4 ms·
> When was housing not an investment? Housing was never an investment before recent decades, with an emphasis on the housing bubble. Housing tracked inflation
by pessimizer 4y ago
> When was housing not an investment?
Housing was never an investment before recent decades, with an emphasis on the housing bubble. Housing tracked inflation for 400 years.
https://thegoldobserver.substack.com/p/amsterdam-real-housing-prices-highest https://thegoldobserver.substack.com/p/amsterdam-real-housin...
edit: the history of US house prices is that they strictly tracked inflation, then with government subsidy right after WWII, housing prices jumped up, then stayed flat at that new level for the next 50 years, then the turn of the millennium happens and housing becomes an investment (after a stock market crash.)
- kgwgk 4y ago“In terms of total returns, residential real estate and equities have shown very similar and high real total gains, on average about 7% per year. Housing outperformed equity before WW2. Since WW2, equities have outperformed housing on average, but only at the cost of much higher volatility and higher synchronicity with the business cycle. The observation that housing returns are similar to equity returns, yet considerably less volatile, is puzzling.” https://www.frbsf.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/wp2017-25.pdf https://www.frbsf.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/wp2017-25.p...
- carom 4y agoThe US was a brand new country that was mostly empty. Look at England for some historical data.
- smcl 4y agoOk but they also provided a link showing how this also applied in Amsterdam, in The Netherlands - a much older and less-empty country.
- kgwgk 4y agoThat link doesn't show that housing was not an investment for centuries, does it? Why wouldn't you consider an investment something that has a relatively stable value in real terms - at least over a long enough period - and also provides a yield?
- smcl 4y agoThe link supports the statement "housing tracked inflation for 400 years". I think the confusion here is the word "investment" is overloaded and could refer to a number of different things regarding property: - you buy the property that you personally will live in - you buy some other property and let it out to tenants or businesses - you are a pension fund, mutual fund, hedge fund, day trader, bank, HFT etc which trades in derivatives based on mortgages The first two have been going on for centuries at some level. The third only really got going at the point house prices completely disconnected from inflation.
- kgwgk 4y agoI agree. That's why the original statement "Housing was never an investment before recent decades" doesn't make a lot of sense and the justification "Housing tracked inflation for 400 years" doesn't support it even it's correct. (Btw, not sure if it was implied but the "you" in "you buy some other property and let it out to tenants or businesses" is often a pension fund or mutual fund.)