3 ms·
Yet, median income [0] and HDI [1] both at the macro level and at the prefecture level are comparable to Brazil [2][3] and lag behind both Russia [4][5] and Mex
by alephnerd 4y ago
Yet, median income [0] and HDI [1] both at the macro level and at the prefecture level are comparable to Brazil [2][3] and lag behind both Russia [4][5] and Mexico [6][7].
There is no denying the amount of growth the service sector in China has seen, yet a lot of this growth and development is among a sliver of the population living in better developed regions such as the various coastal prefectures. Beijing, Tianjin, Guangzhou, Shanghai, etc can be treated as developed, but what about the hinterlands such as Sichuan, Ningxia, Hunan, Guangxi, etc? This middle income trap is not a good thing by the way - I take no joy pointing this harsh truth out because this means hundreds of millions of PRC nationals are stuck in less than ideal economic positions.
Also, if we are talking about the value chain, Brazil is very high in the ONG (Petrobras, Odenbrecht), Aeronautics (Embraer), Automotive, and Defense (Odenbrecht, Embraer) value chain thanks to economic policies in the 90s and 2000s that are comparable to those the PRC has started adopting in the past 10-15 years.
[0] http://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t20220118_1826649.html http://www.stats.gov.cn/english/PressRelease/202201/t2022011...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_administrative_divisions_of_Greater_China_by_Human_Development_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_administrative_divisio...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Brazilian_federative_units_by_Human_Development_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Brazilian_federative_u...
[3] https://agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br/en/economia/noticia/2017-02/brazils-national-average-household-income-capita-40016-2016 https://agenciabrasil.ebc.com.br/en/economia/noticia/2017-02...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_federal_subjects_of_Russia_by_Human_Development_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_federal_subjects_of_Ru...
[5] https://tass.com/economy/1301957 https://tass.com/economy/1301957
[6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mexican_states_by_Human_Development_Index https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Mexican_states_by_Huma...
[7] https://www.efe.com/efe/english/life/mexican-households-have-an-average-of-3-8-members-843-in-monthly-income/50000263-2666718 https://www.efe.com/efe/english/life/mexican-households-have...
- senttoschool 4y ago>Yet, median income [0] and HDI [1] both at the macro level and at the prefecture level are comparable to Brazil [2][3] and lag behind both Russia [4][5] and Mexico [6][7]. This is the present. It does not mean China is a middle income trap nation. It continues to grow and advance in innovation. Also, China's GDP PPP per capita has already surpassed Brazil. GDP PPP is a much better measure of stand of living than GDP/capita. The biggest factor in whether a country stays in the middle income territory is innovation. China is innovating. In some areas, it's already leading.
- alephnerd 4y agoGDP and GDP PPP both quantify production, not income and living standard metrics. While there is often a correlation between production and rising living standards, it is a lossy indicator that fails to take into account inequality and differing regional CoLs. For this reason Median income plus HDI is the standard metric used in developmental economics to gauge QoL, as they give you insights on access to healthcare, education, inequality, and other metrics critical to the functioning of societies. Countries can have cutting edge industries AND still lag behind in development - Brazil (Defense, Aerospace, ONG, Automotive), South Africa (Defense), Turkey (Defense, Automotive, ONG), Mexico (Defense, Automotive, ONG), Russia (ONG, Defense, Aerospace, Automotive), Malaysia (Automotive, ONG, Electronics), etc are all countries that are major innovators and even leaders in STEM/innovtion heavy industries, yet still have significant issues with spreading development across their countries. The PRC is facing a similar issue, and it is a hard nut to crack - I can't think of a single middle income to upper income economy that didn't also 1. receive a massive subsidy from either the EU (southern Europe, eastern Europe, Ireland) or the US (South Korea, Israel, Taiwan) 2. have a small population (<30mil at time of transition) It is harder to lift a nation of 400 million poor (using PRC poverty definition) people than to lift a poor nation of 30-40 million. Also, this same trap that China is in is something that India, Vietnam, Indonesia, and the Phillipines will face in 20 years
- senttoschool 4y ago>GDP and GDP PPP both quantify production, not income and living standard metrics. Purchasing power parity (PPP) allows for economists to compare economic productivity and standards of living between countries. https://www.investopedia.com/updates/purchasing-power-parity-ppp/ https://www.investopedia.com/updates/purchasing-power-parity... >Countries can have cutting edge industries AND still lag behind in development - Brazil (Defense, Aerospace, ONG, Automotive), South Africa (Defense), Turkey (Defense, Automotive, ONG), Mexico (Defense, Automotive, ONG), Russia (ONG, Defense, Aerospace, Automotive), Malaysia (Automotive, ONG, Electronics), etc are all countries that are major innovators and even leaders in STEM/innovtion heavy industries, yet still have significant issues with spreading development across their countries. The PRC is facing a similar issue, and it is a hard nut to crack - I can't think of a single middle income to upper income economy that didn't also Brazil does not lead in Aerospace, ONG, Automotive. South Africa does not lead in defense. And so on. They do not possess technology that other countries depend on. For example, Embraer's revenue in 2021 was 4.2 billion. Puny compared to Airbus' 52 billion. If Embraer stopped operating tomorrow, the world would not notice. We're talking about actual innovation and a technology advantage. You mentioned that Mexico leads in automotive. What? Mexico does not have any cutting edge automotive technology that other nations depend on. Mexico is a hub for car manufacturing because it's close to the US and provides cheap labor. They do not produce any car tech that other countries cannot produce. Real innovation is something like China's CATY new car battery which outcompeted Tesla's 4680 battery. https://medium.com/predict/tesla-is-about-to-lose-its-tech-advantage-5a6cb9161a55 https://medium.com/predict/tesla-is-about-to-lose-its-tech-a... Before Tump's ban, Huawei was set to provide 5G technology to the UK, a country that could not produce 5G equipment on its own. A true middle-income country could never do this.
- dirtyid 4y ago>This middle income trap is not a good thing by the way One of OG researchers who coined the term believe phenonmenon is overstated, to the point of not being useful or existing at all. Fundementally, middle income trap is not a good concept in evaluating PRC because even according to the original middle income analysis countries with proper industrial policies designed to move up value chain (like PRC) is likely continue out grow developed countries and in PRC's case, close capability gaps. It's less about being trapped within arbitrary per capita bracket (which PRC is set to to reach upper income by years end anyway) and more about industrial stagnation that would theoretically lead to economic stagnation. Reality is PRC as you recognize is almost like two countries, rich developed coastal that is still rapidly developing, and developing (really neglected) interior. This segregation was by design (Deng's let some get rich first policy), but that "sliver" living in T1 region is ~200M people, which is about Japan, South Korea, Taiwan combined. And really one should include another 200-300M T2 cities due to industrial synergies. Essentially you have a 500M strong rapidly developing country that is spilling out comparable STEM graduates as OECD countries combined while rapidly moving up value chain in every industry, not just a select few like in Brazil. This is the component of PRC that is globally competitive and building up comprehensive national power to the point of becoming pacing threat with US, even if it's dragged down by the interior poor. Just look at record youth umemployment which is absolutely not something to brag about but reflects just how much oversupply of talent resulted from education reforms 20 years ago meanwhile PRC moving up every research and innovation index controlled for quality and have indigenous industries in almost every sector, many of which are increasingly competitive. Even with demographic crisis looming, rich PRC is really just getting started because it is increasingly oversatuated with talent for moving up value chains. Yeah there's still 600M undereducated poor that can't really be integrated into modern economy, hence common prosperity wealth transfer programs. Think of it as rich high-growth high-income PRC giving handout / economic aid to lower income PRC, not enough that rich PRC stops growing, but just enough that poor PRC isn't spiraling in subsistence and ready to rebel. Ultimately it's useful to think of PRC as massive developed China supporting massive low income China. It's better to have a country with 100 people where 50 rich people can build advanced tech but 50 are stuck being poor farmers then a country with 100 people with equal wages that can only make shoes or farm. Now consider India with 1400M people has 20% of PRC GDP... and while a drain, it really does not take crippling amount of resources relative to PRC GDP to subsidize 600M poor. Last time I did the math, if PRC spends 6% of GDP / 1 trillion per year, it can double income of the 600M poor on 1000rmb per month to 2000rmb. Which isn't great but enough to maintain stability especially if spread out over multiple years so people percieve they're getting richer YoY.