of their own work.
- dalbasal 4y agoSure. Also co-authors, advisors, friends and all sorts of contributors. That said, the author is the sun and editors' role is to help authors write their book. The editor is not under the impression that it is their book.
- gertrunde 4y agoYou'd be surprised. One of the best things about books is that it triggers the imagination, every reader imagines a slightly different version of the characters and settings. Once a visual portrayal exists, it's quite difficult to not 'see' that character in your imagination as that version, be it Daniel Radcliffe, Ian McKellan, Sean Astin, or whoever. Not that it "destroys" it as such, but it does affect/influence it.
- Freak_NL 4y agoIn the case of Harry Potter (as a series) that's intentional though.
- smoe 4y agoTrue, but you don’t have to watch the remakes or adaptations. One doesn’t have to run to the cinema the first day instead wait from reviews. E.g I never watched the new Ghost In Th Shell movie because the 1995 anime is one of the most influential films I have seen as a kid and I don’t want to meddle with those memories. Similarly I skipped most movie adaptations of book I liked. There are enough great movies to choose from.