8 ms·
Inaction on Climate Change Could Cost the US Economy $14.5T by 2070
- epicureanideal 4y agoThat’s all? That’s half a year of GDP. Vs 50 years of investment in climate change reduction?
- gotoeleven 4y agoYeah lets print 14.5T and then stop having to hear about it! Modern monetary theory says this should work.
- water8 4y agoThose people are starting to realize China pranked them pretty good
- stormbrew 4y ago3c by 2100 seems on the optimistic end of something that appears to be a non-linear process, though. Especially since we have yet to meet even a single global emissions reduction target. Kinda feels like they picked a number that would be alarming enough to spur action, but not as alarming as a more realistic "if we continue to fail to do literally anything" number that would be taken as scare mongering.
- aliswe 4y agoyou think gdp is on a receivables account somewhere or something?
- whb07 4y agoI’d like to see this same report circa 1970: “Inaction will lead to an ice age costing $X by 2020” meanwhile there’s another thread here about a “Contrarian VC” investing in climate change…
- dgs_sgd 4y agoExactly. It's hard to take any prediction more than 5-10 years into the future seriously. Not because the predictors are being insincere or deceptive, just the inherent inability for prediction models to account for unknown unknowns.
- civilized 4y agoPredictions of the actual future are hard, but predictions of the future we will encounter if we stay on the path we're on can be very straightforward and reliable. If I move a shovel full of dirt to the same place in my backyard every day for 20 years, I'm going to have a big pile of dirt there. It's the same for climate. If we keep dumping CO2 into the atmosphere, physics says we're going to warm the planet. It's a more complex system than the dirt pile, but no reasonable person thinks some unknown unknown is going to randomly overturn that and cause an ice age (other than possibly nuclear winter). We can see the warming signal from CO2 in history and we can reasonably project the future as well, if current emissions continue.
- rileymat2 4y ago> If I move a shovel full of dirt to the same place in my backyard every day for 20 years, I'm going to have a big pile of dirt there. Not that I disagree with your general point, But this is why prediction is tricky, because unexpected flooding and your prediction is false.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago> Predictions of the actual future are hard, but predictions of the future we will encounter if we stay on the path we're on can be very straightforward and reliable This is completely false. We are not interpolating with climate science, we are extrapolating. That is why the variance in the models is so wide (and expands rapidly). That variance, also, only applies to the known mechanisms: when a new important factor shows up, that can cause the predictions to be very wrong. This happened with ocean acidification in the early 2010's - the climate models had predicted increasing temperature, but it didn't materialize because the oceans were absorbing a lot more CO2 than we thought. In your example, an earthquake, a tornado, a flood, a strong storm, another person stealing your dirt, or even a heavy wind can make your projection false. You can keep doing the same thing, but you will have no idea how big that dirt pile will be 20 years from now.
- akomtu 4y agoThis number, or any other number, is a lie, which only discredits the climate change initiative. An honest estimate would be a 2-sigma range, e.g. $4..24T with 95% probability with such and such assumptions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- joemazerino 4y agoA bunch of numbers from a consulting firm pitching their ESG consulting services. FUD
- anon22334556 4y ago$14 trillion in 2070 will buy you enough hover gas to get you out of the tri-state free trade zone, and a beverage from the starbuxks trade union™
- butmuh 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackeraccount 4y agoHow much will action on climate change cost? The implication from the article " ...the United States economy could gain $3 trillion" seems to be 11.5 Trillion?
- savant_penguin 4y ago$300b/year doesn't sound so bad
- spullara 4y agoThat is a lot of jobs!
- ccooffee 4y ago> If global warming reaches around 3°C toward the century’s end, Deloitte’s analysis indicates that economic damages would grow and compound, affecting every industry and region in the country. I'm betting we overshoot +3c by a fair bit. Given how little progress has been made (emissions are still _accelerating_), I'm at least pleased to see some resource that doesn't merely talk about +1.5c. We've passed that point already. The IPCC's 6th report estimates that if we merely burn the GHGs that are easily accessible via our existing mines, oil rigs, etc, we're headed to +2.5c. I really hope that Deloitte's report here does some good by giving financial numbers to people who only care about the numbers. (But I doubt it. Very few people with ANY decision-making power will be alive in 2100. "Why worry? I'll be dead.")
- wilg 4y agoDoesn't look like GHG emissions are still accelerating: https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions https://ourworldindata.org/co2-emissions
- ccooffee 4y agoYour source looks at 2020 emissions, which is TRUE, but 2020 was covid shutdowns. I've seen somewhat-reliable estimates of 2-7% reduction in CO2-equivalent emissions. (If you look at 2019, it was remarkably about equal to 2018 after many years of increase.) But 2021 was the biggest (full year) of emissions ever, more than covering the 2020 decrease. I don't know of any resources that track quarterly emissions, so I don't know if we can see whether 2022 is on-pace for another record year. Perhaps the price of oil reduced usage enough to reduce emissions this year compared to last, but I won't hold my breath.
- wilg 4y agoRegardless of whether it's another record year overall, I don't think there's evidence that GHG emissions are accelerating. GHG emissions are dropping year-over-year in developed nations, and developing nations will follow. https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/carbon-co2-emissions https://www.macrotrends.net/countries/USA/united-states/carb...
- MaxHoppersGhost 4y agoThat’s it? Seems like it might be easier to spend money to mitigate the effects of climate change rather than stop climate change itself. There is probably a sweet spot between carbon reduction and climate change effect mitigation that optimizes the total cost.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoBalancing this against the cost of whatever "green new deal" would be required to get there, it sounds like serious climate change mitigation is not worth it at all. Also, it's important to note that changes in GDP correspond to human lives: increases in GDP affect longevity, birth rates, and rates of accidental death.
- missedthecue 4y agoSo if we do nothing it will cost like 1% of GDP? Really?
- alfor 4y agoDeloitte is able to predict the climate in 50 years? In 50 years we will have a massive population collapse, the US have been below replacement level for 50 years. China is even worse. Prepare yourself to see massive employees shortage getting worse and worse. The only thing keeping population aflot is longevity extension but 80yo don’t produce or consume much.
- civilized 4y agoWhy so skeptical of Deloitte's climate prediction and so confident in your population one?
- jeremyt 4y agoBecause demographics are very predictable and the climate is less so.
- civilized 4y agoIf we take that as true, then either the top commenter or the UN is utterly incompetent to perform this very predictable prediction. Because the UN predicts steady US population growth over the next few decades, not a collapse. The Census Bureau predicts similarly. I can't find any serious prediction of imminent collapse.
- alfor 4y agoTrue, the population is aging (people live longer) and birth rate is collapsing. The result is that it’s not apparent when you look at population. But aging is having a massive effect on the economy, the job sector, etc. At some point it’s going to collapse, but because we have been below replacement for a long time it’s not going to stop anytime soon. Look at Japan, Italy to see what is coming (they are a bit ahead) Last year japan lost 800 000 of population. At some point the japanese culture will disappear if they don’t start having babies (really not happening at the moment) I heard that in Japan they sell more adult diaper than baby diapers...
- bArray 4y agoAs others have commented, $14.5 trillion USD (even with inflation) is nothing compared to the US's current outgoings. What I _never_ see costed is the other side - what negative cost will the climate policies have on GDP? I imagine that number to be far greater. For example: Great, you increased fuel tax and got less people driving. Now people can't get to work, deliveries are now too costly, the cost of living increases because even basic items like food need to be transported to the store, with costs given directly to the consumer. The single most concerning thing is that no politician appears to be doing these calculations. There is no open discussion about viable climate policies that don't crush the middle and working class into poverty.
- pseudobry 4y agoAn enlightening book I read on this topic is "False Alarm: How Climate Change Panic Costs Us Trillions, Hurts the Poor, and Fails to Fix the Planet" by Bjorn Lomborg. The book explores the cost of: doing nothing to fight climate change vs doing everything to fight climate change vs doing something in the middle that optimizes global GDP (the book uses GDP as a "human welfare" metric). My biggest take away from the book is that regardless of global temperature increases through the end of the century, global GDP is still projected to grow A TON. But because of the temperature increase, global GCP will grow _slightly_ less (like a few % less) that it otherwise would have. The wrong policies could cost GDP growth more than the temperature increase will.
- klyrs 4y agoIf we wipe out the poorest 50% of the population, they hold less than 1% of the wealth. Is GDP right metric?
- pseudobry 4y agoAnnual GDP of a country != the current sum total net worth of its population. Deleting the poorest half of the US population would destroy the annual GDP, which is built on the labor of said population. Theoretically, as the GDP of a nation grows, so does the quality of life of its population through better access to everything money can buy. It kinda doesn't matter how many billionaires there are if the rest of the population is still able to buy air conditioners, health care, sturdier houses, pay taxes, and generally afford the things that make the climate the least of their worries, as there are super diminishing returns on quality of life past a certain income level (all other arguments against billionaires are outside the scope of this comment). Developed countries are quite well equipped (as in they're rich enough) to be able to adapt to the changing climate as needed. They can buy air conditioners, build dikes, choose not to build houses in areas prone to climate disaster, etc., all if which is insanely cheaper than attempting to reduce global temperature (though that's not an argument against any attempt to reduce global temperature). Making under-developed countries richer allows them to stop doing the "worser" things that aggravate climate change and make their populations unhealthy (like burning wood for a lot of their energy needs). (This comment is just an elaboration on the arguments in the book I mentioned—not me being an expert.)
- greggeter 4y ago
- lancewiggs 4y agoInaction could lead to no society or economy to speak of. These reports are not grounded in science, and the science includes potential outcomes that, driven by continued inaction, create an environment where humans and other creatures and plants struggle to live.
- frank_bb 4y ago
- ThinkBeat 4y agoWith the new "climate/inflation/healthcare" bill the plan calls for investing in green power as well as increasing fossile fuel production. I have read several news articles that claim this is the new normal and it is realistic. Given the energy shortage now, and countries restarting coal, restarting gas, and restarting nuclear it is the reality on the ground now. Of course, most goals set in Paris and Glasgow are shot to hell. If this spreads to other nations, we need to recalibrate what type of goals we set. was
- water8 4y agoActing out of fear could cost the US Economy everything.
- bvoq 4y agomisery should stimulate the economy if anything. more suffering => more needs that can be met by entrepreneurs.
- kurupt213 4y agoIt’s laughable that people still think this is something that human intervention can stall without the entire planet going back to a Neolithic lifestyle. The focus needs to be developing ways to mitigate the impact. Climate is never static. One major geologic event can do more climate harm than hundreds of years of human industry. Commercial whaling probably did more climate harm than anything we’re doing now because it broke the iron cycle that is vital to plankton blooms