3 ms·
Unfortunately, I don't believe it can be fixed at the legislative level. It is horrific that the checks-and-balances are so deeply in conflict with a thumb on t
by jfengel 4y ago
Unfortunately, I don't believe it can be fixed at the legislative level. It is horrific that the checks-and-balances are so deeply in conflict with a thumb on the scale in favor of the status quo, but any tweak you do ends up as either "tyranny of the majority" or "tyranny of the minority".
The issue, I believe, is that Manchin was engaging in legitimate disagreement. I don't particularly like it, but it's the kind of thing envisioned by democracy. The problem is that he was pulling out his legitimate disagreement in a context where absolute 100% consensus was required, because 50% of the Senators disagreed without even any attempt at legitimacy. Not a single one would even discuss common ground.
They wouldn't do that because they were told not to, by their constituents. That was the platform they ran on, and their voters approve.
Democracy has gotten jammed up, because lots of people want it to be jammed up. They didn't send a directive of "here are the things we care about and here are the things we are willing to negotiate about". They said "Do not negotiate about anything." At this moment, one of the few even willing to suggest negotiating stands a very good chance of losing her party's nomination.
I don't have a hard time believing one Senator is so intransigent. I have a hard time believing that such a huge fraction of the country is so intransigent that all of the focus comes down to that one man. But it is very clearly the case.