4 ms·
Is There a Curse of the Fields Medal? [pdf]
- gwern 4y agoVery surprised to see no attempt at discussing regression to the mean other than the quickest possible throw away on pg2, when it is so pervasive and must be operating to at least some degree in any result of the form 'after filtering on extreme event Y, variable X decreased/increased!' Most of the data seems pretty silent on this. (Yes, yes, the two groups look pretty similar temporally in raw # of papers before Fields, but you don't get a Fields for simply publishing a lot - by definition the Fields medalists' papers were different from and better than the non-medalists, and that's why they won.)
- dchftcs 4y agoRegression to the mean is ruled out by comparing against strong contemporaries, whose number of papers produced kept growing on average. This group of strong contemporaries was not selected by looking at the number of papers, but instead by looking at the pool of strong mathematicians selected for other prizes.
- CloseChoice 4y agoYou are right, but it is not ruled out entirely because they used Wolf and Abel prize in the contenders group, which are awarded for a lifetime of work in mathematics and therefore biasing the contender groups.
- gwern 4y agoAnd, as I already pointed out, the non-award-winners must by definition be different from award-winners and cannot control for unobserved baseline differences. Even more so if those prizes are, as is only sane, intended to reward different things than what the most prestigious prize in the field already rewards...
- nequo 4y agoFigure 2 shows increased “cognitive mobility” after receiving the Fields medal. This suggests that the story in the number of papers and the citation counts is not regression to the mean but switching to a new area where the medalist is less experienced.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoHow worried should you be that getting a Fields medal might destroy your research career? So, not what I feared the title suggested and one graphic suggests Fields medalists live on average longer than mere contenders. RIP Maryam Mirzakhani, who died like 3 years after becoming the first woman and first Iranian Fields medalist. Happily, this does not appear to be a trend. https://news.stanford.edu/2017/07/15/maryam-mirzakhani-stanford-mathematician-and-fields-medal-winner-dies/ https://news.stanford.edu/2017/07/15/maryam-mirzakhani-stanf...
- Syzygies 4y agoDestroying one career is not the same as destroying a field. Mathematicians like to believe the likely apocryphal tale that Nobel didn't endow a prize for math because the likely first winner was sleeping with his wife. Nevertheless, the Fields medal distorts math far less than Nobel prizes distort the sciences. Mathematicians pursue math in defiance of the far greater rewards of other paths. I know at least nine Fields medalists and many near misses. Unlike the Nobel prize, neither the quest nor the realization of the Fields medal turned anyone into an ashpile.
- pyuser583 4y ago> Mathematicians like to believe the likely apocryphal tale that Nobel didn't endow a prize for math because the likely first winner was sleeping with his wife It’s certainly apocryphal. Alfred Nobel never married.
- crygin 4y agoThat you know of -- it's possible he was secretly married, and his secret wife was sleeping with the likely first winner of a Nobel prize in mathematics. Unlikely, yes, but the tale is not certainly apocryphal ;)
- rytill 4y agoGoogle gives the following definition of apocryphal: > (of a story or statement) of doubtful authenticity, although widely circulated as being true. So it seems to be certainly apocryphal.
- BMc2020 4y ago
- rurban 4y agoHe had no secret wife, but 3 non-secret official affairs. The last one with Sophie Hess lasting for 18 years, in which she had a second lover. https://oe1.orf.at/programm/20190122/540398/Die-geheimen-Liebesbriefe-von-Alfred-Nobel https://oe1.orf.at/programm/20190122/540398/Die-geheimen-Lie... The rumor is that his first love interest in Russia Anna Desry preferred the mathematician Franz Lemarges.
- Aperocky 4y agoGreat essays, shows that Fields Medal is doing its desired effects [personal opinion after reading]. For those that didn't read until the end, recipient of Fields Medal had a far greater "Cognitive Mobility" in which they opened new fields of research. Those fields may as well be dead end, and even if they aren't their production in terms of papers are probably slow to ramp up. But those are the research we need as compared to certain fields, where the amount of papers being churned out arguably have a negative effect.
- lostinroutine 4y agoThe article uses "new field" as a relative term -- a field that the researcher is not an expert in. > A question [BD14] had to address in this connection is: what constitutes a brand-new direction? Again MathSciNet guides the answer. For each pair of the 73 Mathematics Subject Classification numbers, the authors worked out the likelihood that a paper in one area is referred to by a paper in another area. Thus, for instance, they see that 35 (Partial Differential Equations) is closest to 58 (Global Analysis)and 76 (Fluid Mechanics) but furthest from 08 (General Algebraic Systems) and 19 (K-theory). Borjas and Doran deem a topic brand-new if it is not among the 15 closest to the researcher’s original area. This is a conservative choice and probably underestimates the cognitive mobility
- nl 4y ago> With one exception, only people with a Ph.D. in mathematics have received Fields medal Who was the exception?
- axolotl_raja 4y agoEd Witten, Ph.D. in physics, 1976
- nl 4y agoThanks!
- whycombinetor 4y agoOr maybe, after receiving the Best Mathematician of the Year (Under 40 category) award, since your desire for social recognition of your supreme genius and success is now undeniably fulfilled, you start to realize that you can adopt a new healthy focus on some other aspects of life too, so your late career publications and fame burn less intensely than your supernova early career?
- rurban 4y agoReviewing the Fields paper at https://scholar.harvard.edu/gborjas/_publications https://scholar.harvard.edu/gborjas/_publications (2015) (wrong link in the review) https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/gborjas/files/jhr2015.pdf https://scholar.harvard.edu/files/gborjas/files/jhr2015.pdf
- belter 4y agoNumber of Fields medalists at each award year (Award years occurring every four years): 2,2,2,2,2,4,4,2,4,3,3,4,4,4,2,4,4,4,4,4 - The total sum is 64. An even number and a power of 2 - The only two odd numbers are equally distanced from the beginning and end of the sequence - Until the first odd number sequence A279401 - From second odd number sequence A321319 Mathematicians don't like odd numbers? :-)
- gtsnexp 4y ago...recipients feel the “weight of expectations” and so publish only papers that they consider “worthy of a Fields medalist”... This sentence is probably not only anecdotal but could well be the premise that explains the phenomenon discussed in this article.
- CloseChoice 4y agoI am missing error bars here. The analysis is looking at 64 individuals and a unknown number of contenders. For such small samples I would expect the uncertainty to be quite high.