5 ms·
There was an article a while ago that said that American history since the civil war made much more sense if you assumed the South won, and made a reasonable ca
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
There was an article a while ago that said that American history since the civil war made much more sense if you assumed the South won, and made a reasonable case for them actually winning the peace, even if they technically lost the war.
I'd guess a similar argument could be made for the Nazis.
It's easy to look back and think the North had our modern values, and were fighting against 19th Century racists, when really it was (broadly speaking) 19th century racists vs 19th Century racists, so it's not surprising that the 19th century racists won.
Similarly, Nazi Germany wasn't being fought by modern liberals, it was being fought (from the west) by people who were generally more positive about Hitler destroying trade unionists than they were about the Russian Revolution deposing monarchs.
So, it's not really a surprise that the corporate-rich-military complex 'won', because they were on both sides. Though for a few decades afterwards, the average man in the street was needed to fend off wars, so got treated a little better than before, which could have seemed like massive and inevitable progress.
- vt85 4y ago[dead]
- evol262 4y ago> There was an article a while ago that said that American history since the civil war made much more sense if you assumed the South won, and made a reasonable case for them actually winning the peace, even if they technically lost the war. Do we have enshrined slavery and a system of states' rights so strong that the national-level government apparatus is vestigial? No? Then the South didn't win. This is awful revisionist history for the author to sound "smart" purely through cynicism. You could make the argument that the fundamental mistake Americans made was in assuming that Reconstruction (aborted as it was) made enough of a dent that after a couple of generations, it would vanish. Then again for the civil rights movement in the 60s. It's become clear enough that American never "solved" the problem of getting everyone to agree on what rights and liberties the Constitution protects, but that's not the South winning, that's just complacency. That isn't the South winning, it's the nature of government. Without "permanent revolution" which constantly keeps issues at the forefront to change their state of affairs, they are eroded. If you wanted to make another cynical, smart-sounding argument, it would be that rights in America make much more sense if you assume that conservatives are Trotskyists. The conservative party (Democratic, then Republican after the party flip) never accepted that the status quo was the final state of affairs. > I'd guess a similar argument could be made for the Nazis. Did the Nazis get Lebensraum, depopulate the East, form a 1000-year Reich, return the "Germanic people" to their ideal state as farmers on the land, etc? No? Then they did not win. > It's easy to look back and think the North had our modern values, and were fighting against 19th Century racists, when really it was (broadly speaking) 19th century racists vs 19th Century racists, so it's not surprising that the 19th century racists won. This is an argumentum ad absurdum when there were concrete differences between the factions. > Similarly, Nazi Germany wasn't being fought by modern liberals, it was being fought (from the west) by people who were generally more positive about Hitler destroying trade unionists than they were about the Russian Revolution deposing monarchs. As above. It was also being fought by people who were initially unwilling to believe that another European conflict would be prosecuted so soon after the last one -- a war which France's population numbers still had not recovered from -- at a time where information was far less democratized. It is not a reasonable position to assume that the West knew the extent of Nazi Germany's crimes or activities, particularly before the war. Even where intelligence reports gave some indication, it was harder to verify. > So, it's not really a surprise that the corporate-rich-military complex 'won', because they were on both sides. Though for a few decades afterwards, the average man in the street was needed to fend off wars, so got treated a little better than before, which could have seemed like massive and inevitable progress. There was not a corporate-rich-military complex on either side. The Nazi economy's only "complex" was plunder with "pie in the sky" budgeting from every direction which the financials did not support. The West developed a strong military-industrial complex only after the war, and even then, there was a strong push that the fruits of that labor should be free to the public. Eisenhower's warning was meant as a canary in the coalmine, not a statement of how things already were. Do not say "which could have seemed like massive and inevitable progress" and devalue the accomplishments made and gains achieved. Progress is not inevitable, but the decisions made (the NHS was founded while the UK was bankrupt, Johnson's passage of the Civil Rights Act consciously surrendered the presidency, etc) and the sacrifices/struggles of the litany of people involved in the Civil Rights movement in the US, codification of many rights by the Warren Court, and a million other things. It was not an illusion. It was a not a completion, either; like Jim Crow appeared post-Reconstruction, the "emergency" mindset faded from the public eye, and some common acceptance of the notion that it was "solved" now pervaded the national consciousness. That we have taken these as a given rather than something which must be constantly asserted does not mean they did not happen, that it was window dressing to ensure a supply of soldiers (the overlapping timelines of the Department of Defense realizing that drafted troops were nowhere near as effective as volunteer troops and the Warren Court expanding guaranteed rights is undeniable), or that it was an illusion. It means only that manipulative actors can follow the same playbook as Goring's famous Nuremburg quote from Nuremburg of "why of course the people don't want war...", or Niemoeller's "first they came for..." eligy
- ZeroGravitas 4y ago> There was not a corporate-rich-military complex on either side. https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/how-big-business-bailed-out-nazis https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/how-... How Big Business Bailed out the Nazis > Hitler was named Chancellor in late January 1933. He called for elections in early March. With less than two weeks left before the vote, Herman Goering sent telegrams to Germany’s 25 leading industrialists, inviting them to a secret meeting in Berlin on February 20, 1933. Attending the gathering were four I.G. Farben directors and Krupp chief Gustav Krupp. Hitler addressed the group, saying “private enterprise cannot be maintained in a democracy.” He also told the men that he would eliminate trade unions and communists. Hitler asked for their financial support and to back his vision for Germany. > According to Robert Jackson, the former Supreme Court Justice and chief U.S. prosecutor at Nuremberg, “[T]he industrialists…became so enthusiastic that they set about to raise three million Reichsmarks [worth about $30 million today] to strengthen and confirm the Nazi Party in power.”
- unity1001 4y ago> Though for a few decades afterwards, the average man in the street was needed to fend off wars, so got treated a little better than before Its more because the USSR literally won the war and became a superpower and invalidated the "Socialism cant work - they will come down crashing any minute" Interwar propaganda that was done by the capitalist establishments in the West to argue against social and economic reforms for better conditions. WW2 ended, USSR not only won but also became a superpower, lifting its people from mud huts to apartments, from illiteracy to space. Nobody could make any argument against reforms anymore so the left in the West got some time to breathe and push reforms forward. For a brief time, people in the entire West lived in better standards than ever before. Eventually forgetting that the living standards that they enjoyed were not hard-won rights that were based on left wing principles, but instead 'gifts' given to them by capitalism. Then Reagan and Thatcher happened and gave them the capitalism they wanted.
- wbl 4y agoThe Soviet system meant famine in Ukraine, mass expulsions of poles, and being kept in with barbed wire and landmines.
- unity1001 4y agoSoviet state implemented food rationing everywhere to help the famine in Ukraine. And, at the same time the Soviets had famine, the US also had famine during the great depression. Except, Hoover government did absolutely nothing about it, leaving it to the 'free market' to solve for ideological reasons. The amount of people perished during the period is unknown. If the same formula that is being used for calculating 'deaths' in socialist states is applied to the great depression US, the death toll comes around a 7 million people.
- the_third_wave 4y agoWhat 'history' books did you get this alternative fiction from regarding the Holodomor [1]? The Soviet state as personified by Stalin was the main cause for the depths of despair and depravity experienced in Ukraine. If you can leave back that 'history' book I'd suggest doing so, otherwise use it to start your stove this coming cold winter - you'd still be better off than those who Stalin and the Soviet system of collectivisation followed by annihilation sentenced to starvation. [1] https://www.britannica.com/event/Holodomor https://www.britannica.com/event/Holodomor