11 ms·
Secret talks that could have prevented the Apple vs. Facebook war
- KerrAvon 4y agoWhat war? This is about user privacy. Apple implemented replacement APIs allowing for tracking that doesn’t impinge user privacy. Facebook is just mad that they can’t microtarget you on iOS anymore.
- tmpz22 4y agoYeah Apple’s Board of Executives put all profit motive aside and are sacrificing for our privacy.
- cloudking 4y agoRight.. Apple isn't playing 4D chess to challenge Facebook's Ad business. https://www.axios.com/2022/08/21/apple-advertising-privacy-tracking-iphone https://www.axios.com/2022/08/21/apple-advertising-privacy-t...
- JKCalhoun 4y agoI don't see those as mutually exclusive. Apple seems to believe that a company that values a user's privacy can make a profit from that stance.
- robch 4y ago> I don't see those as mutually exclusive. Apple seems to believe that a company that values a user's privacy can make a profit from that stance. The reason Apple doesn't want targeted third party ads is so that they are the only ones that can sell targeted ads to their users. Their platform, their rules. For now at least.
- threeseed 4y agoApple was never going to add Google or Facebook ads into the App Store or News+. And iOS/OSX users will still see targeted ads whenever they open their browser or third party apps. The apps just need to either (a) ask the user for permission to track or (b) authenticate them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zip1234 4y agoApple nerfed everyone else's ads to grow their own ad business. Apple's version of privacy is that if Apple has the data it is private, but if anyone else does it is not private. Just go read Apple's TOS. They collect browsing history, location data, etc. For everyone else they just put it behind a setting. Not for their own data collection though.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoMeanwhile, Apple collects the same types of user data as Google [1], and wants to grow its advertising business [2]. [1] https://www.scss.tcd.ie/doug.leith/apple_google.pdf https://www.scss.tcd.ie/doug.leith/apple_google.pdf [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-08-14/apple-aapl-set-to-expand-advertising-bringing-ads-to-maps-tv-and-books-apps-l6tdqqmg https://www.bloomberg.com/news/newsletters/2022-08-14/apple-...
- dwaite 4y agoFirst party data collection and use is not the same as third-party tracking. I have relationships with Apple and Google. The line around what data usage is appropriate with those companies somewhat nebulous, and also somewhat a personal decision. For instance - the paper you site shows that Apple and Google send location data from devices to the server. Those devices also both ship with functionality for things like mapping and local weather. So for iOS, you have to approve sharing location data (even for the built-in weather app and maps app) on an app-by-app basis. Android has gotten better about this over the years, but I don't know current state. Facebook is (was) correlating detailed profiles of users who had no relationship with Facebook, through interactions with third parties that were not part of Facebook, and without disclosure. That is a much simpler line to draw. Even then, Apple gave the user choice - and the users almost universally chose not to give that capability.
- lern_too_spel 4y ago> Even then, Apple gave the user choice Interestingly, Apple puts tracking for its own apps behind another setting that ignores the global setting. Unlike its competitors, Apple does not give users a choice about whether to send location data to Apple (if you want to see your location at all) or about whether to send app install and search information to Apple. Apple's devices are worse on privacy on every axis when you consider whether they give users a choice.
- threeseed 4y agoa) Apple does give a choice about whether to send location data. It's in System Services within the Privacy section and consists of 18 checkboxes. Do you have evidence that with all of these disabled they are still capturing location data ? b) How would the App Store even work at all if they didn't store your purchases.
- croes 4y agoIt's about users' money. Apple's take on privacy is the same as FB's. If user data stays at Apple/FB it's private. But that's not privacy at all. Any additional confidant besides the sender and the recipient is a breach of privacy. You wouldn't let it count as respecting privacy either if the post office read all your letters and stored the texts.
- dwaite 4y agoDifferent tiers. Facebook is impacted by third-party tracking - such capturing information and generating profiles for people, even those without Facebook accounts. They would do this via Facebook javascript and Facebook native app SDKs. Apple's solution was App Tracking Transparency - a user consent on whether to provide a handy identifier to use for correlation across apps, and App Store rules which ban tracking using other mechanisms (such as IP address correlation). For apps outside the store (e.g. web apps), the privacy proxy stuff and third-party state isolation/blocking are used to greatly reduce such correlation. For first-party data collection, storage and sharing, there are consents for sharing information from the device (location, contacts, health information, and so on). There is also a privacy label (which App Store rules require to be accurate) on what data collected by an app used, for what purpose, and whether that use is linked to you or anonymized. So a post office app that read the letters and stored the text would say that 'user content' was captured, and whether or not it was 'linked to you'.
- croes 4y agoIt's not about Apps it's about privacy, about the data that Apple gets and stores. It's not privacy if only Apple has it, it's privacy if even Apple hasn't it
- justapassenger 4y agoHow many people do you think make an informed consent decision? 0.001% is my guess. Apple is playing dirty. Less dirty than Facebook, but that’s not a high bar.
- 4y ago
- smoldesu 4y agoAnd how do you feel about the data that Apple collects and stores? Both companies are operated by scumbags who don't give a rat's ass about your personal privacy, it's a 'battle' in the sense that neither company can agree who should profit off of advertising.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoApple, because of their proclaimed fealty to user privacy clearly have the most to lose if they should violate that bond.
- smoldesu 4y agoThey already have. Apple complies with hundreds of thousands of federal data requests every year, they send messages back to HQ every time you launch an app, they help China hunt down religious minorities, they give the FBI access to iCloud data without a warrant, they collect a list of unique identifiers for every photo on your phone, and at the end of the day you're still vulnerable to exploits like Pegasus and RCE through iMessage image decoders. If you think Apple hasn't violated that promise, you must have an extremely selective definition of privacy.
- Apocryphon 4y agoAny company’s “proclaimed fealty” is just marketing copy!
- gloryjulio 4y ago> Apple implemented replacement APIs allowing for tracking that doesn’t impinge user privacy. Just like android?
- workingon 4y agoRegarding below comments, and Apple's desire to enter the ad business and still keeping data/not respecting privacy, that's definitely a bad thing, but I still am really happy Apple did this to Facebook/Zuck. Imagine building an entire business that ceases to be profitable as soon as you can't spy on users. It's entirely corrupt. If you took the same ability away from Apple, they would be fine, because most of their business model is actually trying to provide something of value to the world, instead of profiting off of catalyzing it's downfall like Meta. I wish we could do the same thing to Google.
- colechristensen 4y ago>I wish we could do the same thing to Google. Sell computers with chrome preinstalled with a good adblock extension.
- mlyle 4y agoYou can't, because the Chrome license is personal and non-assignable. If you enter into a contract with them to deploy them on computers, I assume this is precluded explicitly by the terms. You could with Chromium, but that's problematic and annoying in minor ways. (Some of the things consumers value involve Google integrations).
- irrational 4y agoI thought google was changing chrome so that adblockers can’t work anymore on that browser?
- 4y ago
- pmontra 4y agoIs it a one sided war, right? FB can only lose money and Apple can only make more. The best outcome for FB would be to legally deny Apple from blocking ads and keep the status quo. The worst outcome for Apple would be to make only as many money as before without the share they are taking from FB.
- AreYouSirius 4y ago
- colinmhayes 4y agoApple isn’t blocking ads. They’re blocking cross app tracking which was mostly run by Facebook. The apps are still advertising, they just can’t use facebooks profile to target you.
- Patrol8394 4y agoTrue, but one should ask why was cross app tracking allowed to begin with. I think that should have never been allowed.
- bee_rider 4y agoWas it ever specifically allowed? Or was it just implemented by Facebook et al using normal things like filesystem and internet access -- the sort of stuff you'd expect an operating system to provide? The idea that users want to protect information, particularly information held by their account, from the programs they run would probably have been pretty surprising in the days when iOS was first being dreamed up...
- JimDabell 4y ago> Apple isn’t blocking ads. They’re blocking cross app tracking They aren’t even doing that! All they are doing is saying that if an application wants to do that, it has to ask the user first. Cross application tracking is absolutely fine according to Apple as long as the user consents.
- 4y ago
- AreYouSirius 4y ago
- ethbr0 4y agoThere's only one sane outcome of the current shifts in privacy that I can see. Something like FLoC, with - The data stored-in and served-by a neutral, not-for-profit, regulated entity - With user primacy and control of their own data (opt-out, wipe, request copy, etc) You're never going to drag tracking out of Chrome, because Google is revenue addicted at this point. So at least you can keep it out of Google's control.
- irrational 4y agoOr, just use Firefox. It works just as well as chrome, in my experience.
- ethbr0 4y agoThat's not a scalable solution for people who are not me.
- cmeacham98 4y agoWhy not? Firefox is freely available and works on (almost) every platform Chrome does.
- ethbr0 4y agoBecause Mozilla doesn't have USD$250b+ in annual revenue, or ownership of the top web destinations, with which to push Firefox.
- cmeacham98 4y agoPeople who care about tracking will do the research and pick other browsers, people who don't will use Chrome.
- ethbr0 4y agoYes. And I care about decreasing tracking for people who don't care about being tracked, because that's most of the world.
- malshe 4y agoHopefully this one removes the paywall: https://www.wsj.com/articles/inside-the-apple-vs-facebook-privacy-fight-11660317376?st=cvnusdrqm9eceup&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/articles/inside-the-apple-vs-facebook-pr...
- GekkePrutser 4y agoIt did and I thank you!
- 7fYZ7mJh3RNKNaG 4y agoThank you. Cueing mirror keyword for others.
- bluesign 4y agoPeople mixing 2 things: tracking over your apps vs tracking on 3rd party apps are different things. Apples tracking protections ( allow apps to track ) applies to 3rd party apps. Apple’s tracking for ads, applies only to Apple apps. Facebook can track people on their apps ( facebook, instagram, whatsapp etc ) if they want. Problem is about tracking with facebook SDK on 3rd party apps.
- dwaite 4y ago> Facebook can track people on their apps ( facebook, instagram, whatsapp etc ) if they want. Problem is about tracking with facebook SDK on 3rd party apps. Right. Google mostly didn't mind, because they can simply push people a bit harder to log in for Youtube as well as Maps and Search, to build a first-party profile as people do searches and follow results. This is different from building a profile as someone browses the internet, regardless of whether they have a relationship with your company.
- jrm4 4y agoIt's weird-but-unexpected that they seem to frame this a bit as if such a war would have been a good thing to prevent. But usually it's best if these big companies ARE at war as much as possible.
- sonofhans 4y agoIt’s to the benefit of Facebook, and other businesses harvesting and selling access to personal information, to call this a “war.” It’s similar to the modern headline news approach to politics — everything is a horse race, everything is sports. The competition becomes the story, rather than the substance behind it. Calling this a “war” lays bare the views of many who believe this is only two tech giants duking it out over market territory, that the only substance here is the competition itself. It’s just like sports! We can root for our favorites! It shows the fundamentally nihilistic attitude of many capitalists, that every commercial entity is _of course_ solely concerned with making as much money as possible, and that any talk of ethics or principles or honest benefit to their customers is smoke and mirrors. Of course, this is simply untrue. Many businesses do operate at least partly on ethical principle. Many businesses do try to do right by their customers, and not only because of the monetary rewards associated with success. This scares the shit out of some capitalists, though, who want to believe that making money is the highest ethical good to which a commercial entity can aspire. Apple is an inconvenient example for these people. What if what Apple says is true? What if it really does matter to Apple that their customers have privacy? Then we have an example of a financially-successful business which is not operating in the most rapacious way possible, and this throws all sorts of wrenches into their late-stage capitalist fantasies. I’m not demonizing capitalism — it works for me. But the WSJ is definitely the high priest at the altar here, and it seriously fucks with their narrative to even admit that commercial competition can be about anything other than money. Thus it must be a nihilistic “war.”
- SnowHill9902 4y agoA humbling lesson on why you must control your supply chain or have commoditized suppliers. Facebook grew on a commoditized platform i.e. browsers on PCs. But then got pinched on mobile and was too slow to react.
- dredmorbius 4y agoWSJ / Murdoch standing up for Facebook is ... a new look.
- Animats 4y agoWSJ view: if only they'd conspired together against consumers like they were supposed to.
- 082349872349872 4y ago... and here I thought they weren't even supposed to conspire directly. Don't industry majors usually have to conspire indirectly, like by all hiring the same consultants?
- GekkePrutser 4y agoI'm glad they didn't. Apple did the right thing. Still not sure whether they did it for the right reasons but it was 100% the right thing IMO
- pessimizer 4y agoThank god they didn't agree, I don't even think they should be able to talk about shit like this. We should force them to use regulators as mediators.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- neonate 4y agohttps://archive.ph/oKuGM https://archive.ph/oKuGM
- sandworm101 4y agoSecret talks? Conspiracy. Between two market leaders. To settle their differences and thereby reduce direct competition. I understand completely why this was kept quiet. I cannot see any firm dates, but it looks like most of these reported discussions were in 2017-2018, 4+ years back, conveniently long enough enjoy SOL protection against antitrust actions. Who really wrote this piece? Who paid for it? SOL citation: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2011-title15/html/USCODE-2011-title15-chap1-sec15b.htm https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2011-title15/html...
- charcircuit 4y ago>To settle their differences and thereby reduce direct competition How do you reach this conclusion? Businesses working together to increase each of their profits is what every business relationship to strives to be.
- eganist 4y ago> How do you reach this conclusion? Businesses working together to increase each of their profits is what every business relationship to strives to be. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_antitrust_law That's generally the threshold, and without saying as much (in fact, the author of the article seems to miss this), the article suggests that the talks in question came close to cresting that boundary.
- cjensen 4y agoIf Marriott and Best Foods work together to increase both profits, that's not an anti-trust violation just because they work together. The article you cite enumerates a number of categories of violations, but you haven't identified which one you think "working together" inherently violates. My guess is you are talking about Monopolization, but since neither Facebook nor Apple is a monopoly, and since Facebook and Apple do not compete against each other, I'm not sure how that fits.
- 4y ago
- eric4smith 4y agoQuick question... Why would we really want to prevent a war between these two giant companies?